资源描述:
《犯罪心理学6new》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在教育资源-天天文库。
1、Chapter6AssessingCompetencyinCriminalProceedings4AlanA.Abrams,M.D.,J.D.SanDiego,CA1.INTRODUCTION5Thestandardsforcompetencyincriminalproceedingsare,atfirstglance,amongthemostuniformandleastcontroversialinthelaw.Adefendantmaynotbeputtotrialunlesshe"hassufficientpresentabilitytoconsultwithhislaw
2、yerwithareasonabledegreeofrationalunderstanding...[and]arationalaswellasfactualunderstandingoftheproceedingsagainst6him."ThisisreferredtoastheDuskystandardintheforensicliteratureafterthecaseinwhichtheSupremeCourtsummarizedtheFederalstandardfor7competencytostandtrial.InPatev.Robinson(1966),the
3、SupremeCourt4Theauthorwishestoacknowledgetheveryvaluableassistanceofhiswife,KarenGurneck,hiscolleague,ChristineTaylor,Ph.D.andProfessorGrantMorris.5Competencytostandtrialisfrequentlyreferredtoasfitnesstostandtrial,andsotheterms"competency"and"fitness"areusedinterchangeablyinbothpsychologicala
4、ndlegalwriting.6Duskyv.UnitedStates,362U.S.402,402(1960).7Infact,thethenFederalstatute,18U.S.C.§4244explicitlymandatedthisstandard.TheSupremeCourtdecidedthatthetrialrecorddidnotcontainsufficientevidencetodemonstratethatthiswastheactualstandardusedbythedistrictcourtattrial.MiltonDusky,thedefen
5、dant,waschargedwithkidnapping,rape,andtransportationacrossstatelines.HewastriedinFederalcourt.Mr.DuskywasextensivelyevaluatedattheUnitedStatesMedicalCenterforFederalPrisonersatSpringfield,Missouri.Theevaluationsand105106Chapter6heldthatthefailuretoobserveproceduresadequatetoprotectadefendant'
6、srightnottobetriedorconvictedwhileincompetenttostandtrialdepriveshimofhisdueprocessrighttoafairtrial.Thepresentchapterproposesthatthisapparentuniformitybeliesmanyproblemareasoflaw,socialpolicy,morality,philosophy,andpsychology.Examplesoftheseconcernsinclude:theextenttowhichadefendantwithaseve
7、reAxisIIdisorder,particularlypsychopaths,cancooperaterationallywiththeirattorney;thedegreetowhichanimpulsivedefendantcanmakereasonedchoicesamongalternatives,whetheradespondentdefendantwhofireshisattorneyandrefusestoputonadefenseinordertoinsur