资源描述：
《英文结辩稿范式.doc》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在教育资源-天天文库。
1、Thanksforthechairman,pleaseletmegivemybestwishestoeveryonehere.Now,Iwillgiveyoutheconclusionofthiswholedebate.Reviewingallthedebate,it’snotdifficultforustofindthatthreeimportanterrorsmyoppositedebatershadmade.Firstofall,youfailedtoanalysethetopicofourdebate.Ourtopicis“Ifoneisdiagnosedwit
2、hcancer,hisfamilyshouldnottellhimthetruth”.Abouthisfamily!Butyourjustificationstrayedfromthetopic.Youclaimedthatheshouldbetoldthetruth.However,thetellercanbeprofessionaldoctors.Thedifferencehereisthatdoctorsareprofessionalandexperienced.Theremustbevalidandimportantreasonswhyhedoesn’ttell
3、.Shouldn’Anotherpointwhereyoustrayedfromourtopicis“should”.AccordingtoCollinsdictionary,“should”isusedtoexpressobligationandduty.Theobligationofthefamilyistoprovidepowerfulhelptothepatients,butnottoruinhimcollaterallybyinforminghimoftheterminalofhislife.Second,yoursourcesofdataarequestio
4、nable.Wehavestronglyadvisedyoutogivevalidandcanonicalevidencemanytimes.However,youavoiditfromthebeginningtotheend.Youclaimedthatthepatientsmaybemorepositiveafterknowingtheirhealthcondition,butyoushouldknowthatthereisnoquantizationstandardforpsychologicalcondition.Whatkindofevidencedoyouh
5、ave?Justquestionnaires?That’snotprecise.HereIinsistthatifyoustillwantthepublictobelieveyourproposition,pleaseshowustangibleevidence.Inacontrast,wetookcitationsanddatafromthemostauthoritativeorganizationsandjournals,liketheJournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociationsandAmericanAssociationofCli
6、nicalOncology.Third,Again,wefirmlyinsistthatifoneisdiagnosedwithcancer,hisfamilyshouldnottellhimthetruth.Wehavementionedseveralreasonswithcanonicalevidence.Theseevidenceallcomesfromauthoritativeorganizationsandjournals.First,ifthefamilydon’ttellthepatientaboutthediagnosis,thepatient’smoo
7、dwillnotbenegativelyaffectedandtheircancerwillnotbedeterioratedbydepression.Ifthepatientisinformedthathehascancer,hewillbetrappedintogreatdepressionanddespair,whichisharmfultoohistreatment.Itisknowntoallthatwhatmakesusweakisn’twhatwefearof,butourfearitself.Second,thefeara
