资源描述:
《interexaminer reliability and cranial osteopathy (nortonhartman)外语英文电子书》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在教育资源-天天文库。
1、ReviewINTEREXAMINERRELIABILITYANDCRANIALOSTEOPATHYSteveE.HartmanandJamesM.NortonWeassessthemechanismpurportedtounderliethehealthtreatmentregimelabeled"cranialosteopathy"or"craniosacraltherapy."Wethensummarizeallpublishedreportsoninterexaminerreliabilityassociatedwiththismodality,reanalyz
2、esomepreviouslypublisheddata,andcritiqueUpiedger'sioften-citedstudy.Ourownandpre-viouslypublishedfindingssuggestthattheproposedmechanismforcranialosteopathyisinvalidandthatin-terexaminer(and,therefore,diagnostic)reliabilityisapproximatelyzero.Sincenoproperlyrandomized,blinded,andplacebo-
3、controlledoutcomestudieshavebeenpublished,weconcludethatcranialosteopathyshouldbere-movedfromcurriculaofcollegesofosteopathicmedicineandfromosteopathiclicensingexaminations....forbothpatientandpractitionertobeblindtothegiventhename"craniosacralmechanism"or"primaryclinicalrealitiesisanuna
4、cceptableversionofthe"double-.respiratorymechanism"(PRM)4(p24)andincludesthefol-blind."llowingelements:3(ppI0-11),4(pp51-53),5.6(ppI65-166),7,8(p23)(1)inherentrhythmicmotilityofthebrainandTHEPRIMARYRESPIRATORYMECHANISMspinalcord;C(2)rhythmicfluctuationofcerebrospinalfluidranialosteopathy
5、andcraniosacraltherapTare(3)articular(CSF);mobilityofcranialbones;variantsofahealthtreatmentregimethatorigi-(4)mobilityofintracranialandintraspinalduralnatedwithSutherland.4Physicians(primarilyos-membranes;andteopaths),physicaltherap~sts,occupationaltherapists,(5)mobilityofthesacrumbetwe
6、entheilia.chiropractors,dentists,andotherscurrentlyuseformsofthismethod.Althoughsomepractitionersmakedis-Accordingtothemodel,intrinsicrhythmicmove-tinctionsamongvarioustypesofcranialtherapy,webe-mentsofthebrain(independentofrespiratoryandcar-lieveobservationsrecordedherepertaintoall.Beca
7、usediovascularrhythms)causerhythmicfluctuationsofCSFSutherlandwasanosteopathandbecauseallvariantsandspecificrelationalchangesamongduralmembranes,knowntoushavetheirrootsinhisideas,herewerefercranialbones,andthesacrum.Becauseseveralofthesetothemallas"cranialosteopathy."elem