资源描述:
《The Macroeconomist as Scientist作为经济学家的宏观经济学家 工程师》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在学术论文-天天文库。
1、JournalofEconomicPerspectivesVolume20,Number4Fall2006Pages2946TheMacroeconomistasScientistandEngineerN.GregoryMankiwconomistsliketostriketheposeofascientist.Iknow,becauseIoftendoitmyself.WhenIteachundergraduates,IveryconsciouslydescribetheEfieldofeconomicsasascience,sonostud
2、entwillstartthecoursethinkingthatheorsheisembarkingonsomesquishyacademicendeavor.Ourcolleaguesinthephysicsdepartmentacrosscampusmayfinditamusingthatweviewthemasclosecousins,butwearequicktoremindanyonewhowilllistenthateconomistsformulatetheorieswithmathematicalprecision,colle
3、cthugedatasetsonindivid-ualandaggregatebehavior,andexploitthemostsophisticatedstatisticaltech-niquestoreachempiricaljudgmentsthatarefreeofbiasandideology(orsoweliketothink).HavingrecentlyspenttwoyearsinWashingtonasaneconomicadviseratatimewhentheU.S.economywasstrugglingtopul
4、loutofarecession,Iamremindedthatthesubfieldofmacroeconomicswasbornnotasasciencebutmoreasatypeofengineering.Godputmacroeconomistsonearthnottoproposeandtesteleganttheoriesbuttosolvepracticalproblems.TheproblemsHegaveus,moreover,werenotmodestindimension.Theproblemthatgavebirtht
5、oourfield—theGreatDepressionofthe1930s—wasaneconomicdownturnofunprec-edentedscale,includingincomessodepressedandunemploymentsowidespreadthatitisnoexaggerationtosaythattheviabilityofthecapitalistsystemwascalledintoquestion.Thisessayoffersabriefhistoryofmacroeconomics,together
6、withanevalua-tionofwhatwehavelearned.Mypremiseisthatthefieldhasevolvedthroughtheeffortsoftwotypesofmacroeconomists—thosewhounderstandthefieldasatypeofengineeringandthosewhowouldlikeittobemoreofascience.Engineersare,firstandforemost,problemsolvers.Bycontrast,thegoalofscientists
7、istounder-yN.GregoryMankiwistheRobertM.BerenProfessorofEconomics,HarvardUniversity,Cambridge,Massachusetts.30JournalofEconomicPerspectivesstandhowtheworldworks.Theresearchemphasisofmacroeconomistshasvariedovertimebetweenthesetwomotives.Whiletheearlymacroeconomistswereengine
8、erstryingtosolvepracticalproblems,themacroeconomistsofthepastseveraldecadeshavebee