Neocleous - Privacy, Secrecy, Idiocy

《Neocleous - Privacy, Secrecy, Idiocy》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在教育资源-天天文库。

1、Privacy,Secrecy,Idiocy*BYMARKNKOCL.KOIJSoNi;ofthesupposedirlucsofliberaldcni()tr;ir'isilsprotec-tionofpri';irv.FromitsI'ootsinthelale-cighlecnl}i-ceiUiir'"'democraticrevolutions"loilsiTisliuuionali/alioninlliearioiisdeelararionsonhumanrii^litsnowinexistence,priacyismootedasa

2、pTiiuipleihalcanheusedlodeientlusffomIhestateandprotectourliberties.Peoplewholioldthis'n_\alsoargueibatsecrecyinpolitiesisahadtbing:tbehigbei~tberlegree(>rsecree'withwbicbtheslalcoperates,theless(lemo(ralicitis.Fromthisperspective,tbedefenseoiindividualprivac)goeshandinbandwitb

3、anattackonslalesecrec.Wehavethentwopoliticalissues—pi~i'aevandsecrecy—thatarebixjughtlogelhertoformafairlysimplebulwell-eslablisbedclaim:thaiademocralicsoeietyisonewithanentit-ncbeddefenseofprivacv(prelerablyina(odiiledconstitution)andoneinwbicbthebareminimnmofslateaftaiisiscart

4、ieflontinseciel.Theseissuesbasereceivedanewleaseonlifeinrecentyearswilbmanyliberaldemocraciesaimingtofhitberentrentbthe"rigbt"lopriae'andlomoetonioie''opeTi"(lesssecrelise)formsofgovernment—tbeBlairand(Hintonregimesheingthemostolwi-ousexamples.Tbesearemovestbatmanonlhel,eflhav

5、epraisedasprogressixe,Tadical,andmoderiii/iiig.Inthisarticle1shallargtiethatdespitetheii~ostensiblyladiealappearan(xdemandsfor"privacv"and"opengo'<:rnnient"areinlaclseerellimitedwbenusedtocballengeibearionsformsofpowerwemaysetonrselvcsagainst.Theselimitationsresultfromdemands

6、ibaiareh(ithhistoricallyand(joliticallynaie.Ibe'arebistori-'•'I'll,inksIIIDavidMnri'.iv.milNukSioiu'loiioiiiiiiciiisonanI'arlii-iihallofihisSOCIALRF..SKAR(;H,Vol.69,No.1(Spring2002)SOCIALRF.SKARCH(alKiiaifinllu'sensethattheoeilo(>kthereas(»nsstatesba'esincetbeirin(ej:)ti

7、(>ubeeneonmiitledtosecrecN:theyaiepolili-(alhnaicinthesensethatthe'hu'intoanessentialKliberalconcepuialapparatns.Ishall(lierefoiebearguingthatIbeap[)arenlohiousnessoftbeajjpealstomorepria(andlessseciec'masksadeepernaiveteibatmisreads(beinateiialnatureoftheslate'scommitmenll

8、ose(recandoperateswithaflawedcon