资源描述:
《Skocpol - The Rise and Resounding Demise of the Clinton Plan》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在应用文档-天天文库。
1、THERISEANDRESOUNDINGDEMISEOFTHECLINTONPLANbyThedaSkocpolPrologue:Thegreathealthreformdebateof1994endedwithawhimper,ontheheelsofanelectionthatturnedoutthepow-erfulDemocraticmajorityintheHouseandSenateandsentsomeofitsmostinfluentialmemberspacking.Whatrol
2、edidhealthcurereformplayinthisturningofpoliticalfortunes?Wasittheunwittingvictim?Orwasit,infact,thecatalyst?InthispaperThedaSkocpolarguesthatthepoliticalreversaloftheNo-vember1994electionsmightturnouttobeoneofthebiggestturningpointsintwentieth-centuryA
3、mericanhistoryandthat,farfrombeingamerecasualty,theClintonplanandCon-gress’sfailuretoadoptit(oranythingelse)contributedmateri-allytotherevoltoftheelectorate.Thisisironic,Skocpolnotes,becausetheClintonplanwasitselfdesignedasamiddle-of-the-roadcompromise
4、betweenthemarket-basedandtheregulation-busedreformsthathadbeendiscusseduptothatpoint.Thede-miseoftheClintonplanisnotable,shewrites,notjustasanat-temptedpolicychangethat“fizzledout,leavingthesameterrainclearforarevisedattempttosolvethesameproblemsfromas
5、imilarstartingpoint.”Indeed,thewordsandactionsofthe104thCongressearlyinitsfirstsessionsuggestthatthisstartingpointhasbeeneradicatedfromtheAmericanpoliticalland-scape.SkocpolteachesinthedepartmentsofgovernmentandsociologyatHarvardUniversityandhaspublish
6、edwidelyonthepoliticsofU.S.socialpolicymaking,pastandpresent.ShereceivedadoctorateinsociologyfromHarvard.Hermostre-centbook,SocialPolicyintheUnitedStates:FuturePossibili-tiesinHistoricalPerspective,waspublishedbyPrincetonUni-versityPressearlierthisyear
7、.Shecurrentlyisstudyingepisodesofattemptedhealthcurereformacrossthetwentiethcentury.DEMISEOFCLINTONPLAN67henightof22September1993PresidentBillClintongaveastirringspeechtoCongressandthenation,callingfor“AmericatofixaThealthcaresystemthatisbadlybroken..,
8、givingeveryAmericanhealthsecurity-healthcarethat’salwaysthere,healthcarethatcannever1betakenaway.”Millionslistenedtothepresident,andpollstakenrightafterthespeechandoverthenextfewweeksregisteredstrongsupport.“TheClintonPlanIsAliveOnArriv