资源描述：
《How to Avoid the Reviewer’s Axe.pdf》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在学术论文-天天文库。
1、JOURNALOFMICROELECTROMECHANICALSYSTEMS,VOL.12,NO.3,JUNE2003229GuestEditorialHowtoAvoidtheReviewer’sAxe:OneEditor’sViewEditor’sNote:StephenD.Senturiahasbeenamemberofthethatisalsoaminormodificationofalreadypublishedwork.BoardofEditorsforIEEE/ASMEJMEMSsincethejournal’sAlongthewa
2、y,someunusualbehaviorisobservedthatthemod-firstissuein1992andwasnamedaSeniorEditorin1998.ifiedmodelcannotexplain.Theauthorsbelievethattheyunder-Thisexperience,coupledwithhisservicefrom1985–1995asstandwhythisbehaviorisobserved,andwishtoproposetheirtheSolid-StateSensorsEditorfo
3、rtheIEEETRANSACTIONSONexplanation,eventhoughtheyhavenotyetdonethedefinitiveELECTRONDEVICES,addsupto17yearsinaneditor’schair.experimentstoprovetheirhypothesis.Overtheyears,StevehaskeptmentalnotesonthemyriadofproblemsthatauthorshavewithreviewersandhasbeeninspiredII.SENTURIA’SGU
4、IDELINEStocompilethefollowing“advicetotheauthor”aboutwaystokeepreviewerssatisfied;hence,tokeepthem“atbay.”Howshouldtheauthorsthinkaboutorganizingandwritingthispaper?Iproposeasetofsimpleguidelines.ThenamesareAbstract—Basedonhismanyyearsofexperience,aJMEMSed-listedbelow,followe
5、dbysomediscussioninwhicheachguide-itorprovidesguidelinesforauthorsthatwill,iffollowed,greatlylineisexploredindepth:reducetheriskofadevastatinglynegativeresultfromthereviewprocess.Thepremiseisthattherearecertainthingsthatrightfully•(Almost)NothingisNew.angerreviewers,and,oncea
6、ngered,thereviewersbecomeboth•RelyontheBelievabilityIndex.negativeandaggressiveintheirjudgments—hence,theimageryof•WatchforGamblingWords.“thereviewer’saxe”andhowtoavoidit.•Don’tBeaLongfellow.•Don’tPullRabbitsOutofHats.I.INTRODUCTION•MineAlltheGold.•Remember:ReviewersareInarti
7、culateandAuthorsareINCEthisisapersonalcommentary,Iwillusethefirst(somewhat)Paranoid.Sperson,somethingthatnoproperwriterofscientificdis-coursewouldeverdo.AsanauthorofmanytechnicalpapersViolationofoneormoreoftheprinciplesexplainedunderovermy35-yearacademiccareer,Ihavetoooftenfe
8、lttheanx-eachguidelinerisksgettingthereviewerangry(withcause),andiet
