2021考研英语一逐词逐句精讲册

2021考研英语一逐词逐句精讲册

ID:83349182

大小:7.36 MB

页数:37页

时间:2023-08-07

上传者:灯火阑珊2019
2021考研英语一逐词逐句精讲册_第1页
2021考研英语一逐词逐句精讲册_第2页
2021考研英语一逐词逐句精讲册_第3页
2021考研英语一逐词逐句精讲册_第4页
2021考研英语一逐词逐句精讲册_第5页
2021考研英语一逐词逐句精讲册_第6页
2021考研英语一逐词逐句精讲册_第7页
2021考研英语一逐词逐句精讲册_第8页
2021考研英语一逐词逐句精讲册_第9页
2021考研英语一逐词逐句精讲册_第10页
资源描述:

《2021考研英语一逐词逐句精讲册》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在教育资源-天天文库

2021ὃẆ⚪⌲⌲SectionIUseofEnglish,•…૘Fluidintelligenceisthetypeofintrlligrricellialliastodowithshort-trnnmemon,andiheabilitytothinkquickly,logically,andabstractlyinordertosolvenewproblems.!ஹᨵ$%&'(ᙢ*ὃ+,-./⚪Ḅ1ᨵᐵḄ34567Fluidintelligenceisᙢ2ᑗ=>j]⇪ABᔳ?6+F+⊤ihalHIḄJKJ9⛲thetypeofintelligencethathastodowithshort-tennmemory89⛲andMNḄOᑡQ|andtheability[TUJVWXYJZ9⛲theability;89⛲tothinkquickly,logically,andabstractly[TUJVW[Ḅ\L89⛲inordertosolvenewproblems.⌕^_`inordertosolvenewproblemsbTUJVḄᱯdeV஺g_`fluid[flund]n.;ia.TḄ;᧕kḄinldliglnee*[ntehd3?ns]n.;᠗;nodowith....ᨵᐵ;ᜐᳮ;stabstractly[aebstraektli]ad.'(ᙢ૙Ilpeaksinyounga$hiltli

1••••;••૘OnestudyfoundihalmusclelossandtheaccumulationofIxxlyfataroundth<*abdomenareassociatedwithadeclineinfluidintelligence.⚗Ẇ´¥ZµᾙḄ·¸ῳºᾦ¼Ḅᚮ¾ḄᨵᐵOnestudyfound6++QK567¿hatHIḄQKZWfoundḄQthatmusclelossandtheaccumulationofbodyfat...areassociatedwithadeclineÀWXYJZ[9⛲bodyfataroundthealxlomen89⛲ÀWXYJ.9⛲adeclineinfluidintelligence.:g_`muscle*[mAsl]n.µᾙÂÂÃÄaccumulation[a.kjuimja'ieijn]n.ᚮ¾ᱥabdomen[aebdamon]Åῳºbeassociatedwith......ᨵᐵ૙Tliissuggeststhepossibilitythatlifestylefactorsmiglithelppreventordelaythistypeofdecline.Ç⊤È1ឋ,ᓽËÌÍVᨵᐵḄÎÏ1ᨵÐÑ⚜■ᡈÕÇ34Ḅ⊦⌨567Thissuggeststiwpossibility6++Q|thatHIḄ×ØKZ,`ÙÈᵫepossibility89⛲thatlifestylefactorsmighthelppreventordelaythistypeofdecline.g_`possibility*[.posabibti]n.1ឋÂ1delay*[dilei]v.ÕÂÕÂÛÜ•1••L,•૘Theresearcherslookedaldatathatincludedmeasurementsofleanmuscleandabdominalfatfrommorethun4,000nii$l$lle-to-older-age

2Theyfound#+%+&'()hat*+Ḅ&,',.foundḄ&,thatmiddle-agedpeople...scoredworsej<=>,.?@A,!⛲middle-agedpeoplewithhighermeasuresofabdominalfat<=>,.C☢E,!⛲onmeasuresoffluidintelligenceas*+ḄGHE,',.&,'ḄGHE,astheyearswentby.=JKL:score*[skoS#r(]v.ᑖ;Vᳫ஻.ᑖYZᑖgoby#GH(]^_`a૘Forwomen,the*usscMjationmaybeattributabletochangesinimmunitythatresultedfromexcessalxbmina]fat:inmen.theimmunesystemdidnotappeartobeinvolved.de᝕ឋᩭi.jkὶmnopqeῳᾦ]r+sḄtuvᓄ;xdeᵱឋᩭi.tumz{|}ᨵᐸ!⛲thatresultedfromexcessabdominalfat;ihat*+ḄA,'[!⛲changestochangesinimmunity!⛲<=>,.E,Forwomen.<=>,.(1)ḄE,.⊤d-(l)theassociationmaybeattributable(+m+⊤)Iᑡ(2)theimmunesystemdidnolappearlobeinvolved.(+%)|<=>,.(2)ḄE,!⛲inmen,=JKLbeattributableto...npqe....;noᵫe....immunity[imjuinsti]n.tu;t◀excess*[tekses]஺.]rḄ;]Ḅimmune*[rmjuSn]Q.tuḄ;Ḅ@IlishopedthatfuturestudiescouklexplainthesedifferencesandperhapsleadtodifferenttreatmentsformenandᔳyjᩭḄẆoLj¡¢£.ᡈ¥n¦§ᵱឋ¨᝕ឋ©ᩭªḄᶭ¬஺Itishoped(+%),k§®,=ihut*+Ḅ,'.¯°Ḅ,thatfuturestudiescouldexplainthesedifferences|and±²Ḅᑡ%&andperhaps(could)leadtodifferenttreatmentsI<=>,.E,!⛲formenandwomen.=JKLexplain*!iksplem]v.L;iµ;▊µtreatment[triitmant]஻.ᶭ¬Y·ᶭYd¸••••_ºa••••૘Meanwhiletherearestepsyoucantakelohelpreducealxloniinulfatandmaintainleanmusclemassasyouageinordertoprolccllx)thyourphysicalandmenialwell-being.ªG.»Ḽ½Ḅ¾¿Àn¦Á¡ÃÄᩭÅÆÇÈῳᾦÉᏉËᾙ,¦ÍÎÏÐᏉÑ•191•

3and(to)maintainleanmusclemass!⛲|and±²ᑡḄÒ=A®>,youcantaketohelp(to)reduceabdominalfat]ḕᶍᐵm=(which/that)ḄA,'!⛲stepsMeanwhiletherearesteps(TherebeÖSthere*+are+)[[as*+ḄGHE,',.ḄGHE,asyouage!⛲Ò=A®>,.Ḅ×ḄE,inordertoprotectbothyourphysicalandmentalwell-being.=JKLmass*[macs]ØYÙYÚᙽwell-being[welbijirj]ÜᏉÑYÝÞ૙Tluitwohiglihrecommendedlifestyleappn)achesaremaintainingorincreasingyourlevelofaerobicexerciseandfollowingaMediterranean-styledietthatishighinfiberandeliminateshighlyprocessedfoods.Éßà₞ḄâkãäC®§:ÍᢝᡈæᨵçèÒéê;⍳ìᙢî®ïð,ᓽ᤬ᐭôõðᱥᔛøùúðû!⛲ofaerobicexercise<=>,.?@A,!⛲yourlevel]Thetwo…approachesaremaintainin^riincreasingyourlevel(+m+⊤)|and±²Ḅᑡ⊤,andfollowingaMediterranean-styledietihat*+ḄA,'.[!⛲aMediterranean-styledietthatishighinfiber!⛲|and±²Ḅᑡ%,andeliminateshighlyprocessedfoods.⌕ýKLthat*+ḄA,'m⊤þ᪀ishigh᦮ᔠrecommend*[jekamend]vt.₞;aerobic[earaubik]a.ᨵḄ◤Ḅfiber[faiba(r)]n.(fibre);ᑴeliminate*[ihmmeit]vt.....!"ὃ⇋;᣸◀ReadingcomprenensionText1••••()*,•)૘Howcanthetrainoperatorspossiblyjustifyyetanotherincreasetorailpassengerfares?,-.⃩ᖪ12᝞45,-6.ἠ89:;<Ḅᔠᳮឋᕖ@ABCDHowcanthetrainoperatorspossiblyjustifyyetanotherincreaseEFGHI,1J⛲anolherincrease)LJ⛲torailpassengerfares?⌕NOAP)QᱯSᶧUA,ABCDᵫ“ᱯSᶧU+Y᝱[+C+[+\”᪀ᡂ஺:,operator[Dpareita(r)]n.(bcḄ)e⃩ὅjustify*[djAStifai]vt....gh5yet*[jet]ad.ijkfare[fea(r)]n.lmmopἠ8૙Ithasliecomeagrimlyreliableunnualritual,evenrJanuan'thecostoftravellingbytrainrises,imposingusigniGcantextraininlenonthosewhohaveno(>[»lionbuttousetherailnetworktogrttoworkorothensise.qrᡂs)tHiᡭ!•192•

4[Ḅvwxyzv)ᨴ.|}lh~Ḅmᵨ2;<,q⌱1ᑭᵨ,-;ḄᩭᜧḄ᜜.ABCDIthasbecomeagrimlyreliableannualritual:(C++⊤)5agrimlyreliableannuulrilual)LJ⛲everyJanuarythecostoftravellingbytrainrises,[ᙠᑖF£¤¥LJ⛲imposingasigniGcantextraburdenonthosewho¦§ḄI¨A,[J⛲thoseLJ⛲whohavenooptionbuttousetherailnetwork[!I©FªḄ¥]LJ⛲togettoworkorotherwise.:,grimly[gnmli]ad.¬Iᙢ;®ᾓᙢreliable*[nlaiabl]«,±²Ḅ³´µḄritual*[ntJual]n.xy¶xὁ¸¹impose...on...º....(»)¼½....૚Thisyear'srise,anaverageof2.7percent,maybeafractionlowerthanlastyear's,bulitisstillwellabovetheofHcialConsumerPriceIn?૙Why.theargumentgoes,shouldacar-drivingpensionerfromLincolnshirehavel<>subsidisethedailycommuteofastockbrokerfn>mSurrey?@ABCD:!:EFG᪍#I⚞KὁMḄNOPḄ?⌕⊡SG⃬UIḄVἠXY?ḄZ[\]2'^•193

5⛲theargumentgoes,___________1_ᐭWhy,...shouldacar-drivingpensioner...havetosubsidisethedailycommutea'b$.[⛲acar-drivingpensionerfromLincolnshire⛲a'b$!⛲thedailycommuteofastockbrokerfromSurrey?⌕C)*deGᱯgᶧi,ᵫ“ᱯgᶧi+m᝱++op+q+r”᪀ᡂ஺()*pensioner[penjog$r0]n.⚞KὁMὅsubsidise[,SAbsidaiz]v.1wsubsidize0⊡S5xpcommute*[ksmjuit]n.\];yz{|}stockbroker[-stokbraukaCr0]n,Vἠ1ᡈᑶ4XY?૚Equally,thereisasensethatth<,travailsofcommutersintheSoulhEasl,nuinyofwhomwillfaceamongthebiggestrises,havereceivedtoomuchattentioncomparedtothosewhomustendureilierelativelypoorinfrastructureoftheMidlandsandllieNorth.᪵ᙢ.Ay!+976ᓅḄẠḄ\]ὅ,ᓭ\]᩷1Ḅ?☢¢£|¤¥ἠ¦Ḅᨬᜧ©ª4Ḅ«¬X6ᑮr¯ᐵ)⛲Equally,[_ᐭthereisasense(Therebe±²there+is+),that´Ḅµ!¶*·asense⛲thatthetravailsofcommuters...havereceivedtoomuchattention[a'b$.⛲commulersintheSouthEast,whom´Ḅ¸▲$ឋ$.⊡ᐙ·commuters⛲manyofwhomwillfaceamongthebiggestrises,¼½ᑖacomparedtothosewho´Ḅ$J⛲those¾⛲whomustenduretherelativelypoorinfrastructurea'b$J⛲therelativelypoorinfrastructure¿⛲oftheMidlandsandtheNorth.()*travail[,trseveil]஻.«¬5⁎Â5⁎¬Ãcommuter[ka'mju,o(r)]Ä\]ὅendure*[!ndjua(r)]vt.7657Ὂvi.ᢝ.infnislructure*[-infrsstrAktJsCr)]n.ẠMidlands['midlandz]n.(the-)(ÇḄ)!ᙢÈ••Ê¾Ë•••஺However,overthepast12months,thosecoinmulershavealsoex|)enence(lsomeoftlirworstrailstrikesinyears.ᯠÍ,ᙠ¼½Ḅ12GᨴU!@ᓭ\]ὅÐXᔊÒÄÓᩭᨬÕÖḄÄ×£|ØÙ!⛲overthepast12months.laḄÚHowever,...thosecommutershavealsoexperiencedsomeofthe…strikes(+q+r)a'b$;⛲theworstrailstrikes⛲inyears.૙Itisallverywelltrain()j)erat()rstrumpetingtheimpmveinentstheyaremakingtothenetwork,butpassengersshouldl>eabletoexpectabasiclevel(»fserviceforthesubstantialsumstheyarenowpayingtotravel.£|¥⃩ᖪÞßᐸ£|áḄᦋãäå¸æ,çè¤ᳮêëìíᑮdḄîï.ðñòᙠ:óPôõÒᜧö2ᵨ•194

6⛲theyaremakingtothenetwork,Pᶍᐵø1whirh/lhatḄ$,ù⛲theimprovementstrainoperatorstrumpetingtheimprovementsIt:úû!üḄýᔠÿ᪀ḄlItisallverywell++⊤IbutḄᑡ⊤ᢚ2butpassengersshouldbeabletoexpectabasiclevelofservice+,+-./01223Ḅ456789:⛲forthesubstantialsums.ḕᶍᐵ0which/thatḄ?@.:⛲thesubslantialsumsB9:⛲theyarenowpayingtotravel.⌕DEFHI0ḄJᔠL᪀trainoperatorstrumpetingtheimprovementsM=trainoperatorsNHI01trumpetingtheitnprovemenlsḄOPQ0GEFtrumpet,trAmpitRSTUᔿᗲ;Yᔿsubstantial*sabstaenjl஺.ᜧ\ḄU]^_ᜧḄ૚Theresponsibilityforthelatestwaveofstrikesrestsoniheunions.ᨬab8cde•ḄghᙠjklTheresponsibility...restsontheunions.+,+-t/01mn?,:⛲Theresponsibility89:⛲forthelatestwaveofstrikes૛However,thereisastrongcast*thatthosewhohaveliernworstafftniedbyindustrialactionshouldreceivecompensationforthedisruptiontheyhavesuffered.pq.rstdkuvᨬwxḄyzᨵᐙᑖḄᳮᵫᡠtḄHowever,thereisaStrongcaseTherebethere+is+thatḄ@..Fastrongcase89:⛲thatthose...shouldreceivecompensationwhoḄ?@..:⛲thosewhohavebeenworstaffectedbyindustrialactionB9:⛲/0146forthedisruptiontheyhavesuffered.⌕DEF/01forthe...sufferedMjheyhavesufferedNḕᶍᐵ0(which/lhat)Ḅ?@.:⛲thedisruptiono0GEFcompensation.knmpenseijn஻.UU⊡disruptiondisTApfn᡾;UM•••••૘TheGovernmenthaspledgedtochangethelawIoinlnnlucraniininiumservicerequiremfiilsothat,evenwhenstrikesoccur,servicescancontinuetooperate.¡¢£¤¥:ᦋ§¨©ᵨᨬ«¬⌕®b᪵ᓽ±²³dk´µ¬¶·¸¹º⃩஺TheGovemmenthaspledged¾£ÀÁRÂ_¶?1$'(+,+-)".H0?Ë1ÌḄ6tointroduceaminimumservicerequirement89:⛲soÍalḄÌḄ6@•ḄÌḄ6sothat....servicescancontinuetooperate.whenḄÎÏ6@.ÌḄ6@ḄÎÏ6B9:⛲evenwhenstrikesoccur,195

7૙Thisshouldfonnpartofawiderpackageofmeasurestoaddressthelong-nmriingpniblrmsonBritairfsrailways.◀ÑÒ᜜.NÔÕÖ´µ×ØÙᙠḄÚ⚪ÜÝ©Þ8ᑡßàáḄâãThisshouldformpartofawiderpackageofmeasures++H0?Ë1mn?J:⛲awiderpackageofmeasures89:⛲toaddressthelong-runningproblems/01mn?.:⛲thelong-runningproblemsB9:⛲onBritain'srailways.0GEFpackage.äÀåR8ᝅçè8ᝅéêaddress*.adresYvl.ì§Ô;ᜐᳮUîï૚Yes,moreinvestmrnlisneeded,butpassengerswillnotlwwillingtopaymoreindefinitelyiftheymustalsoendurecramped,unreliableservices,punctuatedbyregularchaoswhentimrtablrsarechanged,orplannedmaintenanceismanagedincompetently.qḄ,b◤⌕ßñḄᢗóp᝞õö÷zøùútûᢴýþ☠Ḅ,⊤᦮ᡈᳮᗐḄᑜឋ!"#$.&'()*+,-./01Ḅ2lYes,moreinvestmentisneeded,3+56738|but:;Ḅᑡ6=⊤>ᢚ2butpassengerswillnotbewillingtopaymoreindefinitely@3+5+AB[ifCḄᩩEFGH6=I$206ḄᩩEFG------------------I,JK⛲iftheymustalsoendurecramped,unreliableservices,MNᑖPQGIRSTG,[K⛲cramped,unreliableservicesVJK⛲punctuatedbyregularchaos[whenCḄWFGH6whentimetablesarechanged,XJK⛲,r:;Ḅᑡ6orplannedmaintenanceismanagedincompetently.PYZ[inderinitely[mdefmotli]ad.\▲^ᙢcramped[kraempt]a.`ᢴḄ;cdḄecfḄpunctuate[pAgktfueit]vl.ᡭ$chaos*[»kems]n.;ᩖeimaintenance[•memtansns]n.eᢝinccmpetenlly[mkompitontli]ad.\klᙢ;mnᙢ૛Th<*threatofnationalisationmayhavebeenseenofffornow,butitwilln,tuniwithavengeanceifthejustifiedangerMpassengersisnotaddressedinshortorder.op=qᨵᓄḄtuvkw!x◀,z᝞|\}ᙠQ^ᑁ'ᔠᔠᳮḄ៬᝼.qᨵᓄḄtu0ᙢᔁᩭfornow,,JK⛲PQGI$106ḄWFGofnationalisationPQGIRSTG=K⛲ThethreatlThethreat...mayhavebeenseenoff@3+5B6738|but:;Ḅᑡ6.⊤>ᢚ2buthwillreturn@3+5B"|PQGI$206ḄFGwithavengeance,JK⛲ifCḄᩩEFGH6=I@206ḄᩩEFGifihejustifiedangerofpassengersisnotaddressedIPQGIFGVJK⛲inshortorder.•196•

8:PYZ[nationalisation[.niEfnaiarzeiJn](Inationalization)qᨵᓄsecoffᡭeᡊe...〈withavengeance0ᙢ;¡¢+ᧇᙢinshortorder¤ᓽ;¦§ᙢText2…©,ª••,૘Iqslyearmarkedthethirdyearinarowofwht,nIndonrsia'sbleakrateofdeforestationhasslowedinpace.N¬ᓺ¯°±²³´Ḅµ᪍·¸᳛:º»¼Ḅ©X¬,JK⛲inarowPQGIRSTG=[K⛲thethirdyear6738Èstyearmarkedthethirdyear@3+5+ABPQGIRSTG=|K⛲thethirdyear,JK⛲ofwhenIndonesia'sbleakrateofdeforestationhasslowedinpace.⌕ÊZ[ofwhen...pace#,whenCḄAGH6IPofḄAG஺VPYZ[mark*[ma,k]vL᪗Í;Î᪗ÏÐÑ;᪗Ïarow:º=;:bleak[bli:k]³´Ḅe₠ÓḄdeforestation[idiiiforisteijn]ÔÕ¸µ᪍Onrreasonforᵫ¾turnaroundniaylx*theeountn'santipovertyprogram.¿>À☢ḄÂÃ,vkÄqḄᢄÆ⚗o6738Onereason...maybethf2gg!ᵯ!×ØÙgÚÛ•@3+Ü+⊤B[PQGIRSTG=K⛲Onereason,JK⛲forthetuniaround[PYZ[turnaround[-t3,noraond]ÔÝ>eÞ⁐antipoverty[.aentrpovati]஺.àÆáḄ••••©Vª•…૘In2(X)7,hidoiiesiastartedphasinginaprogramthatgivesmoneyIoils|MM>rrslresidentsUIKUT(-crtainconditions,suchasrequiringpeopletokeepkidsinschoolorgetregularmedicalcare.2(X)7¬=E|௃¯°±ãäᑖ▤ªæç,è⚗o=ᓽéêᱯTᩩEḄᱯìíîïðñò=ó᝞⌕ô&'õö7Ú÷ᡈ;øT^ùᶭ,JK⛲In2007.[PQGI6738ḄWFG6738Indonesiastartedghasingjnaprogram(3+5+A)ᵫalCḄTGH6JK⛲aprogram,JK⛲thatgivesmoneytoitspoorestresidents1PQGIᩩEFGVJK⛲undercertainconditions.suchas…üýþÿcertainconditionssuchasrequiringpeopletokeepkidsinschoolrᑡḄ⛲ortogetregularmedicalcare.phasein⌲ᵨ;ᑖ▤ᐭresident*[rezidant]n.!;"ᡝCalledconditionalrushtransfersorCCTs,thesesocialassistanceprogramsaredesignedtoreduceinequalityandbreakthecycleofpoverty.$%&'(ᨵᩩ+,-./ᡈCCTsḄ1234⚗67ᙠ9:;<,=>ᡭẚABCD•197

9E⛲CalledconditionalcashtransfersorCCTs,IFGᑖHIJKLḄMIJKLthesesocialassistanceprogramsaredesignedK+OIHIJKLḄ6ḄMtoreduceinequalityE⛲|andᑡḄandtobreakthecycleofpoverty.conditional[kondijonl]a.ᨵᩩ+Ḅtransfer*[traensf3,$r0]n../QRbedesignedto...7ᙠ...inequality[.mikwnbti]n.;}~E⛲InIndonesia,IcHIJKLḄᙢMIJKLtheprogramhasprovidedenoughfoodandmedicineK+O+b[HIJKLḄ6ḄME⛲tosubstantiallyreduceseveregrowthproblemscHJ⛲severegrowthproblems⛲amongchildren.:substantially[sabstaenjali]ad.ᜧfᙢsevere*[si-via(r)]".ᓝᑖnoḄ;᩽(ូḄ,,E૘ButCCTprogramsdon'tgenerallyconsidereffectsontheenvironment.,CCT⚗62ὃ⇋D᛻ḄIJKLButCCTprogramsdon'tgenerallyconsidereffects(K+O+)cH[⛲efTedsE⛲ontheenvironment.@Infact,|x)vertyalleviationandenvinmmrnla!protfciionan*oftenviewedasconflictinggoals,saysPaulFerraro,aneconomistatJohnsHopkinsUniversity.-ᜧ¡ḄW¢¡_£¤1¥¦¤⊤¨,©▭«ᢄA>D᛻£&®(¯°±²Ḅ6᪗Infact,E⛲´µasconflictinggoals,IcHpovertyalleviationandenvironmentalprotectionḄ⊡zIJKLpovertyalleviatkrnendenvironmentalprotectionareoftenviewed(K+O)____________1´ᐭE⛲saysPaulFerraro,TPau)FerraroḄ·¸⛲aneconomistatJohnsHopkinsUniversity.alleviation[ali,vieijn]n.9¹;º>conflicting[kanfhktiij]஺.±²ḄQ°¯»¼Ḅ1•198

10111½1,૘That'sl>rcausfeconomicgrowthcanlwcorrelatedwithrnvin0nm<*nluldegradation,wliik*protectingiheenvironmentissometimescorrelatedwithgreaterpoverty.$¾(W¢¿ÀÁÂÃD᛻ូᓄ¯ᐵÆD᛻£ᨵÇÃÈnoḄAB¯ᐵ஺__________________________E⛲withenvironmentaldegradation,1cHMThat'sÊË""gggjnqjpjf̔Σ31ᚈÐK+Ñ+⊤ÒbIJKL|whileḄᑡI⊤ÓwhileprotectingIheenvironmentissometimescorrelatedcHMjE⛲withgreaterpoverty.correlate*[knraleit]Ô`...¯°ᐵὶdegradation[©egrodeijn]n.ូᓄÐFb:Ö×૙However,llecorrelationsdon'tprovecauseandeffect.ᯠÆ$%¯ᐵឋÂÚÛ¾ÜᐵÑ|x»rte$lthetraditionalview.ÞßàEE⚗ᑖ᪆¾ÜᐵÑḄẆãäᢝkæçèvẆãéêëhìE]VW©íkCCTsḄᙢî஺E⛲analyzingcausality,],ᙠᑖH⛲TheonlypreviousstudyIJKLTheonlypreviousstudy…supportedthetraditionalyjew.K+O+b4:´ᐭ.⊡ᐙðÛTheonlypreviousstudyE⛲basedonanareainMexico1thalñḄÒI.⛲anareainMexico⛲thathadinstitutedCCTs,:previous*[pri,vbs]a.ᐜßḄQÔóḄanalyze[aenalaiz]vt.ᑖ᪆QᑖôQᓄõcausality[korzsbti]n.¾ÜᐵÑQ¾Üöinstitute*[mstitjuzt]vt.©í;÷øQùú૛There,aspeoplegotmoremoney,xunt,ofllicinmayhavemoreclearedlandforcattletoraisefornwat.Ferrarosays.¥¦¤ðᑮᙠüý.þµUÿᑮḄ,ḄḄᙢᩭ⛴ᾙ⛲aspeoplegotmoremoney,as!Ḅ"#$%&'[)&*+,Ḅ"#$&*+,There,...someofthemmayhavemoreclearedland(++/+01234$)567$,[⛲moreclearedlandforcattletoraiseformeat,⛲8ᐭ$Ferrarosays.3:;negativelyaffecttheenvironment,Ihough.OP'Q⚗SO7TU᛻WXY☢[\.•199•

11&*+,Suchprogramsdonothavetonegativelyaffectthe£nyirstnment,though.s++/+0t3:;

123:;

13૙Ferran)suggeststheresultsmaytransfertootherpartsofAsia,duetocommonalitiessuchastheinifM)rtan(*rofgrowingriceandmarketaccess.ᵫᐸpᙢᓺᙠ#$Ḅ⌕ឋᐭq☢ᙠᐳឋ,Ẇk¡〉ᵨᐸpᙢ஺Ferrarosuggests(0+?+@:)./01]ḕᶍ45C(that)Ḅ@9:.rgoodforthernvirorimrnt.v¹º»¼½ឋD¾,Ẇk⊤,¿ᨵÀḄÁ¿Ã᛻ᨵÀ*+,⛲regardlessoftransferability.cCG9<./01ḄÅÆ89And...thestudyshows0+?+@:A./01thal45Ḅ@9:.,thatwhat'sgood...mayalsobegoodcCG9<89.Ç⊤¿Èforpeople*+,⛲cCG9<89,⊤¿Èfortheenvironment.⌕ÉKLthat45Ḅ@9:.what45Ḅ09:.what'sgood<09,may…beyBC,good<⊤9,also<89;whal45Ḅ09:..what<09,isyBCᓽod<⊤9CJKLregardlessofDË;DÌRDᳮtransferability[.traens.fsirabibti]n.¼½ឋ૛Evenifthisprogramdidn'treducepoverty,Ferrarosays,**thevalueoftheavoideddeforeslationjuslforcarbondioxideemissionsaloneismoreIhantheprogramcosts.”ᓽÎ`]⚗HÏᨵÐÑÒÓ.ᢈ¬:“Ö×ØÙ᪍ÛÐÑ2ÜᓄÞḄ᣸àᙢ`*q☢Ḅáâ^ãä\⚗HḄᡂåæEvenifthisprogramdidn'treducepoverty,*+,⛲Evenif45ḄÅÆ89:.<./01ḄÅÆ89Ferrarosays,çi9./01“thevalue...isᔳ=0+y+⊤AÇcCG9<éêE9,⛲thevalue*+,⛲oftheavoideddeforestation|cCG9<éêE9.,⛲theavoideddeforestation2+,⛲justforcarbondioxideemissionsaloneCJKLavoid*]voidY×ØR■íRî×emission]i-mijnYn.LàRᦣðRàñ1202•

14Text3.111111.OAsahistorianwho'salwayssearchingl(>rtin*textortheimagethatmakesusre-evaluateIhepasI,I'vebecomepreoccupiedwithlookingforphotographsthatshowourVictorianancestorssmiling(whatbetterwaytoshattertheimageof19th-centuryprudery?).<*òóôõ<ὅᡃøᙠùúÅᡃûüýáäþḄᦻåᡈᱏ.ᡃᡃᑭἔᐜḄ᯿ᱏ(ᨵ!Ḅ"#ᡭẚ19&'()*Ḅ+,ᕖ.),123⛲thatmakesusre-evaluatethepast.6at78Ḅ9:;<=>3⛲thetextortheimage523⛲who'salwayssearchingforthetextortheimagewho78Ḅ9:;<,3⛲ahistorian23⛲Asahistorian?@A:B

15Theyarenoting(D++;)ᐝ@ABCDEḆGḄ:JKL᤬8M(ᙠ╄PḄQ᱐STᡂ8V)WX◤⌕ᑖ\]X^ᡂ᤬8•᪵204

16ᩭ,abc᤬ὅᦋfghᡈj᦮lḄmnop@q8VrsftuvDuringthe1840sand1850s,wx⛲z"{'|Ḅ@A}'intheearlydaysofphotography,z"{'|Ḅ@A}'exposuretimeswerenotoriouslylong:(+~+⊤)wx⛲thedaguerreotypephotographicmethod...couldtakeseveralminutestocomplete.ihedaguerreotypephotographicmethod(producinganimageonasilveredcopperplate)wx⛲ᙠᑖ"{'|}'resultinginblurredimagesassittersshiftedpositionoradjustedtheirlimbs."exposure*[ikspoo33$r0]஻.>ᐝ@A☄notoriously[ngutoirissli]ad.ᡠᕜGᙢ;ᙢsilvered[silva$r0d]a.╄PḄP⁐Ḅcopper*[kopo$r0]n.Qa.Q⁐Ḅblurred[bl,d]a.uvḄ;Ḅlimb*[hm]n.n;᪛Ḅᜧq3૙Thethoughtofholdingufixedgrinasthecameraperformeditsmagicaldutieswastoomuchtocontemplate.andsoanon-committalblankstarebecametheuomi.a᡻¡¢£᜻Ḅ¥¦@,§bc᤬ὅ¨ᢝª«Ḅ☄¬®¯M§D°±¯²•³´•µ☢·⊤¸Ḅ¹ᯠ»¼rᡂ½¾᝱,wx⛲asthecameraperformeditsmagicaldutiesasÀÁḄ@A}'ÂIwx⛲ofholdingafixedgrinz"{'|Ãp«'qx⛲Thethought(1)Thethought...wastoomuchtocontemplate,(+~+⊤)andÄÅḄÆᑡ(2)andsoanon-committalblankstarebecamethenorm.(+~+⊤)"Rrin[grm]☄¬Ḅ;ÈḼᘂcontemplatePkontampleit]Ëὃ⇋ÅÎ9ÏÐḄWXឋnon-committal[.nonkamitl]n.ÒvḄablankstare¹ᯠḄ»¼,•,m.••••૘Butexjxwurelimeswere!i)u(*hquickerbytht,1880s.andthei!ilroᐝ@AÕrÖ×,ᨽÙÚÛÜᐸlÞßÛḄ/àᕡḼ>ᐝ@AâãqEä±åᜩḄᦪṹ᪗êᩭëìᯠí᠒஺____________wx⛲bythe1880s,z"{'|Ḅ@A}'(l)Butexposuretimesweremuchquicker(+~+⊤)|andÄÅḄÆᑡ(2)andtheintroductionof...andotherportablecamerasmeant(+&+(Â)thatÀÁḄ('Âq|meantḄ('ñthat....theexposurewasalmostinstantaneous.|IhoughÀÁḄ§ò}'Âq|('ÂḄ§ò}'wx⛲though(theexposurewas)slowbytoday,sdigitalstandards,"portable-[poztabl]஺.ÞßÛḄóôḄinstantaneousiinstsn-temiasYa.ãAḄõᓽḄ205

17૙Spontaneoussmileswererrlalivrlyeasytocapturebythe1890s,sowernusllookelsewhereforanexplanationofwhyVictoriansstillhesitatedtosmile/ᑮ19/0901l÷ᯠḄøù®᧕ᣓᣍqᡠ±ᡃýþÂᐸlᙢÿᩭᑭḄᯠbythe1890s,⛲!"$10#Ḅ$%!tocapture&'()!"%!lSpontaneoussmileswererelativelyeasy*++-+⊤/#0+1|so23Ḅ4ᑡ#6⊤72sowemustlookelsewhereforanexplanation*++8+9/of:;anexplanationḄ<=!⛲ofwhyVictoriansstillhesitatedtosmile.>?spontaneous*[spontemias]a.@ᯠḄA@BḄhesitatetodosth.CDEF…,•JKL••OOneexplanationmightbethelossofdignitydisplayedthroughacheesygrin.,MNOPQRMSCḄ☄UᨵᜫXJ___________________________________________________#0+1Oneexplanationmightbethelossofdignity*++-+⊤/[\ᑖ!"^_(!J⛲ihelossofdignity⛲displayedthroughacheesygrin.>?dignity*$dignati]`XaAXbAcdcheesy[4ji:zi]a.SCḄAD"Ḅ;fgḄ૙*Naturegaveuslipstoconcealourteeth,**ranonejxipularVictoriansaying,alludingtothefactlliatbeforethebirthofprojierdentistrymouthswereofteninashockingstateofhygiene.“@ᯠijᡃᘂᖃᩭnᢱᱛU6”RtᑭrsḄtuᨩᢣxyFz6ᓽᙠ}~Ḅᱛ6ῚPᜐM᩽Ḅ%᝱#0+1“Naturegave...concealourteeth,“ranonepopularVictoriansaying,᎔#9+8++/Iᙠᑖ!"#0+1Ḅ%!⛲alludinglothefactthat:Ḅ<=!#Jtthefact⛲that...mouthswereofteninashockingstateofhygiene.I!"$%!⛲beforethebirthofproperdentistry,>?Aconceal[kon1si,l]A◚A◚Ṱallude[*lu,d]¢ᨩᢣA$3£ᑮinashockingstateᜐ¥Ḅ%᝱hygiene^[.haidsijn]n.¦૚\flashingsetofhealthyandclean,regular*pearlywhites*wasararesightinVictoriansociety,thepreserveofthesuper-rich$andeventhen,dentalhygienewasnotguaranteed0.ᙠᑭḄ§¨6©©BªஹᏉ®¯ஹ᦮᦮±±Ḅ‘³´µḄḍU’¸¹º,»P¼½¾Ḅ¿À*ᓽÁ᝞Ã6ᱛU¦Ä¹ᑮÅÆ/⛲¢Victoriansociety,__________________-____________I!"#0+1Ḅ%!______#0+1Aflashingsetofhealthyandclean,regular'pearlywhites'wasararesight++-+⊤/⊡ᐙtararesight1⛲thepreserveofthesuper-rich__________⊡ᐙtI⛲$andeventhen,dentalhygienewasnotguaranteed0.1206•

18>?pearly[p,li]³´µḄAɳ´Ḅguarantee*[^seronti,]vt./n.ÅÊAËÅ3•••JÌL••••૘AliHithygrin$esjwciallywhenthereweregapsorblackenedteeth0lackedclass,drunks,trampsandmusichallperformersmightgurnandgrinwithasmileaswideasLewisCarroll'sgum-exposingCheshireCat,butitwasnotabecominglookforproperlybredjiei^ons.☄UÍ*ÎᐸPÐᱛUᨵ$◣ᡈBÓ/ᨵᜫÔÕ⏥×ஹrØÙÚÛÜÝᔉḄ⊤ßὅNO¨á×Ὴ,ãä᧕æ•ᓱèéêë☄ḼᱛíḄî»ï»᪵ñᘂᜧ,óRôᦟö÷øḄᩭt,4PM¹ùḄ☢û⊤ü⛲$especiallywhenthereweregapsorblackenedteeth0[⊡ᐙAt$M0thygrin#0+1Atoothygrin...lackedclass:++8+9/t#0+1drunks,trampsandmusichallperfbnnersmightgumandgrin⛲Ibut23Ḅ4ᑡ#6\ýᢚbutitwasnotabecominglookforproperlybredpersons.!"%!⛲withasmileaswideasLewisCarroll'sgum-exposingCheshireCat,tramp[Imp]஻.gum[93:11]vi.Ὴ;guni>exposing☄ᱛḄbecoming[bikAmio]a.ᔠ〉Ḅ;ᔠ"Ḅ૙EvenMarkTwain,amanwhornjoyrdaheartylaugh,saidthatwhenitcametophotographicportraitstherecouldheunothingmoredamningthanasilly,foolishsmilefixedforever**.ᓽ$%&'•ᔢ*+᪵-•./01ᝰᜧ4Ḅ5ᔳ7:9:;5<᯿ᱏ?@AᨵCDE-.FGF≶ḄI4JKLMNOPQḄR”஺UVW⛲whoenjoyedaheartylaugh,]whoZ[ḄM\]^,W⛲aman-VW⛲aman]MarkTwainḄ`a\EvenMarkTwain,…saidbc+e+f]g^hcijhalZ[Ḅf\]^@ksaidḄf\that...therecouldbe“nothingmoredamningthanasilly,foolishsmilefixedforever”.[whenZ[Ḅ?lm\]^,kf\]^Ḅ?lm\-VW⛲whenitcametophotographicportraits⌕othatZ[Ḅf\]^p/herecouldbe“iwlhing…forever”qTherebe^r@c\qnothing:stu\moredamningkvwM\@W⛲nothing:than...foreverqExm\஺portrait[poitreit]n.ᾠ<z"᯿damning[,daemirj]a.ᕴ|Ḅ}~ḄText4.111-....OFromtheearlydaysofbroadband.advocates$orconsumersandweb-basedcompaniesworriedthatthecableandphonecompaniessellingbroadbandconnedionshadthepowerandincentivetofavorafTiliatedwebsitesovertheirrivals".$ᵨ,ὅᩗḄὅ,├Ḅᨵᵯᵯᨵ¡¢⊼ᐸ▬¦§¨©ª«¬Ḅ§“•207•

19-VW⛲Fromtheearlydaysofbroadband.]°u\k^hciḄ?lm\^hciadvocates...worriedthatthe…companies…hadthepowerandincentivebc+±+f]g[°u\kvwM\@W⛲advocates"forconsumersandweb-basedcompanies³ᙠᑖu\kvwM\,W⛲thecableandphonecompanies-VW⛲sellingbroadbandconnections¶M·u\kvwM\@W⛲thepowerandincentivetofavoraffiliatedwebsites[°u\km\UVW⛲overtheirrivals'.:broadband[bnrdbaend]¸(ºὶḄ)advocate*[sedvakat]஻.ὅÂᢝὅcable*[keibl]n.ᨵᵯᵯ½;¾¿incentive*[insentiv]n.¡ÄÅᝄÇaffiliated[afilieitid]a.▬ÀḄÁÀḄrival*[raivl]n.ª«¬W.È……ᓛË૙That'swhytherehasbeensuchastrongdemandforrulesthatwouldpreventbroadbandprovidersfrompickingwinnersandlosersonline,preservingthefreedomandinnovationthathavebeenthelifebloodoftheInternet.+%qCD5ÌÍÎ⌕ÏᑴMᐵÒÓ@ÔÕÖ×Øᖪᙠ⌱ÛÜÝÞÝ@]¨ßºὶ-àÔᩭḄâᾭ-ᵫåæ஺^hciThat'swhYtjierehasnsuehastrongdemandbc+ç+⊤]g°u\kvwM\JW⛲astrongdemand-VW⛲forrules[hatZ[ḄM\]^.W⛲rulesUVW⛲thatwouldpreventbroadbandproviders"I°u\km\frompickingwinnersandlosersonline,éVW⛲³ᙠᑖu\kM\]^Ḅêëm\preservingthefreedomandinnovationthatZ[ḄM\]^,IW⛲thefreedomandinnovationìVW⛲thathavebeenthelifebloodoftheInternet.⌕owhyZ[Ḅ⊤\]^pᒹî-.Therebe^r@ᐸê᪀q“ihere+be(hasbeen)+c\(suchastrongdemand)"0,demand*[dima:nd]n.(ðñḄ)⌕Ïvt.ÍÎ⌕Ïpreserve*[priZ3,v]vt.ßòᶇn.ôõ⚞÷innovation*[.insveifn]".åæᦋ☩æûülifeblood[daifblAd]n.âᾭ:ýâ••••U••••OYetthatdemandhasl0eeiialmostim{x0ssiblfatofill-inpartbecauseofpushbackfrombroadbandproviders,unii-regulatoryconservativesandthecourts.ᯠ¨@+-⌕ÏÿᑮᑖᙠᩭᖪஹḄ▾Ḅ஺#$%&Yetthatdemandhasbeenalmostimpossibletofill%+)+⊤+I⊡ᐙ./#$%&012⛲0inpartbecauseofpushback456789:;7[2⛲pushback=12⛲frombroadbandproviders,anti-regulatoryconservativesandthecourts.208

205>?@pushback[pujba:k]n.;Bᑴ:Dregulator[regjabtari]a.ḄᐹᨵᩗḄconservative*[kans3,votiv]஻.ὅ;(LM)OOᕒa.Ḅ૙\federalappealscourtweighedinagainTuesday,Initinsteadofprovidingabadlyneededresolution.ilonlyprolongedthefight.ᕜ=,0SὶUVW▾XY4ᐭ.[\][^ᨵ0_ញ◤Ḅbcdᫀfghijkᧅm(1)AfederalappealscourtweighedinagainTuesday,(%+n)#$%&IbutopḄqᑡ#.⊤sᢚ(2)but...honlyprolongedthefight.(%+n+u)|45678(2)#Ḅw7012⛲insteadofprovidingabadlyneededresolution.5>?@appeal*[3>pi:l]n.VW;ᵭWvi.VW;ᨵᔾz{weighin|}(~)resolution[rez9-lu,fn]".bc;c;c;prolong*[prolnrj]Mgh;h;h(૚AtissuebeforetheU.S.CourtofApfwalsforllir[)istri(,tofColumbiaCircuitwasthelatesttakeoftheFederal(>>miniini<*ali()ns(Commission(FCC)onurlneutrality,adoptedonaparty-linevot<-in2017.MᱯὶUVW▾☢ḄmFCC(MὶUᕒ)ᙠ2017Oᢗἠ¡¢Ḅᐵ¤¥¡¦ឋḄᨬ©012⛲beforetheU.S.CourtofAppealsfortheDistrictofColumbiaCircuit[45678#$%&Ḅw7#$%&Atissue...wasthe^latesttake(᎔«#¬⊤+)+%)456789:;7.2⛲thelatesttakeoftheFederalCommunicationsCommission(FCC)456789:;7,2⛲thelatestlake012⛲onnetneutrality,¢ᑖ56789:;72⛲Ihelalesllakeadoptedonaparty-linevotein2017.5>?@¬®¯uem¡Ḅ~¡Ḅbefore*[brf3i(r)]}ᓺ.µ☢µ☢;᤮ᙠ...☢·circuit[»S3,kit]".ᵯ±²take*[teikjn.¸¹ºᦈᐭ¼r½¾¿Àneutrality[njurtnelati]n.¡¦¡¦w᝱adopt*[adnpt]M¢ÁᵨᦈÃ૛PIK*Republican-pennedonlcrnotonlyrliminatedihrstrictnetneulrulityrulestheFCChadadoptedwhenithadaDemocraticmajorityin2015,butrejectedihrcommission'sauthoritytorequirebroadbandproviderstodomuchofanything.jÄᵫᐳOÇ₝ḄcÉÊ◀i2015Ì%OᓰÎᦪÐFCC¢ḄÑÒḄ¤¥¡¦ឋÓ.ÔᔲciFCCᖪÀᔜ×⌕ÙḄᩗ{.=12⛲whenithadaDemocraticmajorityin2015,whenzÚḄÐÛw7Ü#[8;7Ü#ḄÐÛw7012⛲theFCChadadoptedḕᶍᐵ)5(wliich/tliat)Ḅ;7Ü#.j2⛲thestrictnetneutralityrulesTheRepublican-permedordernotonlyeliminatedthestrictnet…rules(%+n+u)#$%&Inotmly...but(also)opḄqᑡnu1but(also)rejectedthecommission'sauthorityß5;6789:;7f^Wthecommission'sauthority012⛲torequirebroadbandproviderstodomuchofanything.⌕à?@torequirebroadbandproviderstodomuchofanything¡.broadbandproviders8requireḄu7ß5;67todomuchofanything8u7broadbandprovidersḄ⊡7•2091

215>?@:Republican*[npAbhkan]n.ᐳOOᕒpen*[pen]vt.Ç₝₝âv.ᑏ8Democratic*[^emokrastik]a.M+Ì%OḄreject*[ndsekt]vt.äåὃ⇋pècommission[k/mijn]éᕒaulhcrity*[n:0D2ti]".ᩗ{êᩗ;ᢇìhTheonleralsodeclaredthatstateandlocalgovernmentscouldn'tregulatebroadl>an$lproviderseither.ícÔîï.ðñᙢdñóôᩗᖪTheorderalsodeclaredõ%+n+uÜ+#$%&thatzÚḄu7Ü#J8declaredḄu7thatstateandlocalgovernmentscouldn'tregulatebroadbandproviderseither.5>?@declare*[drklear]vt.îï,öï;î÷regulate[Tegjuleit]..õᵨÓᑣᩩú+ᳮ•••ýþÿ•••૘Tlieonunissionargunlthatoilieragrncicswouldproleciagainstanti-competitivel^liuvior.suchasabn>abroadbandprovidersthatimposeddatacaps<>nth<,irrivals'streamingservicesbutnottheirown.)-.+,ᖪᐸḄ:;

22]sklinvestigation|m^estigeijnjn.impose*[impaoz]vt.ᑴ§x¨capYk&p]஻.ᨬ£▲¤;ᑴ/¥x¥¦streamingservice:;?@

231••\]^OInthemeantime,tin,(unirtthrewouttheFC(/sattempttoblockallstaterulesonnetntnitrality,whilepreservingthecommission'spowertopreemptindividualstatelawsthatundermineitsordei".@x▾ᔲ{|FCC5}~ᔜ/ឋ'ᡠḄ,ᶇᐸᐜNᑴ,.”Ḅᩗ,ᓽ⚜ᐜᑴ~ᑴ'ẚᕒ{Ḅx஺⛲Inthemeantime,ḄthecourtthrewouttheFCC^sattempt(+iFj+)"%&'(¢£'⛲IheFCCஹattempttoblockallstaterulesonnetneutrality,⛲while+Aᙠᑖª᪀Ḅ¬whilepreservingthecommission'spower%&'(¢£'J⛲power¯⛲topreemptindividualstatelawsihalḄ'⛲individualstatelaws°±⛲thatundermineitsorder.⌕,-.ᙠ²³"while+Aᙠᑖ”ª᪀/,´ᐸµḄ¶@ᦑḕᶍ|thecourt,#¸preservedᦋ5ᐸº%»(preserving,»ᡂ|“while+º%”ª᪀ᐸ¶¾¿,ᓽÀwhilethecourtpreservedthecommission'spower...itsorder:-.inthemuanlime@;ᙠÂÃthrowoutᔲ{ÄஹÅxÆÇ?È&"Éblock*[blnk]vt.}~?ÊËn.⊙Ípreempt[pncmpl]vt.⚜ᐜᑴ~;ÎᐜÏ%individual*[iindrvidjual]a.Ḅ?ᓫÒḄundermine*[tAnddmam]vt.ẚ,ÔÕ?Ö×@HiatmeansmorebattlesliketheonenowgoingonIwtwrenIhrJusticeIÇppartnu,ntandCalifornia,wlii4ienactedatoughnetneutralitylawinthewakeofIhrFCCsabdication.Ü<ᕡḼ¸ᨵàáâ᝞äåæxçè;ᑭêëìíî²ïḄᧅñ,ᙠFCCòóᩗ}~ᔜ/ឋ'ḄᩗÇ¢,;ᑭêëì⚙õö÷Ḅ/xThatmeansmorebattles+ø+Ç¢£'J⛲m஺"battles⛲liketheoneAᙠᑖ¢£'J⛲theone¯⛲nowgoingonI±⛲betweentheJusticeDepartmentandCalifornia.whichḄº▲'ឋ'⊡ᐙýþCalifornia]ÿ⛲whichenactedatoughnetneutralitylawI⛲inthewakeoftheFCC,sabdication.#$%'enact[inskt]'()*+ᫀ-./0tough*[tf]஺.23Ḅ;2ᔍḄ;78ḄAinthewakeof9...:;<ᩭabdication[.aebdikcijn]n.ᩗ?ஹABCḄ-DE•••GHIOHieendlesslegalbattlesandback-and-forthattheFCCcryoutforCongresstoad.KLMḄ+NᧅPQFCCRRSSḄPTUᔙWXYZ[\•212•

24]^_`TheendlesslegalIjattlesandback-and-fbrth...cryoutf()rCongresstoact.(_+c+d+d⊡);gh⛲back1and1forthi⛲attheFCC#$%endless[endlos]1.KLMḄ.KM᛻Ḅ.KkK▭Ḅlegal*[a.ᔠ+Ḅ;+NḄ;+ᑴḄback-and-forthRS.ᩭ[»]cryoutforrᑗ◤⌕.vw૙ItrifedstogivethecornniissionexplicitauthorityonceandforallIobarbn)a(lban(lprovidersfn)mmeddlinginihrtraffic(>ntheirnetworkandl(>cn*atedearrulesprotectingopennessnndinncvaliunonline.WX◤⌕xyᣴ{ὶ}(~ᕒXḄᩗ?ἭMᖪF⚜Ḅᙬ,ᑴhḄ+ᩭḄD⛲ontheirnetwork;gh,I⛲thetraffic⛲frommeddlinginthetraffic\i⛲tobarbroadbandproviders[\h]^_`ḄḄItneedsto1n311th*_+c+d-]^_`andᑡḄ\hdandtocreateclearrules¢ᙠᑖ;gh[⛲clearrulesi⛲protectingopennessandinnovationonline.⌕¥$%togive...forall¦§thecommissiongiveḄd§explicitauthoritydthecommissionḄ⊡¨©onceandforall஺#$%explicit*[iksphsit]Ḅ.◚ᨊḄonceandforallxyᙢ.iµ¶⍎ᙢbar*[ba:$r0]'ἭM,¬M.¬ᢱ®⏀ᔳmeddle[•medl]ri.`⚜.`¸.¹º»traffic*[trefik]",~²³;(~*³-openness['ouponnas]n.D..ᚆ᳛PartBGiI1•••૘hithemoviesandontelevision,artificialintelligence(AI)istypicallydepictedtissomrihingsinisterthatwillupendnurwayMlifw.ᙠ¾¿ᒓ¦ÁÂÃÄ(AI)(ÅÆÇÈÉÊËXÌÍᡃÏÐÑḄÒូ»ᱥi⛲Inthemoviesandontelevision,!andᑡḄ]^_`Ḅ]^_`artificialintelligence(AI)istypicallydepicted(_+iÕ)artificialintelligence(AI)Ḅ⊡¨i⛲assomethingsinisterihalÖ×ḄhØ]⛲scmelhingsinisler⛲thatwillupendourwayoflife.#$%arlificiH*[ÙÚÚÁÂḄ.Á⌼Ḅintelligence*[in*tehd39ns]n.ÃÄ.áÃdepict*[dipikt]vl.ÇÈ.ÇÜ.ÇÝsinister[•simsta(r)]a.ÒូḄ;◅ូḄ.ἝḄupend[Apcnd]vt.Þ᎔.à᎔.᎔D૙WhenitcomestoAlinhusiness,wroftenhearaixiutitinrelationl<>automationandthrimpendinglossofjobs.butinwhatwavsisAlchangingcompanicsandthelargerpt'onomythatdon'tinvclved(M)m-and-gl(>onimassuneinploymfut213•

25prNktians?äåᑮᖪç⚞éḄÁÂÃÄᡃêÅXëᑮÁìíîï\ᓄᓽìᑮᩭḄᜫçὶóᙠiô.õöᙠÁÂÃÄ÷☩ùçêúᜧü᛻ḄËËѦ,ᨵþÿ⚜ḼḄᜧᜫᕖWhenitconiestoAIinbusiness,⛲WhenḄ."#1$Ḅinrelationtoautomationandtheimpendinglossofjobs,/012"345,⛲itlweoftenhearaboutit+&+'$|but()Ḅᑡ+⊤-ᢚ2but...iscompaniesand;ereconoin012"#20Ḅ⛲inwhatways7hatḄ5.⛲ways⛲thatrlon'tinvolvedoom-and-gloommassunemploymentpredictions?⌕9:;j$20<=ᱯ?ᶧAḄᱯ?B+ᵫ“01$in0+ᱯ?ᶧA1$what0+E1#ways0+FG1++&G1+'”᪀ᡂ஺1L:;“henitcomesNOPᑮ+ORᑮautomation*[$Ojtameifn]n.SGᓄimpending[impendirj]aᓽVWXḄYZᙠḝ]Ḅd$M0m-and-gloom^_ᨩaḄ;cᜫdḄ•••fg••૘Arecetilsurveyofmanufacturingandserviceiinlustrit^sfn0mTataConsultancyServicesfoundthat$*oni|0aniescurrentlyuseAImoreofteninromputer-to-computeractivitiesihuninautomatinghumanactivities.ᛞᛞijklmnᨬpqᑴ⌼tkluvḄ⚗xḼWy,z{^ᙠ|}~ḄᵨḄ⚣᳛ᙠGSGᓄḄᵨḄ⚣᳛⛲ofmanufacturingandserviceindustriesfromTalaConsultancyServices012"ArecentsurveyḄ345Arecentsurvey...found++'$thatḄ'J"foundḄ'thatcompaniescurrentlyuseAlmoreoften012"☢incomputer-to-computeractivities⛲than..."thaninautomatinghumanactivities.1L:;manufacturing]m2enjufaektJorirjYn.ᑴ⌼consultancy]kan-SAltansiYn.ijmnYijt૙HerearcafewotherwaysAlisaidingcompanieswithoutreplacingemployees:<ᙠᕒḄ.zR¡FḄᐸ£¤¥,¦"areafewotherways#᎔©⊤+ª+$/ḕᶍ$inwhich0ᡈᐵª¯$that0Ḅ5+⛲afewotherways⛲AIisaidingcompanieswithoutreplacingemployees:••••f°g••••,OCompaniesareusingartificialintrlligcn<-r|$>removesomeofIhrunconsciousbiasfromhiring

26Companiesareusingartificialintelligence+&+'$IG152"Ḅ{Ḅ⛲toremovesomeoftheunconsciousbias012"345,[⛲theunconsciousbias⛲fromhiringdecisions.Y1L:;remove*[nmu,v]vt.´◀;Á◀;ÂÃunconscious[Ankonfas]a.»¼½Ḅ;ļ½ᑮḄbias[baias]஻.¾¿Y¾ÆW.¾Æhire*[.hai$r0]ÇὺᵨYÈᵨÉÊËYÌÈᕒ9૙"Tliereart-fxpfriiiientsdialshowthat.naturally,theresultsofinterviewsareiiiuclimorebiasetlthanwhalAIdoes,"saysPedroDomingos,authorofTheMasterAlgorithm:HowtheQuestfortheUltimatelearningMachineWillRemakeOurWorldandacomputerscienceprofessoraltheUniversityofWashington.ºÍÎ⊤Ï+☢ÐÑÒÓÔÕÖḄÑÒ×ᙠØḄ¾¿+Ùᐭ@thanhumanswouldbeableto,[thanABḄ"CD@EF#GFHIJḄ"CD@“AIlooksatrdsumdsingreaternumbersI+L+MFHIJ|andNOḄPᑡLMandselectsthemorepromisingcandidates.,,#RST:,resume[Tezjumei]W*ᔊ;᤺⌕;ᭆ[select*[silekt]\.ᢧ⌱;⌱];⌱^promising*[promisiQ]a.ᨵ;⌶Ḅᨵ4_Ḅcandidate*[kaendidot]n.᎛⌱ᵭb૛OnecompanythatfsdoingthisisculledBlendoor.•cdeBlendoorḄfghᙠj᪵•215•

27FHIJOnecompaiiyiscalledBlendoor.I+LTthalABḄl@EF,⛲Onecompany⛲that'sdoingthis⌕mTFHIJnḄBlend$x0reI@OnecompanyḄ⊡p@qhItusesanalyticstohelpidentifywheretheremayIM,biasinthehiringprocess.rfgsᵨᦪuᑖ᪆ᩭxyz{ᙠ|ὺ~n&ᙠḄᙢFHIJ11usesanalyticsI+L+M[Rl@GFHIJḄḄD@tohelpidentify⛲[whereABḄM@EF,GidentifyḄM@wheretheremaybebiasinthehiringprocess.RSTanalytics[$aenahtiks]n.ᦪᑖ᪆ᑖ᪆identify*[aidentifai]vt.z{••…૘SomeAlsoftwarecananalyzeandoptimizemarketingemailsubjectlinestoincreaseopenrates.♦$%&~ᑖ᪆ᓄ⃩├ᵯH¡ḄI⚪£ᩭ¤¥¡ᡭ§᳛FHIJSomeATsoftwarecananalyzeandoptimizemarketin^emid£gujjggtJinesI+L+MIRl@GFHIJḄḄD@⛲toincreaseopenrates.RSToptimize{optimaiz]W.sᓄmarketing[ma:kitiQ]ª⃩├«├subject*[$SAbd3ikt]n.I⚪©increase*[mkri:s]v.¤¥#¬n.¬®૙One<,$>inpanyintheUK.Phrasee,claimstheirsoftwarecanoutperformhumansbyupto10percenlwhenitcomesl<>emailop*nrates.¯°cdePhrase”Ḅfg±².ᙠᵯH¡Ḅᡭ§᳛☢.³´Ḅ"$µG¥410¶·ᑖm஺⛲Phrasee,IOne$*oinpaiiyintheUKḄ¹º@OnecompanyintheUK....claimsI+L+MEFHIJḕᶍABRthat0ḄM@EF,GclaimsḄM@theirsoftwarecanciHperfomihumansbyupto10percent|whenABḄ½¾D@EF.GM@EFḄ½¾D@⛲whenitcomestoemailopenrates.RSTclaim*[kleim]vt.±²;¿²n.±²;IÀoutperform[.autpabzm]vi.ᦔÂÃÄ~#Å~૚Tliiscanmeanmillionsmoreinrevenue.j&ÆᕡḼᦪ·ÉÊË./ḄᦈᐭFHIJThiscanmeanmillionsnioreI+L+M[ÍR@GFHIJḄ☢D@⛲inrevenue.RSTmillion*[miljan]n.·ÉᜧÏrevenue*[-revanju:]஻.ᦈᐭÑÒᦈᐭ;ᦈÂQTherearealsocompanieslikeAcquisio,whichanalyzesadvertisingperformanceacn>ssmuhipiechannelslike.Adwonls.Bingands$K*ialmediaandrnake>adjustmentsorsuggestionsalwnilwhen*advertisingfundswillyieldbest•216•

28results.ÓᨵÔAcquisioj᪵Ḅfg.rfgᑖ᪆ÕAdwonls.BingÖ×ØÙÚ/¶Û⍝ḄÝÞᢗàᦔá.PâÝÞãäåæçᨬèᡂᦔḄÛ⍝4ê᦮ᡈ¤4íîFHIJTherearealsocompaniesTherebeFïðThere+are+I[ñò\ócompanies⛲likeAcquisio,[whichABḄô▲lឋl@EF#⊡ᐙ\óAcquisiowhichanalyzesadvertisingperformanceø⛲andNOḄPᑡLMandmakesadjustmentsorsuggestionsÍR@Gùúl@#⛲advertisingperfonnanceacrossmultiplechannelslikeAdwords,Bingandsocialmediaû⛲ÍR@GD@#⊤âýaboutwhereadvertisingfundswillyieldbestresults.⌕mTaboutwhere...resultsn#whereABḄM@EF#GÍRaboutḄM@#rEFḄI@þadvertisingfunds,L@þwillyield,M@þbestresults,ÿwhereᙢ஺!"#advertising[^dvataizig]n.performance*[pafoimans]n.⊤;ឋ⊤channel*[-tjainl,n.⍝;⌶;⍝adjustment[adsAStmant]n.᦮;⁚funds[fAndz:yield*[ji,ld]vt.;hTheseare“lookthathelppeopleusedata,notareplacementforpeople.MsaysPalrickH.Winston,aprofessorofartiGcialintelligenceandcomputerscienceutMIT.$%&'“)*+,-ᵨᦪ0Ḅ2ᐹ456'+7Ḅ89:,“<ḕᳮ2?▾$MIT+2ABCDEF?ᦟᣴIᱯKL1H.MNOPnotareplacementforpeople,“QRS⛲⊡ᐙ[\lookthathelppeopleusedata,“[that]^Ḅ_`U,S⛲toolsTheseare"tools|saysḄaUVWXsaysPatrickH.Winston.b᎔dUea+g+Wh|PalriekH.WinstonḄijQRS⛲aprofessorofartiGcialintelligenceandcomputerscienceatMIT.,!"#data*[delta]l[p/.]ᦪ0ᧇreplacement[npieismant]n.89:8ᣚopq…OEnergycompanies$*anuseAltohelpcustomersreducetheirelectricitybills,savingthemmoneywhilehelpingtheernimnmcnLstuvw-ᵨ+2Aᩭ)*yᡝ{|ᵯ~4),ḕḄiᨵ*᛻QRS⛲tohelpcustomersreducetheirelectricitybills,l6_UVWXḄḄUVWXEnergycompaniescanuse&bW+g+ah]ᙠᑖUVWXḄQRS⛲savingthemmoney[while]^Ḅ`URS⛲whileenergycompaniesarehelpingtheenvironment.⌕"#savingthemmoneyḄW'Energycompanies:while]^Ḅ`U4ᐸWWUḄWi.ᦑḕᶍfWenergycompaniesB*areo•217•

29૙Companies$,analsooptimizeth<,irownenergyuseandcutdownonthecostofeleclricity.stuvwᓄ¡¢s-ᵨ᪀4¤{ᵯ~¥Companiescanalsooptimizetheir^wn^nergjuisebW+g+ahUVWX|and¦§Ḅ¨ᑡgandcancutdownonthecostofelectricity.!"#cutdown¤{;ª«;{|cost*[kost]”¥~ᵨ;~૚Insurancecompanies,meanwhile,canbasetheirpremiumsonAImotlelsthatmiireaccuratelyassessrisk.®i,◅tuvw᪷0±²³´µ¶·¸◅ḄAI¹ºᩭ»_◅~UVWXInsurancecompanies,...canbasethqi¼premigm1W+g+a½¾ᐭmeanwhile,QRS⛲ÀUVWXḄonAImodelsthat]^Ḅ_`U4½S⛲AImodelsRS⛲thatmoreaccuratelyassessrisk.♦!"#Ábas¼[beis]³.w...ÃÄẠpremium[,pri,mhm]n.◅~▬³~accurately[.aekjaratli]ad.´µᙢ;ǵᙢassess*[.es]w¶·;·DὃÉ;¶Ê9S૛Domingossays.MBefore,theyniighlnotinsurellironeswhofrhlikenhighriskorchargethemt$x0much,ortheywouldchargethemtoolittleandthenitwouldcostthecompanymoney.MË\ᡀNP.“wÍ.◅tu⌕Î6ÏÃÐ%ÑÒ¸◅ÓÔḄ+Õ.⌕Îᔣ$%+ᦈØÔÙḄ~4ᡈὅᔣ$%+ᦈØÓ|Ḅ~ᵨ.Ü$ÏÝtuÞᩭßḄàᜫ¼QRS⛲UVWXâã#insure[mjo3$r0]”Õ;ᢗcharge*]tfa:d3Yu/".ᦈ~;⌕Ê•••oæq•••O*Machinelearningoftenprovidesamorereliableformofstatistics,whichmakesdatamorevaluable."saysWinston.“Eᘤ?èéêvwëìQí²v☠Ḅïitð4$íïCðvw-ᦪ0²ñ.Êò4”MNO[⍝.QRS⛲whichmakesdatamorevaluable/9which]^Ḅó▲_ឋ_`U4½⊡ᐙ[\amorereliableformofstatistics“Machinelearningoftenprovidesamorereliableformofstatistics.UVWXlõ§]saysḄasaysWinston.᎔dUea+g+W•218•

30!"#:statistics[statistiks]n.[pl]ïC;ïCᦪ0valuable*[«v&ljudbl]a.ᨵÊòḄᨵᵨḄ૙Iluhelpspeoplemakesmarterdecisions,"ø")*+,ù²\AḄú_JIt“helpspeople$W+g+a+a⊡hUVWX½ḕᶍbtohḄ6_peopleḄ⊡û$to0makesmarterdecisions.”૚Oneaccountingfirm.EY.usesanAlsystemthathelpsreviewcontractsduringanaudit.QüýÃEYḄÏCþÿᡠᵨr,ᙠᔠ⛲EY,]OneaccountingfirmḄOneaccountingfirm.…usesanAIsystem$+"+#$that%&Ḅ'(J⛲anAIsystem⛲thathelpsreviewcontractsduringanaudit.)*+,accounting[skauntig]n.-./0review*]n-vju:Y3;5678.89contract*[tkontraikt]n.ᔠ.ᔠ1.᜿1audit]o,dit:஻./>;?᪶૛Thispnx,fss,alongwithemployeesreviewingthecontracts,isfasterandmoreaccurate.AᘤCDEFᔠGHIJ,FK3ILMThisprocess,...isfaster^cn^mor^accurate.++⊤$T⊡ᐙQRThisprocess⛲alongwithemployeesreviewingihecontracts,•1••TUV••૘Anufiibrrofcompunit's,particularlyinenergyandtransportation,useAliniagrprocessingtechnologytoinspectinfrastructureandpreventequipmentfailureorleaksl»ef$0rrtheyhappen.WXYZ[ᐸ]^_`abYZᵨDcdᜐᳮᢈhᩭjklẠno>■qrnᜓᦑuᡈwx⛲particularlyinenergyandtrans|K0rtation,z⊡ᐙQRcompaniesAnumberofcompanies,...useAInnageprocessingtechnology+"+#$|und{|}ᑡḄ)'ḄḄ⛲toinspectinfrastructurrand$to0preventequipmentfailureorleaks[before%&Ḅ(y⛲beforetheyhappen.)*+,processing[-praosesirj]n.ᜐᳮ.lDinspect[mspekt]vt.j;;infrastructure*[*infrastrAktJa$r0]n.Ạnoprevent*[pnvent]vt.⚜■.■.equipment*[rkwipmont]஻.nᜓ.ᘤᩞleak*[li:k]n./v.w☄.x૙MIftheyfailGrstandthenyoufixthem,ifsveryexpensive,°saysDomingos.”᝞Knᜓᦑu5Ḅ.ᡂ-W‘XRᡀQ⍝ஹ⛲“Iftheyfailfirstandthenyoufixthem,IIf%&Ḅᩩk(it'sveryexpensive,“:£|%saysḄ#saysDomingos.᎔¥¦#+"+$219•

31)*+,fail*[fell]H.qᦑu;ᜫᮣ.ᜫ©3ᳮ;ᜐᳮ.ª᣸.ª¥૚*Youwanttopredictifsomethingneedsattentionnowandpointtowhereifsusefulforemployeestogoto.n"®⌕⚜°rᙠ]ᔲᨵ³´◤⌕+¶,}ᢣ%ᕒD¹ᨵᵨḄº»”“Youwanttopredict¼+"+#$1ᨴI&Ḅ#(predictḄ#ifsomethingneedsattentionnowand{|Ḅ}ᑡ#andtopointto[where%&Ḅ#(pointtoḄ#whereit'susefulforemployeestogoto.”⌕¾+,_૙%¿ÀḄᑁÂᐳ૙saysḄ#)*+,.attention*Mtenjn]n.+¶.ᶇÅ.ᐵ+PartC•••TV••૘WorldWarIIwasthewatershedeventforhighereducationinmodemWesternsocieties.TyÇÈÉᜧᡊ]rÌÍÎÏ.-ᦟÑḄᑖÓÔWorldWarHwasthewatershedevent¼++⊤$Õ)Ö×',[⛲ihewatershedevent⛲forhighereducationÕ)Ö×'[⛲highereducationy⛲inmodemWesternsocieties.)*+,watershed[-woitafed]n.ᑖÓÔ;Ùᢚ¾highereducationᦟÑ૙TheseMwiriiesearneoutofthewarwithlevelsofenrollmentthathadl0eenroughlyconstantat3-5%oftherelevantagegroupsduringthedecadesbeforethewar.yᡊÖÍÎÏ-〉ÜÝḄᐭß᳛ᜧáâᢝᙠ3%—5%CᡊäåæçḄÓèEé஺Thosesocietiescameoutofthewar+"$]Õ)⛲withlevelsofenrollmentthat%&Ḅ'(;⛲levelsofenrollmenty⛲thathadbeenroughlyconstantat3—5%"Õ)Ö×'.[⛲3—5%oftherelevantagegroupsë⛲Õ)'(Ḅduringthedecadesbeforethewar.)*+,enrollment[mraulmsnt]n.ᐭß;ᐭí.î/roughly[Afli]ad.ᜧá;ïX;ðñᙢconstant*[konstant]a.óḄ;ᢝôḄrelevant*[rebvant]a.〉éḄ;õöEᐵḄ૚Butaftertlirwar,greatserialand$M0litiealchangesarisingoutofthesuccessfulwaragainstFascismcreatedagrowing

32"#$⛲afterthewar,j&'()*+,-.Ḅ/01)+,-.But...greatsocialandpoliticalchanges…createdagrowingdemand-+3+45ᙠᑖ'()*89),;$⛲great...changesarisingoutofthesuccessfulwaragainstFascism&'()*1)"#$⛲inEuropeanandAmericaneconomies&'()*89)<$⛲agrowingdemandfbrincreasingnumbersofgraduates&'()*89)<;$⛲graduates#$⛲withmorethanasecondaryschooleducation.'=>?ariseoutof@ᵫ...BCDE@F....BGFascismfaeJSmHIJK-L૛

33$lthedemandthatroseinthosesocietiesfr0rentrylohighereducationextendedtogroupsandsocialclassesthathadnotthoughtofattendingauniversityl0eforethewar.ᙠJMNO?kentry*entriHlᐭ@ᢣᩗᑭSBEqrextend*ikstends᡽u;wu;ᒹyhThesedemandsrrsuhrdinaven1rapidexpansionMthesystemsofhigherrdueation.h^ginninginthe1960sanddevelopingveryrapidlythoughunevenlyduringthe1970sand1980s.cz◤RSᦟ{|}᡽~.c"᡽~2060<ᙠ20ᓝ}@ᙳ⊝B+,-.Thesedemandsresultedinavei^rajpidexpansion-+h+4B;&'()*89)<$⛲averyrapidexpansionofthesystemsofhighereducation,⊡ᐙaveryrapidexpansion"#$⛲beginninginthe1960s|andᑡḄ5ᙠᑖ'()anddevelopingveryrapidlythoughunevenlyI&'()*/01)#$⛲duringthe1970sand1980s.'=>?expansion*ikspaenjnH᡽~E᡽ᜧunevenly[Ani,vnli]ad.ᙳ⊝ᙢEᙳᒴᙢ••♦૘Thegn>wtliofhighereducationmanifestsitselfinatleastthreequitedifferentways,andtheseintunihavegivenrisetodifferentsetsofproblems.RSᦟḄ⊤5¡ᯠ£ḄM¤<¥cz£Ḅ⊤5M¤¦ᩭ¨C©"{ᑡᔜᔜ᪵Ḅ«⚪221•

34"#$⛲inatleastthreequitedifferentways.&'()*@10+ḄM¤1)I@1BThegrowthofhighereducationmanifestsitself@-+h+4B+,-.ÀndḄᑡ+2andtheseinturnhavegivenriseto@hffererd^ets^fprob^ms.@-+h+4B:'=>?manifest*['manifest]vt.Å5E⊤a.Å¥᧕ÇḄgiverisetoCDEG૙Therewasfirstiherateofgrowth:inmanycountriesofWesternEurope,thenuinbcrsofstudentsinhighereducationdoubledwithinfive-yearperiodsduringthe1960sanddoubledagaininseven.eight,or10yearsbythemiddleofIhe1970s.✌ᐜÊË᳛k2060,ÍÎJÏÐRSᦟḄPᦪÒ5Ó"Ô<ᑮ70Ö.czPᦪᙠ7ஹ80ᡈ100ÙÓ©"Ô+,-.Therewasfirsttherateofgrowth:@Therebe+ÚkThere+was+-BTÛ?therateofgrowththenumbersofstudentsinhighereducationdoubledwithinfive-yearperiods"#$⛲andḄᑡh)anddoubledagaininseven...or10years&'()*ᙢÜ1)inmanycountriesofWesternEurope,&'()*/01)#$⛲duringthe1960s&'()*/01)bythemiddleofthe1970s.૚Second,growthobviouslyaffectedtheabsolutesizebothofsystemsandindividualinstitutions.ᐸÞ.RSᦟḄÅᯠßà©ᦟ{á\ᓫãᦟä᪀Ḅæçè"#$⛲Second,____________1éᐭ)+,-.growthobviouslyaffectedtheabsolutesize-+h+4B&'()*89)j$⛲ihcabsolutesize"#$⛲bothofsystemsandindividualinstitutions.'=>?absolute*[*®bsalu,t]a.æḄEëᐰḄinstitution*[|institju:Jn]Hä᪀Eᑴî૛Xndihird,growthwasreflectedinchangesinth$"proportionof'therelevanta^e“nroIlMininstitutionsofhighereducation.?reflect*[nflekt]vt.⊤5;¦᧜EÅùproportion*[prapozjn]n.ñò;úû;üᑖ12221

35•••OEachofthesemanifestationsofgrowthcarrieditsownpeculiarproblemsinitswake.ýḄ⊤5M¤,Ò"þÿḼᐸᱯᨵḄ⚪Eachofthesemanifestationsofgrowthcarrieditso^pecujiarproblems(++)]'()⛲initswake.:manifestation[imaemfesteijn]n.⊤⊤peculiar*[prkju:lia(r)]a.ᱯᨵḄ;!"Ḅinone'swakeinthewakeof...Ḽ...$ᩭ;&....Ḅ'(૙Forexample,ahighgrowthrateplacedgr<*alstrainsonIlieexistingstnicturesofgovernance.ofadministration.andaboveallMsocialization.)᝞,,-.᳛01Ḅ2ᳮ'᪀ஹ678᪀9:ᐸ;<=ᓄ'᪀?⌼ᡂBCᜧḄEF஺'()⛲Forexample,[Iᐭahighgrowthrateplacedgreatstrains(++)[9⊤LMTR)⛲ontheexistingstructures|andNOPᑡḄRST9U⛲theexistingstructures+()⛲ofgovernance,ofadministration,andaboveallofsocialization.strain*[strem]WEFXYZFgovernance[,gAvanans]n.2ᳮ[\administration*[admmi,streijn]n.6792ᳮsocialization[^aujalarzeijn]n.<=ᓄ(૚Whenafaculty<»r(l<*partni<*ntgrowsfrom,say,fiveto20memberswithinthreeorfouryears,andwhenthenewstaffan-predominantlyyoungnirnandwomenfreshfrom|H>stgraduatestudy.theylargelydefineIhrnormsofacademiclifeinthalfae]y,)᝞9^_`a▾ᡈdᙠfghiᑁk5`ᡂᕒmnᑮ20`ᡂᕒ,p^qḄᕒrᜧs;ttuᡂv9rwaxḄ☘iᵱ᝕|.}~ᙠᜧTa▾Ḅaw,()⛲freshfrompostgraduatestudy,R,-..])⛲youngmenandwomenandwhenthenewstaffarepredominantlyyoungmenandwomen_()⛲|andNOPᑡḄ|kWhenafacultyordepartmentgrowsfrom,say,fiveto20memberswithinthreeorfouryears,[whenḄ|k9Ḅ|theylargelydefinethenonnsofacademic\ife++RST;U⛲thenormsofacademiclife'()⛲inthatfaculty.:faculty*[faklti]W.,▾᪥Ḅdஹ▾staff*[sta:f]n,ᐰr(ᡈᕒ)predominantly[pridominantli]ad.⌕ᙢsᦪfreshfromtᔊ¢...Ḅdefine*[drfam]vt.T0....T▊academic*[◕kademik]a.aḄQAndifiht*|M)stgru(luuh,student|M)pulali<)nalsogn>wsrapidlyandthereislossofacloseapprenticeshiprelationshiplielweerifacultymembersandstudents,thestudentculturebecomesthechiefsocializingforcefornewpostgraduatestudents,withconsequencesfortheintellectualandacademiclifeoftheinstitution——thiswasseeninAmericaaswellasitiFrance.Italy.ViOEiany,midJapan.¤|9᝞(Ẇ¦w§ᦪ¨©ª-..«w¬Ḅ®a¯ᐵd±ᜫ,³´awᦻᓄ¶=ᡂ&Ẇ¦wqw<=ᓄ¢·Ḅ⌕F¸¹a▾Ḅº»w¼aw_ᙠ½¾ஹ¿¾ஹÀᜧᑭஹÂüÄÅ?ᨵÆÇM223

36ÈU⛲betweenfacultymembersandstudents,RST.IU⛲acloseapprenticeshiprelationshipandthereislossofacloseapprenticeshiprelationship|andNOḄPᑡ_ÈU⛲ifthepostgraduatestudentpopulationalsogrowsrapidly[ifḄᩩÊk,ḄᩩÊAnd...thestudentculturebecomesthechiefsocializingforce+d+⊤RST9;U⛲ihechiefsocializingforcefornewpostgraduatestudents,_ÈU⛲withconsequencesfortheintellectualandacademiclifeoftheinstitution⊡ᐙÍ—thiswasseeninAmericaaswellasinFrance,Italy,WestGennany,andJapan.apprenticeship[oprentijip]Wa¯Îa¯rintellectual*[.mtolektjuol]ÏFḄhHighgn»wlhratesincreasedthechancrsforacademicinnovation;theyalsoweakenedthefonnsandprocessesbywhichteachersandstink'ntsar<-admittedintoacumniunityofscholarsduringperiodsofstabilityorslowgniwtli.,ÐÑÒ᳛-ÓBaÔqḄÕ=;¤|¨ÖᓄBᦟ«¼awᙠØTÎᡈÙ᠒-.ÎÛOÜÓᐭaὅÞᡠ◤Ḅá¼¢஺_ÈU⛲foracademicinnovation;RST9[U⛲thechanceslHighgrowthratesincreasedthechances++IPᑡ2theyalsoweakenedtheformsandprocesses++whichḄTk.[U⛲theformsandprocesses_ÈU⛲bywhichteachersandstudentsareadmittedintoacommunityofscholarsITkḄ|ÈU⛲duringperiodsofstabilityorslowgrowth.weaken[wi,kan]r.âÖãÖadmit[admit]vt.äå...Óᐭ;äå....æᐭoInthe1960sand1970s,Euro]*anuniversitirssawmarkedchangesiniheirgoveniancrarrangements,withtheempowermentofjuniorfacultyandtosomedegreeofstudentsaswell.20çèéêᓝ,iì9íîᜧaḄ2ᳮï᣸mwBñ℉óᓄ•õÈᦟᕒÛö÷r2ᳮᩗ9awᙠ_T¨ùᨵB2ᳮᩗ_ÈU⛲Inthe1960sand1970s.[Ḅ|Europeanuniversitiessawmarkedchanges++RST9[U⛲markedchangesintheirgoveniancearrangemenls,_ÈU⛲Ḅwiththeempowerment[andNOPᑡḄRST9U⛲ᵫeenipowennentÈU⛲ofjuniorfacultyandtosomedegreeofstudentsaswell.see*[si:]vt.ᔊûṣmarked[ma:kt]a.ñ℉Ḅñ$᧕Ḅarrangement[areindsmant]n.ï᣸ᖪTþSempowerment[impaoamont]n.ᩗᑭ224

37ᦑ⁚᪀⌹⌕“ᐭ”!!"#PS$ὃẆ'()*+,-.ᙳ〉ᵨ!

当前文档最多预览五页,下载文档查看全文

此文档下载收益归作者所有

当前文档最多预览五页,下载文档查看全文
温馨提示:
1. 部分包含数学公式或PPT动画的文件,查看预览时可能会显示错乱或异常,文件下载后无此问题,请放心下载。
2. 本文档由用户上传,版权归属用户,天天文库负责整理代发布。如果您对本文档版权有争议请及时联系客服。
3. 下载前请仔细阅读文档内容,确认文档内容符合您的需求后进行下载,若出现内容与标题不符可向本站投诉处理。
4. 下载文档时可能由于网络波动等原因无法下载或下载错误,付费完成后未能成功下载的用户请联系客服处理。
最近更新
更多
大家都在看
近期热门
关闭