资源描述:
《intermediate scope in Mandarin Chinese》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在学术论文-天天文库。
1、"IntermediateScope"in(Mandarin)ChineseJi-yungKimUniversityofMassachusettsAmherst1.IntroductionThispaperanalyzesthe"intermediatescope"readingsfortwoclassesofindefinitesinMandarin;theseareconstrualswhereanindefinitephrase,ifanalyzedonaparwithquantifiersthatexhibitscopeproperties,seemsto"
2、scopeout"ofthesyntacticislandwithinwhichitiscontained,whileseeminglytakingscopeunderanotherscopalelement.MandarinChineseofferstwomainclassesofindefinites,indefinitesheadedbyacommonnoun("N-indefs")andwh-indefinites("wh-indefs").Thetwoclassesofindefinitesdifferfromeachotherintheirrangeof
3、interpretations,inadditiontotheirdistinctmorphologicalshapes.Thetwoclassesofindefinitesalsodifferintheconditionsunderwhichtheyallowanintermediate-scopereading.N-indefs,liketheEnglishindefinites,showanintermediate-scopereadingonlyinthepresenceofaboundvariableintheirrestriction,andthuspr
4、ovidestrongsupportforananalysisalongthelinesofKratzer1998,whichsinglesoutvariablebindingasoneimportantsourceofintermediatereading,ratherthanthescope-takingpropertiesoftheindefinitesinquestion.Wh-indefs,ontheotherhand,canreceiveanintermediatescopeconstrualindependentlyofthepresenceofabo
5、undvariable;IarguethattheyshouldbeanalyzedasdenotingsetsofHamblin-stylealternatives,followingShimoyama2001.Bothoftheseanalysesattributetheintermediate-scopereadingofindefinitestosomethingotherthanscope:inthecaseofN-Indefs,itisthebindingofavariableintheirrestrictionthatsimulatedscopeint
6、eraction.Withwh-indefs,itisthealternativestheydenotethatallowforvariation,thuscausingtheillusionofascopeinteraction.Theremainderoftheintroductionbrieflyreviewsthecommonassumptionsaboutquantifierscope,definesandpresentsdiagnosticsfortheparticularconstrualthatisthefocusofthispaper,andint
7、roducesthetwoclassesofMandarinindefinites.§2presentstheconditionsunderwhichanintermediatescopereadingisobservedwiththetwoclassesofindefinites,eachofwhichisanalyzedin§3and§4respectively.§5exploresthepossibilityofunifyingtheseparateanalyses.1.1.TheTraditionalViewOnecommontraditionaltre