资源描述:
《GRE-Arguement 七种常见错误-个人总结》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在行业资料-天天文库。
1、一.经不起推敲的类推(falseanalogy)ThisargumentreliesonwhatmightbeafalseanalogybetweenAandBC.(开头)InorderforBCtoserveasmodelsthatAshouldemulate,thearguermustassumethatallrelevantcircumstancesinvolvedareessentiallythesame.(环境、背景不同)However,thisassumptionisunwarranted.(过渡)Forexa
2、mple,theargumentoverlooksthepossibilitythat…..Perhaps…..(列举各种可能性)Thearguersimplyassumesthat…..buthedoesnotprovideanyevidencethat……areindeedcomparable.Asweknow,the…and…differconspicuously.Itistruethatboth…...butevenhereexistfundamentaldifferences:….(两种东西本身不同)Theref
3、ore,eventhoughthe….provedeffectivein…..,thereisnoguaranteethatitwillworkjustaswellfor…..(结尾)二将因果关系与单纯的关联关系或时间关系混淆起来(confusecausalrelationshipwithcorrelation)TheargumentconcludedbasedonaknowncorrelationbetweenAandB.Yetthecorrelationaloneisonlyascantevidenceofthecla
4、imed“cause-and–effect”relationship.Perhaps…..Moreover,theargumentoverlooksthefactthat….Thearguerhasnotaccountedforthepossibilitythat….Ifthisisthecase,thantheconclusionwouldlackanymeritwhatsoever.三.认为一个群体的特征适用于该群体的所有成员四.认为某条件是某结果的必要和/或充足条件1.要想取得理想的结果就必须按照这种(推荐的)行为去
5、做2.按照这种(推荐的)行为去捉就足以去的理想的结果a)Therecommendationdependsontheassumptionthatnoalternativemeansof…areavailable.Yetnoevidenceisofferedtosubstantiatethisassumption.Admitittedly,…..However,itisentirelypossiblethatmeansotherthanthiswouldalsoachievethedesiredresult.(指出替代选项的存
6、在)Perhapsthedesiredimprovementcouldbeachievedif…..(列举替代选项)Withoutconsideringandrulingouttheseandotheralternativemeansof….,thearguercannotconfidentlyconcludethat…..mustdo…inordertoachievethegoal.(收尾)b)Therecommendationdependsontheadditionalunsubstantiatedassumption
7、that…..wouldbyitselfimprove……(指出不一定能达到目标)Absentevidencethatthisisthecase,itisequallypossiblethat…..Thus,withoutbetterevidencethat……,theargumentremainsunconvincing.(列举可能性一)Evenassumingthat….,thearguerprovidesnoclearevidencethat…..Themerefactthat….hardlysufficestopr
8、ove…….,atleastnotwithoutmoreinformationabout….(让步,列举可能性二)Evenif…..,perhapsadditionalmeasures—suchas…..—wouldalsoberequiredinordertoachieve….objectives.(