英语诗歌对比评析

《英语诗歌对比评析》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在工程资料-天天文库。

1、DingyuWang(515370910026)VylOOProfessorThorpe11.22.2015IPreferPoets:PoetsCanDoMorethanBarkingInNovember2011，NotchofficiallycompletedworkonMinecraft1.0,"anopenworldgamethathasnospecificgoalsfortheplayertoaccomplish^(Gallegos),whichturnedouttobeahugesuccess(McCarthy).McCarthyfirstregardsitssucce

2、ssasamysterysinceit'sonlyanindiegamewithoutanyadvertisingbuthefinallypointsoutthatthesuccessisjustbecauseplayers"havefreereintobuild,build,build^Xpar.18).Peopledoenjoythefreedomtothinkandcreate.Ineffect,thesituationisanalogicalwhenpeopleencounterpoems.“WhoIsaPoet"and"AnotherReasonIDon'tKeepaG

3、unintheHouse"aretwopoemsthatbothtakeadvantagesofaudience^imaginationinordertoconveyitsmessage.However,"WhoIsaPoet"providesmorefreedomforaudiencetounderstandandtoimagine,thusgivingamoreeffectiveargument,whileuAnotherReasonIDon'tKeepaGunintheHouse"restrictsaudience^imaginationintheauthor^worldb

4、ygivingadetailedimaginaryscene.Thedetailedreasonswhy"WhoIsaPoet^isbetterthanuAnotherReasonIDon'tKeepaGunintheHouse”willbegraduallyrevealedbyanalyzingthelogos,ethos,andpathosinthosepoems・BillyCollinswrites"AnotherReasonIDorftKeepaGunintheHouse”inanimaginarilynarrativeway,encouragingpeopletosee

5、kjoyamidstsorrow.Inthepoem,theneighbors'dogkeepsbarkingwhichalmostdrivesthespeakercraze・Thenhefallsintohisimaginaryworldwheretheannoyingdogbecomesasoloist.Thestorythatthespeakerusesimaginationtomakeanirritatingdogsofunnytellspeoplenottobestuckbylittleannoyanceandtrytomakelifehappier.Alternati

6、vely,TadeuszRozewiczwrites"WhoIsaPoet”toanswerthequestionwhoisapoet.Hisargumentisthatpoetsarehardtodefine-anyonecanbeapoetundercertaincircumstances.Therefore,heactuallygivesa"vacant”definitionofpoets,andleavestheworktotheaudiencewhoareguidedtodefinetheirownpoets.Thiskindofargumentseemsridicul

7、ousbutactuallyisamoreeffectivewaytoarguesuchill-defineditems-ithasnocompleteargumentinthepoemitself,butithasauniqueargumentonceareaderstarttoreadit.It'sthereaderwhocompletestheotherhalfoftheargument.Althoughthestoryin"AnotherReasonIDon'tKeepa