资源描述：
《责任限制案例1》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在工程资料-天天文库。
1、InreOtalInvestments-m/vHKaribanInreOtalInvestmentsLtd.NotReportedinF.Supp.2d,2005WL1588986S.D.N.Y.,2005.July0&2005(Approx.3pages)NotReportedinF.Supp.2d,2005WL1588986(S.D.N.Y.),2005A.M.C.2454Motions,PleadingsandFilingsJudges,AttorneysandExpertsUnitedStatesDistrictCourt,S.D.NewYork.InreOTALINVESTMENTS
2、LTD.,asOwneroftheM/VKariba,forExonerationfromorLimitationofLiabilityOTALINVESTMENTSLTD.,Third-PartyPlaintiff,V.CAPITALBANKPUBLICLTD.CO.,ActinorCarCarrierIAs,Wilh.WilhelmsenASA,WalleniusWilhelmsenLines,ClaryShippingPte.Ltd.,MSTMineralienSchiffahrtSpeditionundTransportGmbH,&MineralShippingCo.PrivateLt
3、d.,Third-PartyDefendants,AUGUSTAASSICURAZIONIS.P.A.,Plaintiff,V.WALLENIUSWILHELMSENLINESAS,etal.,Defendants,ZURICHINSURANCECO.,etal.,Plaintiffs,V.M/VTRICOLOR,etal.,Defendants,No.03Civ.4304,03Civ.9962,04Civ.1107.July&2005.OPINION&ORDERBAER,J.*1Thiscivilaction(consolidatedonAugust27,2004,byconsentofth
4、eparties)hasbeenbroughtbeforetheCourtonamotioninlimineandamotiontodismissaninremclaimbyThird-PartyDefendantsClaryShippingPte.Ltd.,MSTMineralienSchiffahrtSpeditionundTransportGmbH,MineralShippingCo.PrivateLtd.(collectively“ClaryInterestsn).FN1Forthereasonssetforthbelow,theClaryInterests1motionsarebot
5、hDENIED.FN1.InadditiontoClary,Third-PartyDefendantsincludeCapitalBankPublicLimitedCompany,ActinorCarCarrierIAS,Wilh.WilhelmsenASAandWalleniusWilhelmsenLinesAS(collectivelyuTricolorInterests^)・Alsoinvolvedinthismatterarevariousownersofdamagedcargo(collectively"CargoClaimantsv)・I.BackgroundOnDecember1
6、4,2002,theM/VKariba,theM/VTricolor,andtheM/VClarywerenavigatingthroughdensefogintheinternationalwatersoftheDoverStraitsintheEnglishChannel.AstheM/VTricolorovertooktheM/VKariba,thetwoshipscollided,bothvesselssustaineddamagesandtheM/VTricolorsubsequentlysankwiththelossofitscargo.OnDecember20,2002,Plai
7、ntiffandThird-PartyPlaintiff,OtalInvestmentsLtd.("Otal”)，owneroftheM/VKariba,broughtanactionagainsttheM/VClaryforitsallegedinvolvementinthecollision.InconnectionwiththatactionbroughtintheNetherlands,O
