资源描述:
《自己的总结+七宗罪之展开》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在教育资源-天天文库。
1、Theargumentthatblablaomitssomeimportantconcernsthatmustbeaddressedtosubstantiatetheargument.Thestatementthatfollowsthedescriptionofblablasimplydescribeswhatblablawilldo.Thisalonedoesnotconstitudealogicalargumentinfavorofblabla,anditcertainlydoesnotprovidesupportorproofofthemainargument.Mos
2、tconspicuously,theargumentdoesnotaddressthecauseoftheproblemofblabla,theuseofblabla,orwhoisinvolvedintheblabla.First,theargumentassumesthatthecauseoftheproblemisthattheA,theB,andtheCareunknown.Inaweakattempttosupportitsclaim,theargumentdescribesblablathatmakesallofthesethingsaccuratelyknow
3、n.ButifthecauseoftheproblemofblablaisthatA,blablawillnotsolvetheproblem.Second,theargumentneveraddressAandhowthiswillaffectblabla’sobjectiveofdoingblabla.IfA,blablawillnotbeavoided.Finally,ifC,theproblemofblablacannotbesolvedbyblabla.Theargumentalsodoesnotaddresswhatwouldhappenintheeventth
4、atD.Becausetheargumentleavesoutseveralkeyissues,itisnotsoundorpersuasive.Ifitincludedtheitemsdiscussedaboveinsteadofsolelyexplainingwhatblablasupposeddoes,theargumentwouldhavebeenmorethoroughandconvincing.开头1、先陈述作者是如何通过某fact来argue了一个conclusion(这步可分为两句,第一句讲作者得出了什么conclusion——inthisargument,
5、theauthormakesaconclusionthat……第二句写第一个fact——tojustifythisconclusion,theauthorpointsoutthat……)2、作者用什么去支持了这个conclusion(第二个fact)3、还有什么其他的fact是couplewith上面的support的(第三个fact)4、指出作者的argument是unconvincing的,有几点criticalflaws。Citingfactsdrawnfromthecolor-filmprocessingindustrythatindicateadownwardtr
6、endinthecostsoffilmprocessingovera24-yearperiod,theauthorarguesthatOlympicFoodswilllikewisebeabletominimizecostsandthusmaximizeprofitsinthefuture.Insupportofthisconclusiontheauthorcitesthegeneralprinciplethat“asorganizationslearnhowtodothingsbetter,theybecomemoreefficient.”Thisprinciple,co
7、upledwiththefactthatOlympicFoodshashad25yearsofexperienceinthefoodprocessingindustryleadstotheauthor’srosyprediction.Althoughtheargumentseemsplausible,itisunconvincingbecauseitsuffersfromtwocriticalflaws.结尾1、总结说作者的argument是不够compelling的2、为了加强结论作者应该提供哪些evidence