资源描述:
《sw testing, verification and reliability外语英文电子书》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在教育资源-天天文库。
1、SOFTWARETESTING,VERIFICATIONANDRELIABILITYSoftw.Test.Verif.Reliab.2002;12:195196(DOI:10.1002/stvr.259)Editorial:TheimportanceofempiricalworkforsoftwareengineeringpapersIhavenoticedthatinrecentyearstherehasbeenagrowinginsistencethatsoftwareengineeringpapers,bothinjo
2、urnalsandconferenceproceedings,shouldincludeempiricalresults.Icanrecallatimewhenapaperthathadnewandinterestingideas,submittedtoeitherajournaloraconference,couldbedeemedworthyofpublicationonthatbasisalone.Today,reviewersandeditorsexpectempiricalworktobeincludedinpap
3、erssubmittedforpublication.Thisisnotonlyarequisiteforresearchpapers,butalsoforindustrialpapersaswell,althoughthisempiricalaspectmaywellbeintheformofcasestudies.Thereasonforthisistheneedforvalidationofassumptionsorotherclaims,andtheverificationofresultsinthepaper.Ins
4、oftwareengineering,asopposedtosomeotherfieldsincomputerscienceandengineering,itisoftennoteasytoverifyyourresultsanalytically,andsoanempiricalstudymaybetheonlywaytoprovidesuchverification.Reviewersdonotalwaysinsistonafully-fledgedexperiment,butdorequireatleastalightwei
5、ghtempiricalstudy,stillcarefullythoughtoutandexecuted.Also,mostreviewerswillnolongersimplyaccepttheresultsofempiricalstudyorfullexperiment,butinsistuponsomesortofstatisticalanalysistodemonstratestatisticalsignificanceoftheresults.Ihavebeensomewhatsurprisedbytheneces
6、sityforstatisticalsignificance,butexperimentalresultsthatappearcompellingoftenfailtobestatisticallysignificant;youcantjusteyeballthedataandbeconfidentthatitcouldntcomeoutthatwaybycoincidence.Itendtobefairlytheoreticalinmygeneralapproachtoresearch,andsoyearsagoIwasnott
7、rainedwellinexperimentalapproaches;Iwasintimidatedbytheneedforexperimentsandstatisticalanalysis.NowIrequirethatallmystudentsprovidesomeempiricalstudyintheirMScorPhDresearch,andofteninsistthatfullexperimentsbedesignedandexecuted.Recentlyafriend,LionelBriand,whoisare
8、spectedresearcherinexperimentalsoftwareengineering,congratulatedmeonanexperimentalstudythataPhDstudentofminehadcompleted,andthatIhadpresented.Iwa