资源描述：
《respect for the true history of china 39;s population - to take off the halo population of determinism a text of the response to文档》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在工程资料-天天文库。
1、RespectforthetruehistoryofChina'spopulation-totakeoffthehalopopulationofdeterminismatextoftheresponseto1,removethehalowhoInthe“HistoricalResearch”2002,No.1,wehavetheauthor’s“MalthusiantheoryofpopulationsincetheQingDynastyinChina-AReviewofAmericanscholarsinrecentyears,research”(hereinaf
2、terreferredtoas“Malthusian”),ontheLi-ching,WangFengco-“onequarterofhumanity:MalthusianmythologyandChineserealities,1700-2000”(hereinafterreferredtoas“onequarterofhumanity”),abooktocriticize,andotherAmericanscholarsinrecentyears,researchcomment.Weareinthetextthat:LiQingandotherscholarsatthe
3、macrounderstandingofthehistoryofthepopulationtoignoreChina’spopulationsincethemid-19thcentury,dramaticchangesinthecatastrophic;inmicro-behaviorresearch,onlyapopulationwithlimitednewinformationhasestablishedapopulationofChinesehistoryisnottrueThe“real”;theirsocio-economicconditionsinChinasi
4、ncetheQingDynastymisreadingnotonlyexists,andthelackofexperience;sothattheirnewtheoryisnotabletochangetheacademiccommunitysincetheChinesepopulationsinceMalthus’sbasicunderstanding.[1]OverthesameperiodWangFeng,LiQingpublished“takeoffthehalopopulationofdeterminism-andaboutthehistoryofideasand
5、methodsofPopulationResearch”(hereinafterreferredtoas“removethem”),atext,toourcriticismandcounter-criticism.WangandLipointedout:sincetheQingDynastyinChinamacro-demographicchangesandtheirmicroscopicstudyofdemographicbehavior,andthereisnocausalrelationship;inmicroaspectsofdemographicbehavior,
6、weinterprettheoriginal,citationsandconceptualerrorscommitted20points.Inaddition,theyalsopointedout:Wehaveacademicdiscussionsonthecontrarytotherecognizedprinciplesofcommonsense;weacceptedtheMalthusianpreconceptionsoftheWestonChina’spopulationsincetheacademicperspective;wearethinkingofChina’
7、spopulationhistoryisasimpledemographicdeterminism.[2]Firstneedtoshowthat“Malthus,”atextisthroughtheInternetinChinaandtheUnitedStatesbothbyustocomplete.ThedraftarticlesinMay2001bytheBeijingJointPublishingforwardedtotherelevanteditorLiQing,Lihadtothisarticleinan
