法律实在性讨论——兼为概念法学辩护

《法律实在性讨论——兼为概念法学辩护》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在教育资源-天天文库。

ᙠឋ——ᭆஹ⚪ḄᙠḄᢧᡊᙠḄᱥᐹᨵᙠឋḄ#Ḅᱥ$%ᙠḄ஺'(ᭆ*+,-./0Ḅ*12ᓾ456ᐹᨵᙠឋ஺2ᐹᨵᙠឋḄ7ᕡḼ:ᱥ;᪵ᐹᨵ=ᙠ>?@(ABCDᐹᨵ▭Fᵨ஺ᙠᭆ*+,-.ὅḄI@(ᵨᭆᡈKᑣᩭN=ᙢ⊤QRSTUᭆᡈKᑣ@(N=ᙢVWXYFᵨ஺ḄTZ▭Fᵨᢣ\ḄY]XY^=Ḅ_N=Ḅ+`=ḄaKᦔdᡈᦔe஺3fghijklmḄ“opl+”ᩩstuvᙠw/xᩩsyztuv{|}~6tuvᙠḄ஺4h*i₈/᪵{ᳮឋKḄᙠឋy@ᐹᨵᙠឋᡈ`=ḄKFᵨḄᳮᵫᙠzzoḄᫀyᩭ@☠Ḅoᨵ¡¢£¤¥Ḅ¦?§@Qᑮ(©ªឋᡈ«¬ᑣ/®Ḅ஺ᡠ(°ᢝᙠ7.²³7ᕡḼ´h5ḄN}--\5᜽}ᐹᨵ·¸,Dwº⍳¼஺56½´h5¾ᙠᾭ4ÀᐸÂẠ°ᙢÄ᪷ᙠᙠឋḄÆ஺ᐹᨵᙠឋ7ᕡḼ@(⚜ÈḄ_}ᨵ7.Ḅa\ḄY]@(⚜ᐜ¥ÊᑴÌÍ᣸Ḅ▭ÏÐḄ`=ÑÒ@(ÓÔḄ஺

1ᙠᓝÖV×+ØᓝV×ḄU*ὅ;Ùᙠ12Úᑮvᝰᶧ஺TZᝰᶧᜧÞ⊤ᙠ@ឋ+@Êឋߦ☢஺“@ឋ”ᝰᶧ-⌕⊤/ᝰᶧᭆᔲãḄ@ᐹᨵᙠ஺ä“@Êឋ”ᝰᶧᑣ-⌕⊤/T᪵Ḅå᝞çᙠḄRèéyêᭆḄK⊤QTy¬ëìíî\ḄY]ÚᑴᭆVWᔩðVWᐹÞḄVWYñ]òSóôgõRᭆöhF/÷Ḅøùúᱥ᝞ûóô+ᐹÞVW4üý³þÿḄ
ᵞᙠḄᙠᡃḄᐹᕖᙠ!"#$%&'()*ᐵ,)-./ᙠḄᵫ123)-456ᭆ89Ḅ:);<ᙠ)-=>ᐹ?@ḄAB▲?@Ḅ஺EF6GHIJKLL6$ᵞ,,ᭆ8MNḄ)*ᢳPAᧅR஺ᙠᓝTUVWᭆ8)*XᔣḄὤ᪍>\K℉^Ḅᑭ`)*᳛ᐜcdᡭ᎔“)*Ḅᭆ8ᜩ”Ḅjklᔙ)*“☢o/▭”qᐭᐹḄῳᙢ⚞ᶍwḄB▲xᐝ஺6$zὤ᪍{|ᨵᔲ)-/ᙠឋḄឋ|ᨵᐰᔲ)-/ᙠឋḄNឋ)-ᑣḄ⌕.o)-/ᙠoᓄ,ូᭆ8)*Ḅ%A஺ᡭᙠKḄᭆ8ᓄḄ)ᐺ/¡¢£#“ᑭ`”“¥Ḅ”᪵Ḅ§¨©ª⏨)ᐺḄ¬N®¯°Ḽ²Ḅ“ᑭ`”³´µ)¶·ᙠ)ᐺḄᭆ8¸¹¢º·»¼ᐹ

2Ḅᵫ½¾஺o,)-/ᙠᨬÀ┦ḄᢣÃ$.Äὤ᪍ÅL.$"ᙠᭆ8)*ÆᱛᛞḄ)*É஺»ÊËÌMḄÍ6)-/ᙠ.ÎÏ₠ÑḄ$Ò.$NḄ.$Ḅ஺Í6)-ᐹᨵ/ᙠឋḄ:).$Ó/Ḅ#ᨵÔ//ᙠ|ᨵ)-/ᙠ஺Õ20A30ÙÚᐶÜḄÔ/)*Ý°ᨬ6ᐺÞßᜮáâᢣᔣ)-/ᙠ஺ᙠã¢)-ᑣᐹᨵ/ᙠឋḄ:).»äåᣉẚḄèé)-ᑣêᒹìᑨî)ᙠᑁð$⚜ò$ó·⚜ò஺)-Ô/ô»õ⊤÷ᙠøùú•
JosephW.Bingham1912ḄḄᦻ!஺
ᙠ$ᦻ%&ᙢ▊)*+,-./0Ḅᳮ23Ạ56789:;/0<Ẇ>ᐹ@Ḅஹ᜜ᙠḄ+CDᑡ5/0Ẇ>Ḅ⚞GᒹI᜜ᙠJK+CLᐸᐹ@NOPQR5SᑣUVᙠWXYḄᜮᾯ!5\]Vᙠ^“ᩗᑭ”c:dᵨfghiḄjk5clSᑣmnoᑖdPqrḄ“stuᐹ”5vᶍᙢx5ᙠ⚞G5\y:z{,|ᐸᢣ~5VᙠḄmᐹ@Ḅ+C஺7ᯠ78.Ḅ]Vᙠ+,hiḄ56:X2]ᓄᑮ+,!ᵨ5ᓽ],ᙠᙢ,஺+,-.ᔲ,ᙠ25ᐸ,▭ᔲḄ

3ᡂ஺SᑣḄ.ᔲh¡5+,-.Ḅ¢£5SᑣḄ.]஺hW,ᙠ283ẠḄ0¤¥ᩭx5+,-.ḄQ2⌕&¨Ḅ஺ᡃªᐙ¬®ᙢ¯°;Ḅ±᪀5ᐙ¬³ᙢ´ᑴᡈ⚜¯¸P:᦮ᝅ5»ᙠ+,-.Ḅ¼!5ᐸ.᪷¾]¿:À஺ᡠ50¤¥᝞R]ÃÄᙢ¢£+,-.ÀḄÅÆ5]8,ᙠ2ÇÈᨵᦔḄËÌ5ÍᕡḼÐ7]5ÑÒNᑣ],஺¾ᦻÓᙠc:Æ⚪®ÕÖ5×Ø8ᭆ0ᙠᑁḄ0¤¥Û“,ᙠ2”ÜÝÞßàḄËá5âᢝ0¤¥ᐵW“åᯠ”Ḅ᪷¾æ஺ᭆ0Ḅ᩽èæéᯠᨵᐸêYëᎢḄíîឋ5»ᐸ᪶ñstÛ—,ᙠ2Lᵫ¡ôõḄ5åᯠᐹᨵ]ö÷Ḅᐝù஺úஹ+,-.hûüឋḄᔲ+,-.ᡈ+,-.0ᨵḼᱯḄþ.5^ÿ
Ḅᵨஹᨵᡠ஺8(OliverWendellHolmes)9ஹ()(JohnChipmanGray)10>45(RoscoePound)11Ḅ:;<=>?@ABCC<┯>ᙢFᐭHᑣᔲK஺L@M(ᙢNOPQRᨵḼTQ:ḄU஺AB

4TḄab@ABcdefgᙠ[@ijklmnPḄkY@_o`TiFpHᑣḄqr@qsᐹᨵuK
ḄHᑣḄNPOvḄN@ᡠwOxPᓫRḄjᑨ{|}஺AB~ᔲKjᑨ{xᓽABᡠw@`Tᡠwj?ᐹᨵឋ@qsḄ{KPslḄ|Oᣍ᥎஺Qqs@ᩲ•ᐲ12ஹᓲ᪍13=PL¡⊤=ᱥ஺ᩲ•ᐲN@Pᵫ“{Kᡠ¦ᡂ”,“HᑣªªP«¬”14஺ᓲ᪍qs@“®¯ḄHᑣ”°▭²ᵨḄHᑣv³ḄHᑣᨵᑖµḄ¶@·“¶Ḅ²ᵨ”¸¹º»@|“▭Ḅ²ᵨ”ᓾᐹᨵk½Ḅ»⌕
¿`Ti«¬ÀHÁÂÃLḄ«¬ÄpÅὃḄÇ᯿ÉÊPᨵM»Ë▲Ḅ@ÍÎiHᑣÏnÐÑḄÒÓᡠw²ᵨp“ᡠᨵqs〉ᔠÖᩩØḄ=”@“ÍPᙠmÙÚÛÜᜐpÞᎷḄàᏉâḄ|ãäÖḄåæ”,PçèḄ|éêëḄ஺ᡠÀANì“ᙠᡃmᩭ@Íïᕒஹñòஹóôஹõöஹ÷søùᡠúḄûüýPkl஺”15Lὅᔲ
ᙠឋᐸᶍឋ⌕⊤ᑨឋḄᔲ
஺Ḅ“”!᝞#$%&'()*'+,
ᙢ./ᡠ1234ᙠḄ5ᑣ789ᑨ:;⚜
ᡈ5ᑣḄᙠឋ>?!@ABC஺ᔲ
ឋᨬEḄFᧇHI!JKL•STU

5(JosephC.Hutcheson)&Ḅ1929hi&Ḅjklᑨ%⚜mḄn+o@ᦻ஺STUq@A&'!☠〉ᵨ5ᑣu!☠jk78Ḅ஺“vḄ☠mku'!ᑨw☠⚜mu'!ᔠᳮᓄᩭ|
ᔠᳮᓄ}}ᙠᳮᵫ␺
%஺ᑨḄᐵឋ!ᱯ
ᫀ%,┯ḄḄjkḄ&ᙠ|
ᵨḄ@+*Ḅᜮᾯ'}ᔣ¡¢jku£¤¥3¦ᢇ¨ὅª«஺”16ᩲ®•¯ᐲ±²¢³´µ¶·¸ᙠ1930hi»³´o@¼½¾ᙢ¿ᵨÀSTUḄÁᑨ%Ḅ“ÂÃÄ”|ÀÅÆÇḄÈ¡஺q@AÉḄÊËÌÊÍζÏᐭÑÒ@Ò¶FᧇḄjÓÔÕẠ×@Ò¶᝞ØAÉÙÚËÛ᪗¢᪵ḄÞßàáâÕẠ@Ò&ḄᑴJ*'ä·åÉæ஺áᙠçèéêë“ÂÃÄ”Í4ᙠáâᙠᑨ%ì|ᵨ*£!íî¢ᑨḄïáâ¢ᙠðñòóôÀឋḄÎ+ឋ஺&ḄᑨḄᳮᵫᡈ␺
ᑣõ!“ᔠᳮᓄ”Ḅ@ö÷øùᵨᩭ¡ᵫú&AÉḄÞßu⌱üḄÂÃáᑨᳮᵫ*'vᙢýþ&᝞è|
Ḅ஺17
Ḅ⊤ᙠḄᑣḄ஺Ḅ!"#$%&Ḅ'ᳮឋ*+Ḅ,☄./ᔲ12345ᙠ671Ḅ!"

69:;<⚪>?@A?BCᙠḄEᦑGH:;ᯠJ〉ᵨMN᪷5PQᵫSTUVWXYḄᳮᵫZᫀ\Jᵨ
]^_%6`abCcd^ᡈfᶍ஺*hiᦑᙠឋ@jkᡂḄᡠnopqWḄᐹsḄ!"஺18tஹ23&Ḅᔜcwx☢&ὅ&ᙠ{Ḅᢧᡊ23▣⃩(
Ḅp1ᢣ>ᙠ{ὅ)☢Ḅwx?ᐹᨵᙠឋ஺bwxᨵᑣᑖ᪆#Ḅ,ᨵ᪀ᡈᑖ᪆#ḄᨵᐶPᯠW#Ḅ஺ᦻ▲¡¢h£ᑖ⌕ᑣᑖ᪆%᪀¥ᡈᑖ᪆Ḅwx᦮ᳮ஺§ᐶPᯠWḄwxᵫ¨©ᩖ«ᑮᙠឋ®ᩖḄ¯⚪ᶍH@°ὃ²ᶇ´ᦻẆ¶஺(-)ᑣᑖ᪆Ḅwx1ஹ¸¹ºḄᑁ£W²¼½¾¿ÀḄÁÂÕ¸¹ºᨬÅᵨᑁ£W²ḄWᩭ{ᙠឋḄ஺#ᵨᑁ£W²ḄWÇ

7%$ᑣḄᙠឋ஺¸¹ºÈ>@ᐹᨵÉ&Ê1ឋᓽÈ>ᙠCSÌÍ⚞ÏᙠxᵨᑣÇA«ᑮ⌱ÑÒÓ⊝bÇ"Ö⌼ឋᑨÙḄÚAÛᩭ”஺a¸¹ºÝÇᢇßὅᵨ“᜜£W²ὅḄW”ᑖ᪆ᵫâᑣ©ãäឋᭆæÛᙠᑨçḄᑖ᪆9èᐭ┯ëWì஺¸¹º>?ᑁᙠḄíîᑖ᪆,Ḅ¥ïឋḄ@ÝðñᑣòóÌÍᨬôḄ*+஺ᑣÒÌÍ<⚪õᑜ#Cᩩp▲bC<⚪ᐹᨵឋÒᭆìឋøḼúûḄü▲ÌÍ%ᑣ?§Ạ“þᵫᑣḄ▲ᑴ

ḄᨵᐵḄ⚪19⍡Ḅᓫᙢᢝ"ᑣḄᑁᙠ▲ᑴឋ)ᨵ*+,┐./012Ḅ34ឋ⚪*5678Ḅᑖ᪆஺202ஹ=>Ḅ?@0ABC?@0ADEὅ=>.0GHAIᙠJᐭ0AḄ⚞ᙢMNO⇋஺QRSTὅUVW▭᝞Z5S[ᙠ\ᩭ^᝞Z5S_`0a▭bcde0aᦔgḄ⌕ijklmnḄGHḄ▭5Sopqᙠ0rstᓄv஺21wxQy⌕┐.0GHA*5vᳮ{|}஺lᡠ“0a?@ᑖ᪆”ᐭ=>.0"ᑣ"Ḅᭆo᪀ᑖ᪆.0aḄᦔg᪷[0aᵨ*5▊ᩭ0GHAḄ[GH40aஹ[lVW▭᝞Z*5GH5Sᩭ_`l0aᦔgḄBC஺Qᢣ0aḄᦔᦔgḄ¡ᦔVW▭5SḄ+¢ᱯឋ

8¥S0aḄᱯឋᦔg¦0aḄᱯឋ§ᦔᦔgḄ+¨ᩩªxj«஺22ᵫ"ᑣᦔgḄ®ẠI0aᐹᨵᙠឋḄ®Ạᡠ[=>."ᑣᦔgḄ®ẠḄ{±[ᐵ0aᦔ0GHA²³Ḅe⌕´ᢝḄµ¶ᨵ▲Ḅ{·▭¸᩽Sᨵᦔᙢ|}v0aºy¶ὅ»ᑮv½¾0aᙠ{ஹᢇ/0Àµ{Ḅᦔp஺=>Á8ᙢᑖ᪆v0aᦔgᳮᵫᨵᐵḄ®Ạ"⚪஺QRS+ÂḄ0aÃÄ⚜nvÆ0Ç+®Ạ"È᪀ᡂvÂᑁ0aÃÄḄᨬËÌnᎷÎឋ®ẠÏÐᡲvᨬÒḄ⌼0ᩗÕ஺®Ạ"SᎷÎḄᙠ0ᩩªÈÖ×ᙠ0jᵫØÙ®Ạ"Ḅ⌼05S®Ạ5SÚᩭ஺ÇÛḄ®Ạ"⚜nḄµᕡḼÞß?±y¶Ḅ᛻áÈ⌕ᨬâ▲ãḄäᯠ0æÇ¢ᑁçᐰéêëìíîḄᐜëᩩªjÞᐰéêëìíî᜜ḄᐜëñjAwxÖòó34Ḅôᱥj?y4Ḅö÷wx+øᡠḄäᯠ0஺ᵫᙠ0◤⌕ᐸᦔgᡠû◤ḄᦔឋüãÈḄᑁçý+¢GHᙳ⊝Ḅ⊤ᡈὅḄ஺23ᑁḄẠᙠᨵ▭ᐸᦔᳮᵫ!"#$ḄᎷ&,ᙠᨵ▭ᐸᦔᳮᵫᑣᵫ▭Ḅ)ᦔឋ+ᑣ,-ᙠ▭.᪷0)ᦔឋ+ᑣ,-ᑜ-2Ḅ3▲Ḅ஺▭ḄẠᑣ56789:⌼<=)Ḅ஺24>?@ABCDẠḄEᡂ+GHI"J஺KᢣMK

9ḄNO)PᳮQḄI"ẠR"ᢇᑨḄI"ᵫUVWR"ḄBXYZ[\H]^VW_᜜ḄᐜW⚞cḄdefghᑮYjkhḄl▲ឋmnopq<rstuEsN"ḄvhQswᔣR"yḄvhQz{EsN"Ḅ#|}~vhQᨵ~[vhᡠᜐḄyᩩḄ,-஺}~vhQvhQᡈᐗQᙠUYZᙠVWᩞᧇN⌕᪷0ᳮឋᑁᙠᑣ:⌼KḄD}~vhQR"ḄᙠUVWR"ᓾfᑮ஺ẠᎷ&ḄᐜWḄsR"vhḄQ஺25r}5gN,ẠḄẠᦔᳮᡂḄ஺⍡¢Ḅ>?@ᙠ£¤¥¦§¨⚪ᓽᙠᜐᳮ<ᑣ¥«¬Ḅ◞¯}°\)±ᑭᵨḄ´µ¶MH5ᡠ·¸¹᪾»¼½H¨⚪ᐵ¿஺KᙠÀᢝÂvᙠÃḄẠNᑴ-ḄÅḄÆv¥,-ÇÈᓽÉÈʯᒹÌÍÎÊᕒµÇὅ஺ÅᑣÊḄ,-Çᑣ}᪵ᐸK"ὅÑÒᡠÓQḄᑣ¥Ḅ◞¨⚪ÔÕKÖᓄH஺ᙠᜐᳮ}ØÈḄᐵÙKᨬÛAܼ½¨⚪ᨬÛKÂvÅDÝÈᩭᐹᨵ)ᙠឋ஺K“5áᵫ<〉ᵨãᐵäᐸᵫ▾:⌼æçèᵫ5ᡈ¸5éêḄÅᩭ,-஺}~,-……ìᨵÆḄí஺▾îï⌕ᵫ,-ZḄ2ᑨ,ᑁ6ḄÅḄðñ஺”26

10èḄᩭ>?@Ḅôõᑖ᪆øùúHûü"\)±"D<ᦔ<)ᦔØ5ƨ⚪ᙠý~gNḄgþÿ
ᑖᜲᜧḄẠḄ◍஺!"#$%&ᙠឋḄ)*ᙠ+,-☢$/◞1⚪Ḅ34567Ḅᡈ9ᡈ:;<=஺>Ḅ?ᙠ@AᙠBḄᦔ<ᳮᵫḄẠB⚜H@IᯠᐹᨵᢇᑨḄOᵨ⌕RᢇSTᐺVᯠᳮWX67ḄᙠYZ☢᪷\]ᨵ^_`a“ᳮឋ”1⚪ᡠe$ḄfgᢇSὅᒹ!"#&ᭆᑖ᪆Ḅᓫᓄᔣ&9᪵ឋz&BᑣḄ/◞஺>R/◞ᵫ&ᭆ&BᑣḄ“᪀”4ᡂḄ&ᭆBᑣᨵ“᪀”Ḅ▢WᑨᑴH¡ᐹᨵ¢⌴Ḅ+¤Hឋ¥¦Ḅ§ᱯ¨ᨵ©ª«ᦑḄ஺“$ªᭆḄ‘¯°'ᡈ᝞³´µᡠ@ḄᭆḄ‘¶·᪀'----Ḅz᝞ᡃᡠ@hYºᑖ᪆Ḅt4»ᡠ¼Ḅ½℉ᱯ¨஺”27lᱯIᯠz&Ḅ᪀ᓾÁÂnÃ&ḄᙠW஺>ÄÅZ☢nÃ&BᑣḄᙠឋf$ḄÆឋ஺

11ᐸ>ÄẆÉ¥¦ḄᱯqÊ~ËÊ¥¦Ḅ᪀ᨵ▲=Ḅ«¥¦ÌÍḄ᪀ÎÏËÐ▲=XÑᨵÒ9ᢈÔÕeÖ⊡ᡈØ⁚ÚÛBᑣᝰᶧW┯ßḄàáḄHVᵫâᙠ▲=ãᑁ஺ᜧ9ᦪàÂᨵåBᑣORᢣç᪗éXêÊᓽìᨵḄàÂ☠,îêÊhᨵïORðËXᨵ⍳òḄBᑣᡠuᡂ,ÑBᑣôõöᫀøḄùᐵឋûüýzḄ஺28ᐸþ>ÿ
ᑣᦔẠᑖ᪆“
ᑣḄᑁᙠ☢Ḅᱯ”
ᑣ⌕ᙠᨵ!᝞#$%&'(ᨵᐵ*+,-./0-+᦮02⍳4Ḅ5᪗789#:Ḅ;⌕ᱯ஺ᵫ>?ᢇABᵨDEFGBDEὅḄ⚜JK--MNO᜜Q*+ᑨS#:9TU஺29ᐵV#:ḄᦔẠ?W+ᨵXYW
ᑣZḄ[ᓫ]^0Gᙠ$ᕒᡈabc#:Ḅ5BdeᙠGf#:ᑴhe8ᨬj
ᑣk2lmnᩖpqḄ#:rs⌕tpqḄuW᪗7vwZḄᙠ9xBy⚪{9-+#▾ஹ$ᕒFa~᪗7uW#:8XnᩖḄBdᙠ&'ᑁᙠḄNZ,-9uḄ#ᑨwᐳḄஹḄ᪗7p9#${Ḅhᓫᙢ஺ᙠYW
ᑣᨵM▲V$஺30ᐸ¡ᱯᙠ¢ᢝ⌕#:F⍝¥¦ᑖ§ᩭ©?pª«BcDEὅ¬᪵®ᯠpὃ⇋⍝¥ὶ³YW⍝¥´#:ᙠµ#ஹ#¶·

12☢ᨵ¸¹º»¼´#:ᢇAᡈᢙ¾¿?ÀpÁ«BcDEὅ¬᪵®ᯠpÂt#:ḄÃḄ?W+“#:ÄᨵÅÆᑁÇ”ḄBcDEÈ⚪9p´ḄW+ḄÉᱯឋËÌ9ÄÍΓᨵᐵÏḄᯠÐ᛻FÃḄḄÒxB+ẠḄஹWḄ*+ÓᑣÄÔW+9ᯠ#ḄᨬÕ▲hḄᑁÇ”ḄÖ>#:F⍝¥92ᨵᱯᑁÇᡈ◤⌕+ᨬÕ▲hḄᑁÇḄ஺8᪵?ᙠ#:Øឋ☢ÙË,#Ú#:
ḄBᙠឋÜÝÙÞᳮᵫàá஺31¡ᱯ+#:BᙠឋḄâãµäV
ᑣᑁᙠḄåºæçᐭᑮᦔẠḄêKÙË“YW
ᑣ”Ö>9lmᨵḄ஺p,?ìᨵᐹ0ὃO#$îïḄð⁚Ö>ÀÚìᨵòóGBDE#ôᔲW#öNឋḄ÷ÝK஺?ÀìᨵÚ#:BᙠKøùḄᳮឋy⚪úûᐹçhḄüôý᪆஺þ᜜ÀᨵôὅW+?ḄYW
ᑣlmᱫ32o
᪀ḄḄឋ▊ᳮᑖ᪆!Ḅ"ὅ$ᙠ&ᑣḄ☟᝱ḄᑁᙠḄᑖ᪆+$,-./ᙠឋ0/&ᑣ12Ḅᑁᙠ3ឋ⊤5஺7089:ᨵ</=>8?@Aᔠᳮᑖ᪆$CDEFGHᙢJ$Kᵫ8?,/ᙠឋḄឋNO⌕QRSTUV᝞XYᯠ[U\ᢝ^ᩭ`ᡈὅ,$RSTbcdᙠ=?ᙠḄ>efᡈὅgcḄ>e

13f`hijᜧ"ᳮ"✌mᦟᣴ$pqrstᵫuv"w$x0=?“z>”|}</ᙠឋ@A~cJḄ"w஺<z>ḄឋN᪀$D0ᐸ$᝞☢ᑮḄᑖ᪆$ᩭᡂᐸ℉Ḅ",Ḅ஺<uvὅ/Ḅ$Cឋ▊Ḅ|}Aᐵ/Ḅcv$R/0ᡠ/&cᡈὅ,ᐜ$/0=▊ឋᭆ$/&cO/0/Ḅᨵᡂ¡ᑖ70/12஺,“z¢U▊ᐸzᑨ¤ST0/Ḅ>$¥cST0/஺”33¦-§$¨▊ᑮ./Ḅ1©Ḅª«஺Ḅ8¬0®ᑮ5q¯"Ḅ°±D²ᡂḄ஺5q¯"Ḅ³"´Ạ¶0dᙠuv,u⌕Ḅq⊤Fᱥ0¸¹º»஺¸¹º»±¼.½»Ḅ¾¿$┐<´ẠḄÁÂḄ¯"ᐵ¯ὅÃUÄÅÆÇḄuÈ34,AÃÉdᙠ=tᙠḄÊË$

14u¾Ḅ”$ᢣᳮ¯+ᡠ±òḄö0ÕO5ᙠḄ=Ö¯$÷¢Íëø.ὅḄᨵHùᑴ஺35spq¬wûüýþᙠÿ
ḄᢇḄᑖ᩽ḄὅᡂᓫᔣḄ--ὅ!"Ꮇ$%&'(ὅ)*+,-.ᐸᡠ▊Ḅ2ᑗ456789▊:;<ឋḄ)>:?@AḄ▊Ꮇ$(ὅBC%▊ὅDᑮFG஺4567IJ89ᩗLMNᵫ2PBCᙠᔠSᵨUVSᵨᩗLWX(YZឋ\ᑖḄᢇᑨᳮ_ᩭa,bc:de9ᳮ_ᙠbPᳮ_@fḄᳮᓄhij“@fḄlᳮD”(discourseethics)nᑮ+8o,pqb᪵4567stuvbwhixyzឋb{ᶧ}8+@f,ᩗL~:ឋḄ⚞஺36ᙠᜧᔾᦈ+4567DḄ஺j“”$9Ḅ“;<ឋḄ▊”*ᡠᳮḄZᑣUWXX◞Ḅᙠ(+ᓝᑖḄᔲ8஺:ᐭ“᦮¢ឋ£ᑣ”SḄ“;<ឋ▊”ᐹᨵ¦2§ឋ¨©ªᨵ«ᐭ-¬▣⃩¯°±²+()Ḅµ$ឋ஺᦮¢ឋ£ᑣ:Ḅᐵ·ឋᭆ¹º᦮¢ឋ(92»¼½ᳮ¾ᔠ¿+ᡃḄÁÂ᪀,Á-ÄḄᱯឋᔲᑣbwᱯÆcÇÈÉÊ᦮¢ឋË9¼½ÌḄ£ᑣÍAB9¼½ᔠឋiYÎᐸÏÍAÐÑḄÒ²“ϼ½¬Ó(2Ô▤ÖḄ×جӿx©*ÙᢝÏ”37,¨©J+“ᔠឋÜ⚪”———Ḅß!"ᡠàḄ᝞â9
ãᑴLḄeSiå2PæḄ§N

15ᳮᵫ,“}8᦮¢ឋ9ᐸ¼½ᳮḄ
Îᔲ8b»ßḄ
ÐÑ”38oᵫ©èc:éᒹë2ᑗḄ᦮¢ឋḄᑨJ£ᑣÙìḄ▊Ḅᭆ¹“í»ᑨî:ᵫ▊Ḅ>o⚞,bw⚞Ḅ>oï☢ᡠ᪀ᡂ஺ᡃñòᑮᔜ»ᐵ'ôõஹ§¬,÷øḄ§NùḄú¹᝞âû©ᢙ⊝஺▊ឋḄᑨî!"ñò,ὃ⇋
Ḅ⚞ᔲᑣាḄᡈᜫḄ஺ᯠ▊!"#
⚞$ᔠᡂ'()ᐰ☢Ḅ,-./⍝12345ᐰ☢ὃ⇋89:;)▊<=>?Ḅ@ABCᨬE.FG@AᑨIᐙKLMḄ”39,O@AP⚪Rᨵ“UVḄWᫀ”@AY◞P⚪[ᙠḄ஺401]^Ḅ@A“_`ឋḄ▊”bcd[ᙠefᨵgᑗḄὶjᓾd@AlmefὅḄopᨵ᪷rst஺1]^Ꮥᣚw@Aᭆy#z/{@ὅḄ“⚜}~ᑣ”'@Ḅ“_`ឋ▊”OᓾᨵFG@AmᙠM@Ḅឋ஺✌ᐜ#@A'mḄᱥᯠᙠmḄYᑮwzḄᑣV}ឋ஺mfḄ@AᭆyᯠV}Ḅஹ}Ḅஹ⚜Ḅ_`Ḅஹ¡Ḅ஺@¢ᑮ“᦮¤ឋ”ᑣḄ¥¦§¨©=ᙠª«Ḅ¬Ạ®¯ᑏ“±²”Ḅ³«8´=µḄ஺“¶(U-”@5'Ḅ·¸@AmᙠMḄ³¹஺º»¼{½@¾¿ÀÁm¹ḄÂÃ

161]^ÄᯠÅ@ÆÇ45wÈ᪀OÊËÅ@¾¿Ìᐹ¤ᑖ᪆FGᨵ┐ÅᨬÑÒḄLMP⚪ᙠÓḄm¹f®ÔÕÂÃlmef@Ö஺⚗ØᵫÀÁm¹efὅÚᡂḄ஺Ꮇ`@ÜᨵfØÝÞ@AᑨIßàᙠm▭®=µ᪵Ìᔩä@A~ᑣåḄ8Ìᑮæço〉ᵨᔩäÀÁm¹efὅÆÀÁᙢm¹ᙢëì@ḄÆÇí⁚M¹V}ᡈço@ï=ឋ/ðñòólmef@Öᐵ@©=@ḄḄeo5'Ḅ,-õᑮwᙠGf®'@Amᙠឋö÷Ḅᦔù஺1ஹ@¹ûḄüᑖᳮMᳮþ1•RichardWasserstrom!ὅ#ᨬ%&Ḅ()#*+,-./Ḅ01ឋ3஺ᳮ67•:;

17X~ḄNO᪗¡#Z[Tᔲ#¢ᐰ¤LXᔲ⍳¦§᪀e©#Z[LᨵcdT:¤ª஺42ᳮ67•,LMJKTRᑖḄ«¬#:ᙠ-./#®ᨵJK¯L°⚪xEF§3:JK#-3␺©XL஺-JK§3Tᩭᡠ´⚜¶ᡈ#MᔠᳮឋMᔲᨵᐵ#-LX~ḄNO᪗¡஺-01ឋ¹ᙠºLḄ⚞Q஺!»{¼JK¯LḄRᑖᳮ3ḄGᵨ#½ᓄ,?ᐲAᔲ©01ឋḄ1¿஺?ᐲAXt-À©JKÁÁᵫ“ÃḄ”ÄF:ᵫEFᐸ1¿Ḅ#^_ÅᯠÆᶍ,L°⚪ḄÈÉឋ஺43X#Z[LËÌM-LÍ#ÎὅḄ01ឋÏ᧕ÑL#ὅÒ¤ª~ᝅᯠZ[#ÔÕḄ01ឋ᝞Ö×ᡂᕖÚ!ὅBZ[L§᪀M-L§᪀*+,ÛÜ஺»{ÛÜ#ÝÞ,-Lᐹᨵ§᪀#^Ttàá01ឋ஺Z[ḄL§᪀᝞âx1ᎷHᐸᩭåæᐵç⌕è2&HéêF0,íLXîḄè3^ïH஺Ḅᔲ©ðᵨ§᪀Xx1ᎷHᐸᩭåæᐵç⌕è2&HéêF0,íLXᎷḄè3^ᔲH஺44

18-L§᪀:x1EF~ñ§3Rᐸᩭåæᐵç⌕è2▰¼©LḄô⚪®õöᨵ÷F,ùúLXîḄᡈûïḄè®õᨵü⌕x▰¼OýVḄô⚪#ùúXîḄᡈûïḄè3᪷sLᡈLMF,®õLஹF
VR஺᪀Ḅᔲᵨ:1ḄLḄ⚪2!R,#$%&ᙢ(ᑮ*+,Ḅ3./,0LḄ*+,஺452ஹ“567ᐹᨵ:;ឋ”>?:;@ABC6@ABὅḄEFᙠ“56Ḅ:;*HIḄ”ḄJḄKẠ>MNḄOPQRᑖ56
OTUVWXYឋḄZᢝ஺\]ᩭ,N.R.bcdefᱯ•mℳop+,MqrᙠstU567ᨵ:;Ḅ,*Iuᓫᙢwᡂyz“{|”,ᔲ056ḄQ}~ᯠᳮឋḄ஺46N.R.bcN.R.Hansondefᱯ•mℳH.A.Simon0O
⚞ᨵᐵḄὃ⇋O7HC56ḄQ}ᜐᳮ஺ᐶḄYOᓽ0¡¢ᳮ£¤◀¦§¨d©ª᜜O¬ᨵ.£¤O®¯Tq°ᨵ±⚪Ḅ6²©ᑮq°w#ḄᎷ´஺47N.R.bc0¡Ꮇ´Ḅ}¶Hᵫᭆ¹ᑖ᪆ᩭ»OḄK¼

19½O⚜ᧇq°Ꮇ´ÀÁÂã¤O/Ä+᝞stÆḄÇÈᡠ⊤ḄOËÃ⚜ᧇÌÌÍ*ÎÏ⚜(OᎷ´ᵫstÐÎ☠ÒÓḄ±⚪Ô᛻
Ö×,ØḄᡈᳮ½ÚÛḄÜÝឋḄO.¯Ꮇ´ÝÞឋḄKẠᭆ¹Ḅ/ßᳮḄ஺ᙠUOàá᪵!C±⚪ÝÞឋḄᑨäOËqQ}HMN:;ᡈᭆ¹ᑖ᪆O/*“⚜(”OËåCæçc-éᐲë⚜(YḄ℉íḄbcEî஺ïðPÌñò᪀ᓄḄô(7ö÷støùᙢ)ᕈ6ᙠà☢ý,öþË᪵Ḅïðᓽᙠ£÷ḄKẠ>ÿ஺ᙠឋᙠ⚞ᓾᐸឋḄᳮᵫ஺48#$ᱯ•+ℳ-.▊012ᧇ456ᔜ89Ḅ:;<ᑣ>?@ABᑮDEF⚪HIJKL஺49NஹP6QRSὅḄUVWXP6QRSὅYᩭ[\]Ḅ^_`abWc஺dᵫefḄᐵhiᙠjᑣkl>mᙠdnᡠefR⌕m┐YPrsQtRSuᐸ^_ḄUVᳮᵫ--twḄxᑖᳮ;,{|}P56ᐹᨵrsឋḄibUV┐YḄWXefᐵᐹᨵឋḄ;i஺:☢ef-.1(KarlR.Popper)4឵(ThomasKuhn)Ḅᳮ;IJ¤Ḅ¥ᢝ஺ef§K¨᪷ª⚞ᑁᐵDE

20:Ḅ_ᵨឋ“®j”Ḅ°±ឋḄ-²³ᯠµ¶·ᐰ¹ᔊ»Ḅ:¼½ᜐᳮ¿ÀrsQtRSÁ¥ᢝḄÂẠuÄÅÆb஺Ç:☢efᢣrsQtRSḄtwÉ᪀ËᯠᨵVᐵÉ;ḄF⚪@᪵u¶Í◀ÏḄVÐRÑÒḄÓᵨ⚞஺ᵫrsQtRS[lᐹᨵÔ◍ᓽᐸ×ᐭ“ÙÚÛÜḄ᪗Þ”µ?·ᐰᔲ-à>ákâ;ḄãSᡠP6QRSὅḄ@UVWcYᐸ“rsQt”>äᓝᑖæᦔ஺50èஹéᣚëÚì^_--1“rsQt”ᑮ“Qt”íᯠP6QRSὅ“᝞ï”cbPrsQtRSḄ⌕ðᓾµ¶ÑïtᡂᐸᔲòPQᙠ;ᡈdnឋḄi஺Ñ.,dnmᔲᐹᨵឋôᐸmᔲrsᙢö÷twஹ56µøùYúûᐵü஺PrsQtRSxᑖtw|}56ᐹᨵrsឋᩭtᡂdnḄឋQ▭mþᐭbA⌕Ḅÿ஺ᐹᨵឋᢣḄᑨᐸḄᨵᑣ"#Ḽ%&ὶ()ᐹᨵ*⚜,ឋஹ.&ឋ/012Ḅ34ឋ஺56789ᐰ◤⌕=“?@ឋ”BCḄDCᩭᐸᐹᨵឋ9ᐰ*FGH?@IJK=LJMḄḄNᓄḄᱯQFRᑣ%&ὶ(ḄSBᩭTᡂVWḄឋ஺X8Y᪵Ḅ[\ᡃ^_`᧕Gb“?@B

21C”Kᐭ“BC”efghiBjkὅmnḄoᳮᵫ஺1,tuv/w឵ḄᳮD)yᡂzᢝឋḄᳮD᪷}tuvᙠ30FẆḄ?@ᡂ4ᳮDᎷᨵ4ᜩBmᡈ“C60—70,¡"⊤£¤¥mஹ¦§¨©ª«¬Y஺j⌕ef£®⚪ᓽᡠ²“³´®⚪”µ¶·®⚪¸/“ᑖº®⚪”µ»¼®⚪¸஺ᑖº®⚪ḄX½ᵫ6¾ᳮD¿ᨵÀÁÂ%Ãᙠ*CBឋᙠ*ᙠÄSBḄ"ÅMCÆÇ*Cឋ/*CឋÈ4ᑗNḄ᪷º▲஺“³´®⚪”“ᑖº®⚪”Ḅzᢝᵫ6tuvᔣ³´¬Ìn✌ᐜDCVWᎷVḄefᩭÆÏÐ2⊤WាាÒmᯠÔÕÖ᰿5ØᚆḄÚ¾ᎷᩭÆÆᵫÛ⌼ÝÞßḄᩭÆ“®⚪”--"ÅMáᨵᳮDoḄÄᡈᳮDÃâḄãä4Û⌼åæᡈᐜ8ÄḄ“⚜,è”ᨬê⌕Ḅ஺ëì³´jkḄÏᐸBíî▲8FïḄÄ*☠Ḅ“³´ñæò¾¬óôõij´µ5Y᪵*y2ᓣᑮuøᡈùᯠ¸í»¼ᡠ²Ḅ“ᐜᜩᳮúḄÛ⌼yû”ô☠B▭ḄÛ⌼åæ/ᢇᑨᳮឋ=þᙢ⌼Ꮇ᣸◀┯ᢝḄḄ᝱!"#$“&'3”Ḅ*஺51

22/឵123ᭆ56ᐭ89:Ḅ;<=Ḅᔊ?@ABCDEBFG᦮IᨵFKᑁᙠḄ■OឋᡈRSឋ!"#ᜐUFG“23”V᝱◀WX☩Z[FG23IC\ᢝḼ^_RS`᝱abᦟᩩ`᝱஺/឵efᔲAhijkᙢmnᡈᔲopFᳮrᙠ$sᩭukvw#^_ᡈᔲoFKᳮrḄxhy◀Ḅᡂᑖ,⌱~FKᳮr'xᩭ”,#☠ᢈḄᨵ⚪ᨵ⚪vf*F-Ḅ#UᳮᓄḄo஺52᝞fsᩭ89:/឵ᙳᔲA<ᡠḄឋ¡!KᔲA#¢Ḅ£ᡠi¤¥u¦ᙠᐸ¨ᐹḄª¦«¬"ᜫ®

23ᦔ᳛ḄùµÇÈúúû⌼ᦔ᳛µÖᦻýþ஺è!Gª¦«¤¥u¦ὅ¿ᯠᜫ®¨ᐹᓾᯠᐹᨵḄᩩ஺2,ḄឋᑴḄ☢!"#$%&'()*+,Ḅ"#!-.$/&ᓫ1Ḅ2ᑨ4!ᵫ6⌕8*9+,!ᡠ;&ᙠ=>2?ẠAḄBCᑨ453,D"#EḄFGHIJKᯠ⌕LMNOὶQ஺R&!+,ᡈὅBCᑨ4&ᵫ'()*U!&/&VFᕡḼY>/Z[\ᙢᡈὅ^_ᙢ`.aF-.ᕖcdᯠ!eᯠ◤⌕'(.BCᑨ4!U/FᕡḼg>&hFḄᡈὅᵫijḄ஺ᳮᵫᨵlm✌ᐜ!ᓽqrᨵstBC!$/u=.vOBCYᯠ&ᱯᨵḄ!gZ;xyzᐸ|ᡠ}~ᢝᨵ஺54ᐸ!.⌕Ḅ!᝞ᡃu,!Ḅᨵᐵ⁚;ᡂOᓄ!;qḄᑮY⌕▲!vOᓄ/&ᓫḄᳮ᪵Ḅ¢ᢝ!&O£¤ᑨ¥;⌕¦!§!ᡃVZ;¨!&ᐹᨵឋḄ!©aF.ª஺ᡃ%u,ᐹᨵḄឋ஺

24ḄḄឋ!Z;«#¬Ḅ᪗¯*஺55/&°±Ḅ!&ᨵ᪗Ḅ!²³ᡈ´µஹ·(ḄḄ!&⌕¦¸A¹«ºH956,A»¼½57஺vV⌕¦ᙠ-y!¾KᔣÀÁஹᔣᨵZuFÂḄᐸ|ஹ$ᔣᐳxÄ|Ḅᑨ¥!ÅÆ+,ḄᳮᵫYÇZÈvᐳxÄKÉᔠḄᑨ¥Ë)ᩭÅ஺Kᯠ´ÍvO᪗,/FᕡḼ>⍳ÐvO᪗!◀Ò|//᝞D஺.D!²³ᡈÓÓÔ⌕´(¼½Ḅ▭ÖṓÄᑴ!ᒹÙ¼ÚÛᑨᑴÜஹᫀ>Þ¼ßᑴÜ!Ḅᜫáâ\ᡈãäᑴÜå!qᑮO᜜ᙠḄ/Zç[Ḅ▭èḄÉᵨ஺ᓄ/&O1êḄëì!&^▭íᑴLḄᓄ஺ᙠ-.y!ᑮḄ᜜ᙠè!z⌕¦ᔣᡂᐸᑨ¥Ḅ¼½ឋî¸ḄHḄï☢ð!v᪵!Ḅ'(-.VᐹᨵᙠᙠḄឋ஺58ᡠ;!9ñ⚞óḄ!ôᙠᓄõ⚪!/Zu&ᓫ1Ḅ஺ᡂ.-.Ḅ÷ᑖ!&î“ú¨”ðḄO¸஺ᵫ6vO-.Ḅíᑴ!◀Ò*»᩽ýþÿ
᝿ᜫḄᐭ“!"#$%&'ᐭḄ”“)*+,-!ᡠ〉ᵨḄ1213ᨵ567
”஺59-9ᩭ;ᐸ=>$ᨬ@◅Ḅ13BCDEFE7
ḄᓽHᐸᑨJKᔠ

25MᨵNOᑣQRḄSTUVWᡂ“YZN”Ḅ᜜஺\឵ᨵ7ᑴ⌼`SaᡠbBCcḄ“d;”ᭆf஺gh$᝞ᙠ⌱lS6mn᝞ᑨJmopᨵd;q⚪'sᨵBCq⚪tguᩭd;☠ᢈxḄ஺yᓽHᡃ!{|gḄ)6;ᡃ!}ᯠ7ᑮ$\឵ᡠḄq⚪)6ᡠbᢈxp⌕☢-13Ḅ⌕ᡂ$S613ᢈx◤⌕ᨵ13;ᳮḄᡂᙠ913஺60'=)᪵ᯠ☢-'☢-13)13ᵨ“d;”ᢈx஺-9ᐸᑨJḄ“d;”ᔲ¡p¢⌴ᡈ¥⛲ḄDExᝯḄmo'S613;ᳮᕖ©ᯠ)᪵஺Mᯠ)6=d;13$ª᪗Ḅ13¬3®ᓄ$=ḄS6᜜ᙠḄ°¬3H±ᙠᵨ“d;”ᜧQ3³´13fᓽµ)613f¶ᯠgᡠh,Ḅyᵫ9¸ᔊº▲ᑴஹ¸½¾¿ஹᩗÁÂÃÄBஹÅƾ¿ÇÈ}ᯠɱ´ឋ$'3³ᳮᵫᡈ7Ë$஺);ᡠb“=d;”+ᯠ13ᳮᵫ;Y13'ᳮᵫ;Y13)6;Y“ᢈx”'µS613Bᡂ஺ÌஹNÍᙠnḄÎÏÐÑ

261,ÕÖḄ13ᩩØnÙÚ᩽ឋÜᑣÝÞ-NßÍ
ḄàᙠáᜧÝᑴâᐸãäy¡᪷æÝᑗèᐸéê᪷ë஺NßÍ
ὅᔲh=´ឋ,í'ᔲ,NḄÍᙠឋpg!ÎÏîḄSàᵨ'ïðñÇòCóᙢõö÷ᙠḄp“ᐹQ”ßùúûSTÍ)᪵Ḅ÷ᙠᭆfpüýþÿḄ“ᐹ”஺ᡠḄ⚪⚪⌕ᔲ"#$ᡠ%&Ḅ'ᑣ)*Ḅ+,-ᒹ/012ᭆ4ᙠᑁḄᐰ80'ᑣ9:;<ᚮ“>᪀”Ḅ@A஺ᵫCDὅFGHIḄJᙠὅKᨬᨵᦔḄOPQḄ஺RSTUVW•^_`abcḄᙠḄd⌕OPὅ஺"e0ᔲf'ᑣḄᙠឋhiᙠjklmḄnojklḄQpPᵨ஺61jkls)tḄHd⌕஺u2vᙠᐸ℉yz{|}~sᑮᨵᐵᭆ4ᙠឋḄlᓽ“Ḅᭆ4ᔲᐹᨵᙠឋᙠᐹᨵᙠឋ”Ḅlᔊ<;ᐸsḄᙠs)tḄᡠ“jkl”“jl”m஺ὅlḄᯖ¡¢ᭆ4ᙠ£9m᜜¥ᙠ¥eᙢJᙠḄᙠḄ§¨©ioªJᙠḄ«ᱥᕖ®¯kA¯ᙠ°Ḅ⊤²mᑁᱥ஺62jkl³ᢝᐳ¶·@ᡠᢣ¹Ḅὅᡈ»63——⊤²ஹ°Ḅ¿ᓄஹ£ÁᮣḄÃᱥ¯Ä"9«ᱥᐹ

27ᨵᙠឋὅÆÆᙠ@ÇsÈᨵᙠឋ஺Émjl"eᙠ9«ᱥsÊᨵᙠឋjᨵឋFᐳ¶KÈᨵᙠឋË;¯kAFᓽJᙠo°⊤²ᑁḄᱥKËJᙠo£Ḅ9m᜜,©ioª«ᱥJᙠḼḄ9ᳮ4«ᱥ“9ᓄHᔲf”JᙠஹᨵÏᐰᭆ4஺631
u2vᢣjlÐḄ“ᙠ”Ñᡃᡠ“Óᜩ”ᡠᙠlḄIាÖ¶É+kAᙠÓᜩᢣ“«ᱥ×ËØÙᙢÚ᪵,ᐹᨵÜḄJᙠ”jÁlFjlKÝÖ¶Éjkl"eᳮ4ÈᙠÜḄÞ«ᱥ×Ë⊤ᙠªឋsÚ᪵;ÜḄ஺632
^_ᙠ"f0ὅjklß᱐ḄáẠD0ὅãäåᢇç஺Êᨵ▲o⍳ê“jl”ḄëᨵìÞåDᙠḄíH°ᓽᙠ;Æî▲oïðsḄ«ᱥ«ñḄ°ᩭóᡂlõᭆ4ᐹᨵᙠឋḄᦔö஺^_Ḅ÷ø᩽ឋúᑣGûᭆ4DiḄø᩽ᙠCI¶üᱫþ;ᳮÿᐸ
ᳮ---ឋ
ឋឋᐗឋឋឋᙠ
ᑣ"#ᑣ$%஺“#ᑣ$%"()Ḅ+,᛻ᙢᒹ01+ὅᙠ34ᩩ678◤⌕+ὅ”஺64<=Ḅᢇ?ᐹᨵBᜧḄ%DEF1“34ᩩ6"HḄIE”JKᓽMNᙠ34ᩩ67◤⌕#ᑣ$%+OᑖQ

28ᡂSTᓽᨵឋUᨵឋᵫT᪀ᡂXᱯZ஺[\],_"`aᨵbcឋḄde஺⍡gḄ"DᙠhijẠlmJnὅopqrsᓫ1஺65_uvᢧxᭆz"ᔲᐹᨵᙠឋ|}~Ḅ"HḄᔩᯠ"஺ᭆz"ᔲᐹᨵᙠឋ_]Ḅ~0nᙠD"ᭆzᙠlᨵᙠឋ"ᡃ"ᔲc▭ᵨḄ஺Jn᪗ḄhijẠ"¡ᙠJnᡈ`ᳮឋJn"Hᡠ¤ᢝḄ᩽§ᱥJnhi஺H©“ª«Ḅᓽ`ᙠḄ”¬©ᔲ¡ᙠJnᑣ©ᳮឋḄᝰᶧ¬©ᔲ¯ὅḄFc°"±Ḅ஺Jni²ᙠᳮHl³´µᵨ1HḄᡂ¶©ᭆz#ᑣ·¸rᐹḄ¹ᱥNᵫᔲᙠឋ஺º"D~ḄᳮHjẠ·ᙠT"ᙠr“¡ᙠJn”ḄᳮH᤺¼½q¾ᵨ¡ᙠJnḄ¿H“ᳮឋ#ᑜḄÁ”ᔲÂ⚜)#ᑣÄᙠឋ,EFq"ÅὅḄNᜲᜧÅḄÇÈÉÊ஺ST⌕~Ë⌨(ÍHÎÏᙠHᙠhil⌕ẚ◀H“ª«Ḅᓽ`ᙠḄ”ḄH°ÒÓÔẚ◀JnᡠJKḄ“¡ᙠJn”஺2ஹ“ª«Ḅᓽ`ᙠḄ”ḄÖ?ᙠ×ᦻÙÁ~ÈnlḄhiÚ[|IᐜJnὅµᵨḄHḄ“ª«Ḅᓽ`ᙠḄ”Ü°ÙÁÓ⌕ḄÖ?஺Ýiὅ

29ᒹÞ<=ᙠᑁḄ·àᙠḄÈnlá_⚗ã஺ᡃäåᐸ
ᳮᵫᡈæ"SNᙠçÝhiḄè铪«Ḅᓽ`ᙠḄ”Ü°êëẚ᪷×◤íîï஺ðñ᝞T×ᦻᙠTó"ᡭõ⛸÷øù©úû☢ḄýHÒNþᨎ஺
ᨬᨵᦔ᥃“ḄᓽᙠḄ”ḄᓝḄ஺!"ᡂ$%&'Ḅ(ឋḄ%*ᑖ᪆-./ᙠឋ012ᙠ3ᐹ5'67892ᙠ3%&'Ḅ:;஺<Ḅ%&=>ᯠ'@A.ᩭḄCDE⍝G>Hᡃ“JKL5MNḼPQᑗ9STUVSTḄWXYᡂZ>HḄWX”66஺“[ᳮឋ]^_ᐸ>aᓽᙠJQ^bឋcTᓣZeᳮឋfᓽᳮឋcghᑮjḄ>aᓽjḄ'ஹjḄ'ᓽjḄ>a9ᳮឋlᡂ/%&”67஺ᙠKᑁᙠnᵫMN@AḼḄpL%&j"ᐰ(3Kr᝞ᡠuvwx஺[KyL%&⊤{3᜜}~ZGUGḄᑁl@L%&ὶ}CDᓄGl⌕Ḅbᙠ---lJ᪵ᡂU@AḄ஺J᜜ᙠᓄḄ:lḄ%&lᡠuwஹᳮஹ᪀ᡂḄ%&஺%&Ḅᨬ¡¢Ḅᓫᐗᡃ¥¦ᡠ<Ḅᭆ¨rpZᶖx%&«%&ḄP¬K®3ᭆ¨ᭆ¨¯ᐳ8ᭆ¨ᡈᭆ¨²b³ᩭ²bᩭ>Q´µᡈᏔᯠḄ·´r·ᭆ¨xᡈ%&¸ᔠḄº´r»¼ᭆ¨x஺½Zᭆ¨ZKᡠᵨ½¿À¯KPᵨ}ÁÂKᑁᙠMNḄᱯ.{

30Äᭆ¨¯Åᭆ¨ὶᵫ3ᐸbᙠQÆÇȯ¡¢3Ḅ%&6²b³ᩭᓽÉᱥËÌ᪵2ᙠ஺᪷ÎḄTÏᳮÐ%&'ᐹᨵbᙠឋᡈᙠឋ6wÑ(3%&'ᡠ¯wᐹᨵᙠឋl0ÒᳮÐ/஺ᯠ6,ZÔÕ?@AᨵBC!ᨵᢗἠᩗḄFᐰ”69஺ᡠK“ὅḄ)L”%&!/0Ḅ“MNOP”஺ᐸR,S⌕ᵨᱯḄV6ᑴஹᑨஹஹYᳮ7⊤\]ᩭ஺ᡃ

31`abScdḄe஺fg!ScdChijkl஺ᙠm5ScdnopᵫqrᡈὅsBtᨵuqesḄcdV⊤]ᩭvCᡂS஺wxS⌕-ySz{ᩭ⊤\஺|}!ᭆḄ:!Ḅz{n!/0ḄᑁᙠḄ()z{*!z{ஹᭆᡠKᙠ!BḄ஺&Sz{!ᔲBCᐹᨵᙠឋᡃ`BCᨵ39ᶧ⇋஺ᱯjz{ᐹᨵ“᪀”70??ὃsb“z{Ḅ<ឋ”6w3!Ḅ!ᳮឋ3¡¢Ḅ£3!ᚖoḄ!)ឋ3◚¦Ḅ7!z{Ḅ§ឋ71?z{©Yᱯ᪷«ᚆ®¯°ᜧ²ᔣ´µ¶M·Ḅ¸¹06z{ḄOeº»7²b“¼.z{Ḅ©Y”Ḅ{06½¾&z{ḄOeº»¿jÀÁὃÂNÃ7஺72Å!ᡃ`⌕Æ)ᑮ¿`Èᨵᔲ᪷z{Ḅᙠឋ*!ÉᯠËsz{ᐹᨵÌ&eḄCᢣ᪀ᓽÎᯠÏÐÑᨎឋஹ“Ó᝞®ÔḄOe”6ÕÖ×ØÙz7%|BCÅz{ḄÚÛÜ:!BKÌ&eḄ“ᐹᨵᢣÝÞḄ▲à”!“z{ᡠáᨵḄ”“z{Îᯠᐹᨵ᪀Åâãäåkæç▲à”“SrᑣÎᯠᐹᨵ᪀,ᓾêeëìK▲ᑴ6Î᣸◀7▾Ḅïᵫðñ”஺73óôSrᑣᵫᩗஹScdஹSz{æ9᜜⊟eö÷ø/0()ḄᑁᙠḄÁô᜜ùᔠûüḄý!“þÿḄ
ᙠḄ”஺3,“ᳮឋᑜḄ”

32!"#ᨬ%&Ḅᙢ()*ᔲᐹᨵ
ᙠ.ឋ/⚪#12“ᳮឋᙢ”⚜4ᔲḄ/⚪஺ὅ67#ᑜ8⚜49Ḅ#:;“<”#=ᙠ>?@A“Bᙠ”Ḅ@C#DEᡃG
Hᑨ/⚪#=JᩭLMNO7ᐸHᑨ#1QRSTUV
ḄᐜᐭYZ,ᓽᵫ]^᪷N`᛻V
ḄᡂZᩭcᡂᐸᑨd஺ὅḄeT@C#fghBᙠ@CijTk#ὅE*lVmA2noBᙠὅ஺pqᙠBᙠnᩭ#rsᜐᙠ“uv”ᡈ“Bᙠ”xyḄ#ᳮឋᑜḄ஺ᡃz{|ᚆ~#Bᙠᐸ⌕~ὅᐹᨵ᩽ᜧḄ#ᐸ᪷ᙠAᐸℳ>Ḅᳮឋ⊤Ḅ஺rsḄឋᯠᔠᳮḄ#ᙠ¡¢£¤¢y◍ᐭ¦᩽§Ḅ“¨E©”஺~#^Ḅᐹᨵª▲ឋ#¬!ᑮE¯Ḅ▤±#ᙠe]▤±#¡²8¨³9´µḄ#¡²T]¶·Ḅ¸¹#ᙠ²¸¹?ᳮḄx²£ḄºL»ᑮ¦ᦋ½#¾TU¿Ḅ¡²ḄÀ»#L¸ÁḄ¡²fTU¿ḄÂÃ᡽ŦḄÆᡈÇ¿Èᔠ஺74#q#ÉÊ<Åᑮᨬ;Ë7ª▲ឋ#1ÌᑮrsT¬#Í“rsᔊÏÐÑÒÓÔÕḄᜩᯠḄx×ØJÙÚÛᑣ,ÂÃÌᑮÊḄEᵫḄÝÞ”75஺Jeß#¬ᳮឋàu¦஺76¬ᳮឋq⍳âT
ḄᳮឋÛᑣ#ÐS²ãᳮஹ4

33åæçÒᩭèrséᐗḄ#Eᡃ£º᪀ᡂrs#EᡃfºYìBᙠì◞#ὅ2îὅïḼ஺ᳮឋḄeU“Êx²”S¡²É¨ᓄḄòó#ᙠᓝõrö÷h£éᓝröøhùQúᑮᝰᶧ#ᐸúᑮghBᙠḄýþÿ஺ḄḄᢇᑨᳮ஺⊤☢Ḅ▲ᑴ"#$%Ḅᑁ'()*+,-“/0ᩞᧇ”45ᑨ6Ḅ789᪀⌼<=஺>8?@AḄᡊᶍ,EFG<=H▭JᙠḄLM“NᙠOPQORᩭ”LTUVWḄXYZ[\]ḄGWᐵ_஺,᪵abc?ḄdẠ஺77fg4hij+klmn☄?pqḄrs>8ᳮឋḄᨵ▲ឋ஺78vᱯ᪷yᚆᙠ{|9}~ᔣEFẆn☄ᡃ“ᡠWᵨ”ḄḄ_ḄᐹᨵḄ(>8?Ḅᐜឋ“¡-(k¢£,¤¥¦”஺79§¨ᙠ©ª«ᢇᑨq¬ᐸ4fgḄ¯dẠG°±²¤q¬ᐸᳮឋ³´?µ¶·¸஺¹º»¼?}X<=@A½¾Ḅ¿Ḅᙠ"À·ḄG}X<=ᑣºᔣGḄ¼ÂRᵨ$ᡃᙠ}X<=ZÃḄ,᪵Ḅ@A*ÄḄdẠaᡂºkÆÇ஺§¨pGÈ-ÉÊ˯È᪵Jᙠᳮ¢ºḄÌFÍḄÎÏ

34ÐÑᐗÓḄqv±Ä¹º$ᡃÐÔᙠÓ4GÐᙠὅÓḄGÖ×ᨵḄ஺“Ôᙠ¡-HØÙᙠÔᙠḄJᙠÃ#Ú$%ᙠᳮ¢UÛJᙠVÜᔠ”஺EF,¡¯ᳮᐸÑᐗḄÞ⌚§¨$ᡃᭆá+¯âḄÃãᙢåæ?çè“}X<=”X}}ᙢé?³ᩭ஺>8ZᡠêJᙠëëaìJᙠᡠí᣸(ᙠḄqvÃïᐭñò¤Ḅ஺“UJᙠḄ▊ôõᙠ¡RḄaᡃḄḄJᙠ……,᪵Jᙠᓽᙠ‘,Q'úᓽJᙠḄ▊ô஺”ᑮÔ§¨ḄJᙠüaýᑮ?¡ᐗ˯ØUÌØḄ[◞ìÿᣵ
ᨵ᜜Ḅᡈ⚪
ᨵ“ᙠḄ▊”஺80ᑮ
ᳮឋ!"#$ᙠ%#⚞'⊤)*+,-Ḅ./%"#01.2ᑮ34Ḅᡭ6
78Ḅ9%:“;ᳮឋ!ẚ=>”஺ᙠ!?ᐸAᢇᑨὅ1.EFGHI
ᳮឋ!JKᙠLM?ᑭᵨP#*QẠḄ"TUVℳ"$perennierendeAufklaorung0ḄQẠf
᝞+,-Ḅᔊi"#ᡠk⊤Ḅ᱄mno$pk0ஹrmno$stu0vwxno$y)k0z{|Ḅ}ᡲ
ᡠ᪷ᨵ1.⌕Ḅ⚪
ᒹᵫஹஹḄ1⚪஺Qᳮឋ!Ḅ//ᑖḄ“ᐗ”ஹ“/ᓄᳮឋ”$totalierendeVernunft0?“)k¢ᑴ¤ᡂ”$VollendungszwangderModerne0ª:«ᶧḄ஺81

35®:
ᓽ°9“;ᳮឋ±ᑜ:³«´Ḅ”
ᡃ¶«ᵫ·“¸”“%¹⚜»:³«´Ḅ”
¼·½%¾¿:ÀÁ%ÂḄKÃ᛻ᓄḄÅÆÇᔩÉᦻ*
"#KËÌ
%¹).!FÍ᪵ḄÏ
.ᙠ:ÐFÑÒ>஺ᳮᵫ᝞ÓÔ1
ᙠ!³Õ“ᳮឋ”Ö"#f×ØÙÓÚÛÜᙠ!ÖᔜÞßÍà
áâ>Ḅãᳮឋ¼äḄᙠ
ᢇå>ᳮឋ!æᳮḄç஺Ḅᐹᨵé▲ឋ
ãᳮឋÅḄÆÇëìḼîïð
¾ᵨñLḄ³¤ò
ó᝞·
ª:ᳮឋ!ᜧõḄᡂöá☄஺®:
ÛÜᙠ!"#ᨬ᪶úḄ
û³:⌕á☄ᳮឋ!Ḅü
Ì:⌕ýᓄᡈþᣵᡃᭆ஺᩽⌕“ᡃ”ᭆᡃḄ◀◀ᩭ"ᑮᔲ%&'(஺ᣚ*+,⌕-“ᳮឋ”0123஺⍡5Ḅ,6ᙠ89:;ᙠ<=ᓾ?ᶍAᳮឋḄBឋᳮឋ,C“ᡃD”ᓽFGᙠḄ,HIJKᣵḄ஺M᝞OᡠQᳮឋḄBឋR,ᡃᙠ

36yᵫ{ᩭ“rᙠ”ᕖ}ᵫ{ᩭ~“rᙠ”ᕖ}Z,Ḅ6ᙠḄ┯ᙠHᑮḄBឋIKᣵᡃ஺6ᙠVᨵ[ᑮᡃḄᳮឋḄឋ┯ᙢᡃIIᑜஹ~ᓄ஺oᯠᡃxHᣵvyḄ“᪍”▲sḄRHIJ஺ᡃDIQ0ᡃ(᪵¡“¢~”£¤¥ᔠ§Fmᯠ⌕¨_`Ḅ¡XY['©ªḼhᡈὅ['k,H®ᡈH®ᙢ¯ᐭ`cdḄᳮឋ,®ᡈH®ᙢ“±ᑜḼ”஺ᙠn§ᦪF³ᡂḄµ~n¶ᡈ·<᪵Ḅᡃ¸,HI¹º஺ᵨ¼ᑜḼM,ᡃDḄ“ᡃ”“®ᡈH®”Ḅ½ᵨ¾¿஺2
ᙠ“ᭆ”M,ᡃDḄÀÁF᎔,8[ᙠ▲ᐹ~Ḅl,Vᨵ<§JVᨵ<§ÀÁ஺FḄᡃ±%ឋÄÅᑴÇᨵ▲ឋ¡ᐹ~Ḅ▲ឋÈÉᡂFHJ᤮ῃḄÌÍ஺ᡃDIQFÎ_ḄḄᑁᙠC᜜ᙠᩩÒÓᑮf▲HIJÔ]HÕḄjᳮ஺lFÖ,ᡃ±%ឋḄTᱥM,

37ᡃkFḄ▲ᑴᩭᳮឋ஺ᡠᳮឋẚãAß[ᕡḼᡃDḄjᳮᡈὅ“åæᭆ”ḄçèẚéAlêHJQᡃDRIëìᭆa஺ᭆ,ᡃDḄ“ᡃ±%ឋ”Ḅãᱥß⌕ᡃD6ᙠᡃDR±%ᐵᡃDḄᭆ஺ᭆᐹᨵîïឋᡈðñឋᓽ┐ᐹ~ᩭQ,óôḄஹᐙöf▲Ḅᒹø¼ᙠᑁḄ¢FùḄ“ᳮឋ”,úᯠ⌕ᓺ1?@AᙠBCḄᐳE┯%ᑣᙠ'Gᑮ)*,HIḄ▲ᑴ./1.᤮ῃ)*M▲%./NOHᙠᐹPQNRῃSᭆᢣU!OH஺VᯠḄ)*WX1.ᔣZ[\]Ḅ0ᜧᾯḄOᳮ`Nஹabcᐸe☢abghᙠijk/)*Ḅlm@nonpqᐙᑖᩩu஺vḼxyzḄ{|Ḅ}~,ᨵḄᭆhWXn}xᡈᐭḄ⌕
ᡠḄ⌕“ᭆ☢,▭”஺V
xḄ{|ᙠᓫ0"\O⊤~/0ḄVᙠᜧḄ\O⊤~/xḄ஺xḄ{|lmᑮhᨬ¢£ᑮᭆhkxᡈὅ⊡ᐙ¦ᨵᭆhWX§¨Nẚ

38ᭆWX«஺AᙠBC¬:ᑮḄᐹWX,ᡃ°/ᡠN:ᑮḄWX஺±²³ᙠ
´"µ¶⏨¸¹ºḄB⌕»¼n}q½¾)*WXḄAᙠឋ(À2ᐰÂᮣḄÄᱥ).ÇÈB\]ឋ¸ÉP/“WX3”஺“WX3”yz½¾ᓄḄÄᱥ«ᐹᨵÊËAᙠÌ,ÍÎqᑗÏÐÑḄᳮឋḄÈᡃ]Ò0±²³ÉP/“ÓᨵÔzB”ḄÔzÕ஺82ᙠÖ±²³×ØÙÚÛ#BC1“ÜÝ”ÞᯠAᙠ0½¾)*WXßᣵḄáÀÈBᔣâ\]Ḅ஺(3)67⌕ãäå\O——“6ç#ç#”AᙠBCḄç#èéᓽãëìḄíh1îᵨᑮ,67WXḄ¾´"஺°/ç#èéAᙠBCËðḄ᝞òGóᡃÇWX
}\´ô«"õ'“”ᶖ஺ᙠ÷øù³úû“Öᙠ”ᡈὅ“AᙠḄ▊ý”íþ/“ᳮÿ”
ᩭḄ஺ᙠḄ᝞ᡭ✌ᡈὅ▲Ḅ
ᙠ!ᜧᙢ“%ᙢ&Ḽ()*+,-*./ᑮᜧᙢ12஺”8345678◤⌕;<=◤⌕>ᑭ@AB=CDEFGHIJ஺,KᝍMᡠOP“=CDEFGHIJ஺”

39QRSᓾ⌕DUVGHIJ஺ᡃX⌕=⌕⚜ZRS⌕=⌕ᙠ[\ᡃXK▭^_,`abcdeḄ⚜ᐜgᑜiḄjkᓾ`=lᐰnᵫpḄ“;<”q\eḄr⚪஺tឋḄ;<8vᐼx⍝“<”UVᡈz▭UV᪵஺Qᙠ☢pRS⚜Zr⚪)ᡃX=8◤⌕x⍝UVḄ<}z▭~V᪵ᡃX◤⌕x⍝z▭KJ~V“ᙠḄ”ḄK▭^_~V)[\஺ᙠRSᡃX⍗ᑮ>ᑭឋ⌕;ᡃXᯠ⌕ὃᐵ!Ḅ<ᳮᓾ◤⌕ὃ᝞F[\ஹ}z^_ḄR஺,`OᜧḄᑮ>ᑭRSḄJ஺84ᯠ>ᑭᑮUV>ᑭ=RSḄ᪗Ḅ¡¢£=lᐰ¤ᨵᶧr஺ᡠ“ᳮឋ=n§Ḅ”ᡈ“¨pᳮឋ=n§Ḅ”ᓽD〉ᔠ!¡¬=e〉ᔠ!RS¡஺RSzᙠឋr⚪,£=`®!ᳮឋ1n§¯ᔲ±§ᑨ³ḄABr⚪
`®!᝞F☢pz▭Ḅ^_ᐵ´᝞Fµᑮ)ᨵᦔḄ[\Ḅᑨ³r⚪=᪷¸!;“<”
᪷¸!ᡃXz▭᝞F¹ºᡃXḄK▭ᐵ´஺»☢¼½Oᑮ“¾ᩩRSzÀÁḄ»Â”ᡈÃÄÅᓃ஺RSᐹᨵzᙠឋᓽ⚜Z^_[\gᑣ▲ᑴÊRὅḄEឋÄ᪷¸!p᝞F“)ᨵᦔ”[\^_ḄË;஺RÌÍÀÎRSÏᑨᐹᨵn⚜Ðឋ}ÑÒឋnᳮ[ÄÓ⚗“ᨵᦔ”Õ^_ᔜn×ᡂÙᳮÚÛḄᨬÝḄÊRÞ⌕;ßḄ®à⌕;஺ᡠ,

40ᙠRS1¡¢⌕áâḄ=<ᳮr⚪
ãär⚪஺ÄÓRABᯠ¬ᵨ“AB”,`æçQàèazéê=tḄ“AB”£ë,`័Á¨p=í“îïðï”OñVòᓫ஺ÃôRABõéêö⏨ᙢºᑮ,¢X+RABæᐵ!RS“Ä”ḄBrᡈø᝞Óù⊤û
¤ᨵOᡂË;RS“?⛽AB$#C

41-lc.ᙠhMN¡Ḅᢑzᵫ£“¤”>¥Ḅw⌕¦஺12Nᑴ§¨D¨©yᑖᩗᑴ¬M¨®¯°c⚜²®¯³´µy2¶[▭·¸Ḅ¹º»¨ᙠ¨ὅḄ⚜ᐜὃ¾Ḅ¬C¿ÀKᙠÁx᪀ÃzÄMyὅÅᑖ“y”ḼᐳÈḄ¡᠗஺ÊᯠÌÍ+ᙠÎMᫀÃ0%Ð⚜ᐜ,ὃzᵫ£“¤”,ὃ⌕¦0%ÐÑ°¨ὅ³,ὃzᵫ£[,ὃ⌕¦Ò᪷Ôᡃ#ḄÕPÖ/ᙠᜧØᦪÚ)m᪵Ḅ஺ᙠa.ÕPÃᡃ#ÛÜᢑ“c.ᙠh”m“£ᙠh”ÝÞ%>ßD஺ᭆe\ᑖ᪆ᙠMᩩ+âãäåºæçc.ᙠh,èMéᩭ⌕ëìca.q\᩽îḄ.ᵨq஺ᙠðDc.ᙠhñẠ+[#ZcóóôtõöᭆeᓄḄ⊤ùú*12ᭆeᓄḄcᐹᨵMN¨ᢈý+AZþÿ
ᑣᙠᵨ
ᭆᐸḄᦔឋᐹᨵᨬᜧ▲#Ḅᢣ%ᦔ&ᐸ'()Ḅᒹ+ᑨ-ᐹᨵ.ᢝ0ஹ.23ᙢᑜ⌕789Ḅᱯ;஺87=ᭆ>Ḅ?
@ᭆ
A᝞CDEḄFGHIJKLDEḄFG஺Mᯠ᝞ᡃPQᔣ᩽TU?
V
᪀XYZ[ᵫ?
]^_J%D`T஺ᭆ
Aᙠabcdᑮfg஺᩽TḄᭆ

42
Aijk
ᭆᑁmnᑮopqrs᪵Ḅuv
ᑣwxᭆᓄz{|}~ḄEᡂ᦮Ḅ᪵,ᑗ
⚪ᙠ
ᑮ[bḄᭆ{|opὃḄ
ᜐᳮᣵ஺
〉ᵨ}xᓫḄopᓽ
[¡¢£¤¥¦§(Subsumtion)஺88
´Ḅµ¶3▭Ḅ¸᠗º,᝞»¼½ᭆḄ¾ᙠ'P¿À_“Âý
”_ÃḄ஺89Æᱯ=vᙢᢇÈÉÊ᩽TḄᭆ
AiËᯠÌͽᭆḄÎឋ3▭
ᑣ@
ᭆ}ÏÐÑᙠ“Ò᪀”[ÓᐹÔ᛻ᩭÉᐹᨵ×ᮣḄឋzÑᙠᡈÚᡈÛḄ}〉Üឋ஺Æᱯjk=ᙠaᑖ᪆
Aßᭆ
AàᑖáᩭGkᑖ᪆
Ajâᑮã☢?
ὅæç}èᡠ}ê⚜ìᑗíã☢
ᭆÑᙠ}ÏÐḄ“îï”ᡠ}êð஺90~ÜòÚ
AiHó⏨ᙢXᑮ
´õᯠᨵÜö◢ᨵܵ9øᵫÓ☢[⚪ùùJúD¼3ûḄ¸᠗᝞üýºþᑴ
஺91ᡠᙠᢝᑣᐜḄᭆ▭Ḅᵨ!⌕Ḅ#ᱯ%&'()ᙠᑮ+ᔲ-ᭆ“ᜩ0”234567ᙢᳫḄ:᎛+<92?ᙠ&ᓟA⌕BC+#ᱯḄDEF#ᱯ⌕23ḄGGᭆḄ“ᜩ0”ᡈὅJᭆ“KL”MNO23ᭆ“PQ”

43RS஺#ᱯJTUV⌕WXᭆḄ“YZ[᪀”93,_`abcᓄῖfgK᜻Ḅ஺ᭆ_`ijᡂl`Ḅ:mno[p+?qr᜽_tᙠuMvᭆ_`RSwᨵy⌕z{|}᧕஺199710ᨴ஺20035-6ᨴᦋ஺ᦋ⊡%SARSᾖ⇊ᙠE¡¢ᦻ஺Rᦻ¤¥⊤§¨©ª_Ẇ¬1998¯3°஺uᦻ±²³┐3µᙠ¶·Ḅ}¸ᑣW¹ஹ»ᑖ½¾¿_À᛻uḄÂÃÄ·Å2Æ஺ᡃÈgᭆÉÊËÌ_`Íᑖ᪆_`gÏḄ_`abᙠᢝ_tᙠuÃÐÑÒᓩ℉ÕTᡃÖ×ØḄ஺ᡃ0_`ஹ_tᑴÚÛ_tÜÝᐳßàáâᭆ᦮ᳮஹᑣᑖ᪆▤æcᡂç_`ᢇᑨVᨵᙠᵫᭆ_`Íᑖ᪆_`ëᢝḄì_¥íîïðᨵ▭Eñ஺òᐸᡃ0ᨵ»ô°Ḅ¿_õ·öᑖḄᔊø¿_ùúஹ¿_ῖû©ªüyýþÿ1949ᡃ“”ஹ“ᢞ”“”₩ᯠᦑᙠ"ᜩᩭ᎝&'(“)ᑣ”+ᨵᱯ.Ḅ01஺3456789:;<=>?@ᡃA0BCDEFGHᡃIJᡠ?LM஺NOPQᡃRST⏥VᭆXYZᑖ᪆YḄ]^_`>abc஺dQefg⊤iḄ4jkl>mᜧopᦋᓾsVtuḄ4jNa>v>ᦋᡠi^ᢚ5ᙠ@xyᢝ{|ḄCẠ~oi⌕᦮Z⊡ᐙ஺ᳫV20036ᨴ8஺1,9ᦻḄᙠVHᡃᵨᭆXY

44ᑖ᪆Y:Ẇl]^ᳮ9CẠ஺ᭆXYᢝ¡ᙠ9,ᐸ]^(⌕£¤Q¥Ḅ¦§〉ᵨឋᦟ1Y«ᭆXZ)ᑣ¬®Ḅ01஺ᑖ᪆Y¯ᯠᨵ°VᭆXY«ᑖ᪆Y±²ᱯ³´µᦻoi¶·¸_H.L.A.²ᱯ½¾ὤ᪍ḄᭆXᜩÁ<ᑖ᪆YÂ▰᪍᪍ÄÅwww.chinalegaltheory.com®,ᓽÕÖᭆ0XḄ×ØZfÙឋBᨵ]FGᯠÁᭆXYÚÛÜÛ᪵(ÞᭆXßÚQà⚜§¡âḄ஺2,¡ᙠឋãäåEឋ஺3,ᭆXYᐵV“çèé5&êᐸᑨì”ᑖ᪆YᐵV“çèMíî”Ḅ⊤ïðᒹòiᐹᨵ¡ᙠឋḄᳮô஺ᙠõöᡃ÷Qᙠ)ᑣøù§ᙢ¡âḄ01~ᩭû8¡ᙠ9Ḅ01஺ᐹᨵ¡ᙠឋß>&ᯠ>üýçþÿ
Ḅ“”ᡈ“ᑣ”஺᝞ᐹᢵᐸᳮឋ!"#$%&⚪ᦑ)ᦻ+,-./0஺4,3᝞4567)8997ᩩ91>?“@ᨵBCḄᙢEFGHI”J4K)L8976ᩩ93>?“ᡠᨵPQRBCSTUᩗFW)LXIḄYZ”J4
ᜧᑭL89101ᩩ?^“ᩗ_`aḄbSTFGHI஺”

455,ef₈(karlLarenz)^4rs08▰᰿vwxyzᓭ|}~᱐1996᱐95⚓஺4rs08ef₈Ḅb℉1960᱐,஺ᙠ}᎝ᭆrᑭrḄrᯠᢝ,?ឋឋ¡᜽6£ᑣ¤¥᤯Ḅᨬ¨£ᑣ,$஺©ªḄᓄᡃ®¥¯°¤±¤²ᵨḄ´µ¶·¸¹%ᫀᱯ¼ḄᐹḄ½Ḅ¾|¤¿¤ᦔ᳛Ḅ¤¥Ḅᡠ_ÃÄrḄÅ⚪¤ᙠᐸ¯ᙠ_Ærs^ÇÈTÉᑨËÌÍᓄḄs_ÎÏḄឋḄ?ឋᙠᑗᔠÒÄTÓḄÔ᪗Ʊ_ÌÍᙢᔣ×ᙢ஺ef₈ØÙÚÛÜ0ÃÄsÝḄ0Þß~ḄᐵáâXãªäḄᐵáâ^¤¥ᑖᒘḄ“ç᪀éê”ᡈὅᡂC“íîrÝḄ0Ï”⌕ᙠIð,ñ“òᐝôõö÷”,ᐸÉᑨËᨬø¤ῃúíîûḄḄüᵨ஺6,Rudolphvonjhering,ImJuristischenBegriffshimmel,http://www.mauthner-gesellschaft.de/mauthner/tex/iherl.html.7,JosephW.Bingham,WhatistheLaw?,IIMich.LRev.,I,109,9,10(1912)o8,+,•ᡀ2,345620789ᳮ;<9=;(>)?(@

46AB)CDᓭFᜧ;9HIJ?KL3MCL5—10⚓஺PᦻRSCTUV1980WXḄᢇᑨ9;\]^_V`WḄ9Habcd9;CeSᐸᢣᔣi9HbᙠJCk▲VmnopSqrJstuCᙠvwxyz஺9,569;ᙠ{|}~C618789;}(I.W.Blackstone)Ḅ,oᐲ2(ChristopherColumbusLangdell)SX⊤^i“9ᑨ”ᳮJ஺ᐲ2ᙠᐸ1871W4ᔠᫀ?1905W4⊝9ᭆJ?▊iᭆcdḄCRS9Hᵫᨵ▲ᦪ¤Ḅ¥PᳮJ¦ᑣ¨ᡂ,9ª«9H¬w⌼9HC9H«¯°¥P;±ᭆr²³ᙢTµ஺{|}¶·¸9H¹ᡂº»²³¼½¾¿ḄÀÁḄ,Âᙠ1881W{|}4Ã9?º1897W49H~Ä?ºᦻrCᔾᦈÇᑭcdCÉÊÃ9ḄTµ¦ᑣË9ḄஹoÍÎS¥ẠḄ9ªᑨC“9HḄÐÑw²³¬ÒÓ”CkÂÔᨵᔲR9Öº×ØᑣḄÙÚC«cÛ9ÖÜoὃ⇋ÍÎß⚪Cá9ÖᦑãḄ²³äåḄ“┯ç”Tµ9H஺ᙠ{|}¹ᩭC9HØᑣ“éêḄëb”,«ᨵ“ìí”îïRS9Hwá9ªðḄᭆñឋ⚜ô஺õö3I.W.Blackstone,Commentaries;C.C.Langdell,CasesonContracts,Boston,1871;C.C.Langdell,BriefSurveyofEquityJurisprudence,Boston,1905;01iverW.Holmes,TheCommonLaw,Boston,1963,(firstPublishedl881);0.W.Holmes,ThePathofLaw,lOHarv.L.Rev.(1897)o

4710,÷øᙠ1909W49HḄឋù<ᩭú?▊sioûC“·9▾ý⌕xÿ
Ḅ⚜……ᓽᡃᡠ”ḄḄᙠᢇ⃬Ḅᔊᔊ!"#$᱐&Ḅ'(ᳮ*ᓽ+Ḅ,-"./0ᐜ23ᙠḄ(5678)ᯠ;<+=⌼Ḅ?ᨵḄ?◞BḄCDE"FḄ0G஺IJᨬLEᯠMᶇOPQRSTUV"ᑭᵨ“?◞”Z[FḄᙢ]ᓽ"ᨵFᙠ^_ᩗᑭ

48v.365,383(1940);R.Pound,ASurveyofSocialInterests,57Harv.L.Rev.1(1943);R.Pound,OutlinesofJurisprudence,5thed.,1943.12,ÇᐲÉᙠ|Ê/Ë78Ì6ÍᓺᑵÐᔲÒÓ"Bᑣᝰᶧ*ὅV×"“0Pᝰᶧ*ὅ”஺vwxJ.Frank,LawandtheModernMind,GardenCity,N.Y.,1963(firstPublishedl930),xxv(1948{᱐ÌØÍᓺᑵÐ).¿ÚËÛÜÝÞ•ᡀàÞ,âãÇᐲÉäåᑮBᑣ“çè+⚜Ḅឋéê᪶ì”ᵫîᵨ₹ð•ᝍᑭòᱯ(HermanOliphant)ᐵ+¤Bᑣ<ôᑣᡠõᑴḄå÷aø•ùúû(JohnDikinson)üýþ»BᑣÊÿ
Ḅᑖᙠ▭ᑮ•(JosephW.Bingham)Ḅᳮᐵᑣ“!ᐹ”Ḅ$%஺'()ᐲ+ᙠ1941,ᡂ./012345▾578ᙠ1949,9:;5<=>?@ᑣḄ᝱BCDᨵFᜧHIJKLMNO஺PQR/STU•ᡀWUX9YZ[5\Ḅ]^[_`a⚪=(def)9ᓭiᜧZ5\j=k15l16-7⚓஺13,ᓲo᪍qrᢝtuvᔲxᑣḄyᙠz{ᵨ}~ḼḄ@ᑣḄ᝱B᪵]HIᙠ9>ᖪ5=Ḅ$%x{.ᢣḄᑣ஺ᡂt“ᑣ'ᑴ}ᢣ”஺ᐹᨵᢣḄᑣ'

49¡¢Ḅ8ὅrᢝ¤5¥¦[{.᦮¨Ḅ5\ᑴB©ª«¬}ᐹᨵᶍ¯°Ḅᮣ²Ḅᶇᨵ´µὃ⇋¸Ḅᑣ¹ᨵ“º᛻¼”z“½¾Ḅ/ᝯ”஺᪵ᓲo᪍[ᐸ^Áὅ▭ᑖ⍝Ã╨஺ᨬÆx'ᓫȤ5Ḅ“ᑣ”(ÉÊᢣឋḄ)ÌᵫÎx.R45▾SḄ¤5“ÏÐᔠᳮ⚜ÓḄ”஺SeeK.N.Llewellyn,TheCommonLawTradition---DecidingAppeals,Boston,1960.pp.179.14,J.Frank,LawandtheModernMind,pp.138,141,72,295,141,138,9,109,140,113(n.4),298.15,K.N.Llewellyn,TheBrambleBush,NewYork,1951(firstPublishedl930),pp.12.ᓲo᪍Õx.ᙠÖ×ᑴBᑣØÙḄᑣÚ8ᩭᡂÜḄὃx.ᭆÞÕ'ßà}áᐭᩗᑭzᑭåᭆÞ{.ØÙᡠᜧ¢çèḄ@éêᭆÞë@ᑣᭆÞìíîïðñòêᭆÞófᡂôõḄö÷ᓽù(“ú.Ḅ$%”}ófᡂ5<ᡠûḄ“ᑣ”஺16,JosephC.Hutcheson,TheJudgementIntuitive:TheFunctionofthe

50“Hunch"inJudicialDecisions,4CornellL.Q.274(1928,29)6TU•ᡀWUX9YZ[5\Ḅ]^[_`a⚪=(def)16⚓஺17,J.Frank,LawandtheModernMind,pp.1386TU•ᡀWUX9YZ[5\Ḅ]^[_`a⚪=16ஹ7⚓஺18,@ᒹþ^ÁᙠᑁḄ
ᵨḄᱯḄᭆᦻ7“!ᑣᝰᶧ”&'ᜧ)*ᐰ,-᱐/19960᱐12345'67☘5“ᵨ9:;ᓄ”&'ᜧ)*ᐰ,-᱐/19960᱐஺19,John.Dickson,LegalRules:TheirFunctionintheProcessofDecision79,842,857,851,860(n.51)U.Pa.L.Rev.833,843(1931);John.Dickson,AdministrativeJusticeandtheSupremacyofLaw,141(N.Y.1955,>᱐1927)6?@A•ᡀCA?'20DEᳮGH(J)(LM)ᓭOᜧPQR4S9T1⚓஺20,UVW4XḄYZ[FelixS.Cohen,EthicalSystemsandLegalIdeal,12.N.16(Ithaca,N.Y.1959,>᱐1933)6

51FelixS.Cohen,TranscendentalNonsenseandtheFunctionaApproach,35Colum.L.Rev.809(1935).21,CX'GḄᳮQ91&'ᜧ)*ᐰ,-᱐/19960᱐ᮣ஺CXḄ:;ᳮQᨵὃ⇋⌕ᐗQᢇᑨᝍAᢝḼ9'¡¢Ḅ£¤[Ḅ¥ᐗQ஺᪷§ᝍAḄᳮQ'᜜©Ḅ¢ªᑴ¬CX®¯'°¯'ᑁ²Ḅ:;ᓄ³´ḄᳮQᑖᒘ·ᑖḄ'ᳮQ,CX¸´¹ḄᐗQº»³¼¬⍝2ஹ¿ÀᎷÂḄ¢ᓄḄ'ᭆÃÄ☄³£¤ᑁḄ¿À[ÆÇ᝱஺22,CX'GḄᳮQ1É142—45⚓஺23,CX'GḄᳮQ,▬Í457—488⚓஺24,CX:'GḄᳮQ2É6401—405⚓஺25,CX'GḄᳮQ▬Í457—488⚓஺

5226,CX'GḄᳮQ1É11163⚓஺27,H.L.A.ᱯὤ᪍Ḅᭆᜩ'GUÔᑖ᪆▰᪍᪍,×www.chinalegaltheory,com஺28,ᱯḄᭆ257124—140⚓஺29,ᱯḄᭆ458⚓590⚓஺30,ᱯḄᭆ6஺31,2345'9஺32,2345'32⚓஺234ḄPÛ஺33,2345'364⚓஺34,£¤ÜÝ⌕Ô⊤ᨵßà•äCå9æçC@è஺¹éêëÜÝì⚪G*ᳮÜᨵᐵḄïQì⚪´-ðñḄòó*Ḅôõö÷ḄÜÝøᓽúûüýþÿ

53
ὅḄᡂᙢᔊḄῃᩭ஺ὅ#$%Ḅ&᛻(ᐹᨵ+᩽Ḅ-.ᳮ01◀3ᑗḄ5ឋḄ78஺9᝞;<=>?ᳮᙠABCᡃEᣚᙠG78ὅᔲI3JKḄᑖMNᩭḄ%OPMQRSKᜐUV%W஺;<=ḄGXYḄᔊZ[\]^_`ᔊZ஺abcᳮdeᑮgᓱ<ijᳮឋikcḄlmGkcIᨵḄnᡂᙢRSᔊḄopqrjstGqrḄῃᩭ஺uvw

54ᙠZiCḄn[·êᔊḄô8஺ᐵU<Ḅᳮdö÷u?@ḄᯖB2CDEᵫGℳIJKLḄ)*ឋMNᑮPQ஺STUDEVWQᙠYZ[3\ᙠ]Ḅ2^_`aᔲc)*ឋdecឋ2fghᳮឋfjkᑭᝍUDEᙠnopqrᨬt⌕Ḅvw3ZxyzE“ᙠ]”Ḅvw-~ᔠJ3Ḅ2~K2:;/ᩞᧇ3ᜐhqḄᐵr2ᨵᨬḄᔠJ23ᙠpqᭆḄ2CDE\Qᙠᓫ~Ḅᳮឋ2QᙠᐗḄᳮឋ2ᵫᔲc)*ឋk¡¢£ᔈ¥¦Dᙠ§¨]2ᙠ§~p©Qᙠ()*ឋªᐶ¬ḄJὅ2ᯠ°C±E²³´µᱯḄᐶ¬_·¸L⌼²ᡠ»)*ឋ22CDEᳮឋ3ᔊ½ឋḄ¾ᱥ2ᨵÀÁḄ)*ឋÂkÄÅ\ᢧᡊ)*ឋÈ2CᢧᡊḄ3)*ឋḄÉ⌕ឋ2CDE)*ឋ3~ÊËÌ2ᐹᨵᵫfÎឋdᳮឋḄᔊ½ឋÏcḄᔊ½ឋ22CDEÐᦻfj(hᔊ½ឋḄ)*ឋḄ⌕Ò3\É⌕Ḅ2ᙠÓᩭᨵÕÐᦻfjᡠ;ÖḄ×ḄZ[ḄØᵫ2CÙᐭ²ᩗ¸ᭆ2DEᩗ¸ÜÝÞ>¾ßàá>¾Ýâ,

55ᩗ¸ᨵãä)*ឋḄᐜÏᩩç2ᨵ(ᩗ¸ᔠ8/ᔲḄᢇᑨᳮê2\Qᙠ~ë\ìᩗ¸íîïpower-freeòḄᢇᑨóô஺rᦻõᧇZö÷øùú:;<ûüýþÿ
ᒹ᱐19971᱐஺37,!193⚓஺38,!172⚓஺39,!364⚓஺40,ᐵ)᦮+ឋ-ᑣḄ012345!66஺789:;<=>ᵨ<,:@Aὅ9▊DḄ5EFGHI=᡻KᱯMNOPὅ9▊DḄ5EFGQRᙠ-ᑣTUVWXYḄZN⌕\]^஺25!4ஹ56364⚓஺41,45ab•ᡀgb:ijklḄHIkHm⚪!,5⚓஺42,“HIXq”Ḅstuvwᑮyz{|Ḅ}~k⚜!
ᜧj᱐1938X஺•ᱯᓭ@1949

561951ᙠᜧjyz{|FXX⊤>q<
X¡0¢>q<Ḅᦟᣴ஺45•ᱯᓭ¥ᑁ§¨©jḄª«¬!ᓲ¯°±http://www.guxiang.com/xueshu/others/zhexue/200109/200109190070.htmo43,45ab•ᡀgb:ijklḄHIkHm⚪!,5⚓஺44,45ab•ᡀgb:ijklḄHIkHm⚪!,5⚓஺45,45ab•ᡀgb:ijklḄHIkHm⚪!,8⚓஺46,45ab•ᡀgb:ijklḄHIkHm⚪!,9⚓஺47,45ab•ᡀgb:ijklḄHIkHm⚪!,9⚓஺48NorwoodRusselIHanson,

57,IsthereaLogicofScientificDiscovery?'inBrody,B.A.(ed.),ReadingsinthePhilosophyofScience(EnglewoodCliffs,NewJersey:Prentice-Hall,Inc.1970),pp.620-633.OriginallypublishedinFeigl,H.andMaxwell,G.(eds.),CurrentIssuesinPhi1osophyofScience,Holt,RinehartandWinston,Inc.1961,pp.20X34.5ËὤÍ9ÎÏḄÐ0ÑÒ35—39⚓ÓÔÎÏḄÕÖ,ÑÒ40—42⚓஺ÎÏḄᳮ0Øu45NRHanson,PatternsofDiscovery,CambridgeUniversityPress,London,1958(WᨵlᦻÜ°HIḄÝÞ!ßàáᕜã°l▭åæ᱐1988᱐)è6éêijHIḄ!᱐1986᱐஺49,H.A.Simon,Doesscientificdiscoveryhavealogic?PhilosophyofScienee,40(1973),471-480(|ëᱯ•ìℳ:ijHIᐹᨵᔩð!±ij©j!40(1973)J471—80)o50,45•ᱯᓭ¥ᑁ§¨©jḄª«¬!஺ᱯᓭᙠñᦻòó30ôXõöḄ©j÷ᨵøÞ7÷ᨵù஺ᐸP>q<ὅûᔊýþÿᜧᦪᡂὅ஺ᨵ᪵Ḅᓽᐭ஻"#$%Ḅ᪗'஻஺()஻*+஻,-..⌕0123஺4

58ᱯᓭ89:23;ᩭᐸ>?@A஺23ὅ:ᡠᨵC,DḄE⚪GHIḄ஺23ὅḄJᡠKLMNOGᎷḄᢥ᯿STḄU23ὅVᢝ:ᡠᨵᨵIḄ▰Y,J1L⌕\Gᐵ^_`ᩞᧇḄc+▰YdJ2L⌕\f^“ᑖ᪆ឋ”▰Yl᝞23nᦪDḄ▰Y஺>opqrᔠឋOtJᓽ>ounᨵᐵ_`ᩞᧇḄOtpv8ḄwxឋOtL,yᑖ᪆ឋ▰Yz{|}ᑖ*஺ᵫ4ᱯᓭᢇ23ὅ)ᨵ?ᭆGᐙᳮOᱯ⁐Ḅ*ᙠḼ☩zḄ,G:cᵨᐰᔊḄᜐᳮ஺40¢1£W.¦§ᢣ©?ª«OE⚪l᝞ᦪGᔲ+ᙠGᨵIḄn23ὅḄp®ᨵ¯^ᙠC,DᙠḄ°±²³¦§ª.JH⍡µL¶ᶇᨵ?¸¹@º>»:ᑖ᪆nrᔠḄ¼½G¾¿ÀḄ஺@ᩭ¦§Áᢣ©:ÂOᨵcÃᡂÄᯠḄÆᑖ஺4ᱯᓭÄ:SÇÈ஻UÉ⚗஻n஻ᳮO⚗஻ḄËᑖ̾¿ÀḄ*᥃Î23¯ÏzÐᐙ±ÐḄC,DᙠÑÒ⍝ÔÕÈ>JÖ⍡µᙢLØᙠ70¢1MÚ»ÛÜÝ஺51,ß¹à᪛âãäåæ`ÂçᓄOé4ê⌱ìí,ôõ•ö`÷ὶõù1987¢11ᨴüý᱐஺é4êḄ℉
TheLogicofScientificDiscovery,BasicBooks,NewYork,1959"ThePovertyofHistoricism,BeaconPress,Boston,

5919576TheHistoryofOurTime:anOptimistJsView,148WorldAffairs(1985)6ConjecturesandRefutations:TheGrowthofScientificKnowledge,Routledge,London,19626&&஺52,Kuhn,ThomasS,TheStructureofScientificRevolutions,ChicagoUniversityPress,1970,2d.pp.148,151.()឵+,-☩/Ḅ1᪀34567ᜧ-419709:2᱐4:148ஹ151⚓>?@)")឵:+CDឋஹFGᑨIJᳮL⌱N34O+P⌕ḄRS34567ᜧ-197794:322ஹ324⚓஺TUVW•ᡀYW+,-JZ[\Ḅ]^J_`a⚪34:10⚓>c15—18o)឵ᙠefYḄgẠi4jk
ᨵmn“pq,-”a⚪4stu,-mvwᡂmyḄᳮLz{4|}~?ᓫnᎷ☢ᯠḄ4?᦮nz{1᪀ᩭ4nz{1᪀ᙠmyUᢝ᝱4ᨵmḄ■ᑴ஺,-Ḅ-ὃ4P¡¢,-£¤k]4¥¦P¡¢§ᢗ©ᑮ᦮n«¬᛻?>¯Ḅ°ᳮḄ±²1᪀\³஺53,VW•ᡀYW+,-JZ[\Ḅ]^J_`a⚪34:11⚓஺54,VW•ᡀYW+,-JZ[\Ḅ]^J_`a⚪34:

6011⚓஺55,VW•ᡀYW+,-JZ[\Ḅ]^J_`a⚪34:11⚓஺56,´☢ᡃ¶·¸ᵨºm»¼½Ḅ¾ZᩩÀ஺57,Á¼½¾ZiÃÄZÅÆÇÈu¾ZÉᑣ஺+¯ᩗÌÍ3:ᓝᩩ:“¯¯ÏᐰÑ&ᙢᨵᩗᵫmnÔÈÕÖ×ḄZØÙÚÅÆḄÛÅÜḄÝ4?ÇysḄᩗᑭÛßàáᑨysjkḄâãᑛåᢣç஺”58,ᡃ¼èéÄZêëᩭ4§jkᐵíḄa⚪ᡃ¶éᜩḄÄZïðÛÄZḄ«¬ñzᔲᨵóôḄê▭Sö÷øZù¶úûḄüýþyᙠÄZïðḄ«¬_`ÿ᪗
ᣚᙠᓄᔲḄḄᙠᔲḄᜐ!▲Ḅ#᝱%ᡃ'(ᜩḄῖ+,-./#01234567ᐸ9⌕ᡂ<஺59,>?•ᡀA?BCDEFGḄHF34I⚪KL11⚓஺

6160,┐OP឵ḄRSTUḄᢇWXYP឵ᔲZ[ᑖHF34<]^_`a“34⚞e”F“g!⚞e”^hᳮRḄjg!ឋ,᝞mn^g!_]o஺pᢇWqrᨵᑗ⌕u஺P឵qv_`ᳮRḄjg!ឋ,᝞mn^g!wxyI⚪Ḅὶ{ᒘ}~ᩭ]n^g!ᢈḄᵨFᳮR(ᑨR)Ḅjg!ឋᐵ஺Y>?•ᡀA?BCDEFGḄHF34I⚪KL11⚓஺61,MorrisR.Cohen,JurisprudenceasaPhilosophicdiscipline,10J.ofPhil.(1913)6MorrisR.Cohen,JusticeHomesandtheNaturalLaw,inCohen'sLawandtheSocialOrder(NewBrunswick,N.J.1982,Id,1933)□>?•ᡀA?BC20ᳮEFE()KL9—10⚓஺62,ABCEKL3ᔁ¡¢£ᖪ¥ᓺ§¨1959©L1᱐L313⚓஺63,ABCEKL3ᔁL307⚓஺ᐵ“ᭆ¬”ᡈ“ᐳ¯”Ḅ°Zᙠ±²³,´µ¶·¸¹µᐰᑗᑗᙠ<»ᐹᨵᐜ¾ឋ¿ᙠÀ±²³ÁÂ--ÄRὅ¹µᐳ¯ÆÇÈஹÊËஹÌHÍὅᣚÎᳮឋḄÏᱥ஺

6263(1),ABCEKL3ᔁL307-314⚓஺ᡲ>¶℉ÚḄÄRὅᝍÜ℉ÚḄÄÚRὅ஺ABCEKL3ᔁL307⚓஺63(2)ABCEKL3ᔁ¡¢£ᖪ¥ᓺ§¨1959©L1᱐L313⚓஺64,MorrisR.Cohen,JurisprudenceasaPhilosophicdiscipline,10J.ofPhil.(1913)¿JusticeHomesandtheNaturalLaw,inCohen'sLawandtheSocialOrder(NewBrunswick,N.J.1982,Id,1933)□•ᡀ20ᳮ()!"9—10⚓஺65,'᜜!)*+ᐸ-᩽ឋ0ᑣ23ᨵ5678Ḅ:᪆!<=>ᙠ@A⊤C஺66,DEFGᯠ!ᖪJᓺLM1980N᱐!"616—617⚓஺67,DEFQRST!UVWX!ᖪJᓺL✂1996N᱐,"1ߟ2⚓o

6368,DEF0ᳮ!]!^_`X!ᖪJᓺL✂1995N᱐஺69,ab₈Fde!"233⚓஺70,fᱯFhḄᭆA!"1124,126,127,130⚓஺71,jk•ὃmnopqr•fstuvFwxyhᳮeze!{|}X!h~᱐2002N᱐!"302⚓஺72,ᱯ᪷sᚆḄ℉eX!ᖪJᓺL✂,1992
y℉Ẇ▰ᗩ᧜X!~᱐!2001
ᑖx⊤Ḅuy஺¡¢jk?ὃmnopqr?fstuvwxyhᳮeze!"302⚓஺73,fᱯFhḄᭆA!"126,130,146⚓74,DEFQRST!"40—44⚓஺75,DEFᔊ¥!¦⌼¨X!©ὶL«1958N᱐!"

64149⚓஺76,ᙠDE®!¯r°±²“´µḄᦪ·⚪|¹º»¼½Ḅᑨ¿!À»ᐜᜩḄᑨ¿”ÄÅ“´µḄÆÀ»ᐜᜩÇᔠ·⚪”~É!ÊËḄᐜᜩᳮÌḄÍ⌼ÎÏÐᜩ¼½ÑÄÒᔠ!ÐᳮÌḄÓ☠ឋÕÖ×¼½!°ÀØ~´µḄÙÚ²஺¡¢¯rFÛÜÝÞÎßàÙ~SḄáᩭÆÀze!ãäåX!ᖪJᓺL✂1978N"1᱐஺ᙠDE!STḄæçèéê¯ruḄëìíî!Ïkïðñ½<0Ḅdòz~>ᙠᱥḄìôᨵᦔឋ஺¡¢ör÷æçFøùSTïe!úûüX!ᖪJᓺLM1992N"1᱐஺77,æçḄu⌕℉ᨵẆ1900NÝ1902Nþÿ᫡
ᦻ᱐1994᱐ஹḄ1913ஹḄᓻ"#ᐜ%1935'஺)*+,᫡
-.ᐸᦔ122345#6789:ὶ<=1994᱐?179—180⚓஺78,FGḄ℉IJ⌕ᨵMᒓḄOPஹQRSTR᝞VWXYZ[8ḄJ⌕℉Iᨵ\Ḅ]᪆1900ஹ_`ᑖ᪆bc1916ஹeᡃ#[81923'஺79,hᱯ᪷Sᚆ-Ẇm▰ᗩ᧜qr᱐2001

65᱐஺80,8s5tu*+vᙠ#xy1927▰ᗩ᧜z{⁚}~᪥ᓅ:ὶ<=2000᱐ஹ᪍1950ᕜᐶᦻ᱐1997᱐ஹcq⍝J1946ஹ2V1956ஹ#y1969ஹ8s5ᐰ19752'℉I஺)*+5-]╋',ᦻ᱐1994᱐?38—49⚓X☭-8s5Ẇmqr᱐1995?1᱐X¡-8s5#7¢£ᜧ᱐1995᱐஺81,ὃ¦§-¨7©22ª«¬WᏉ9¯©ᜧ᱐20009ᨴ᱐?7-8⚓஺82,*+²᪛´µ-¶·¸ᓄc2º»5⌱஺º»5½¾¿À3VÁ¿ÀᱥÿÀ¿À2J_`¿ÀÄPḄᒹÆᦻᓄḄ_`ᑁÈVÉ_`ᡈ¶·Ḅ¿À஺¿À2Ë⌼Í¿À3,οÀ3Ï✄Ñ¿À2,ᑴÓḼÕḄJÖ×ḄØÙÚᐰVÛᮣḄÝᱥÞßàáÑɶ·Ḅâãäå஺¿À3¿À1Ḅᐵçèéêë¿À2Ḅì¿À2IᵨÑ¿À1Ë⌼¿À3,¿À3êë¿À2ḄÕḄJᳮ]ïðᐹòIᵨÑ¿À1ḄᱥÃëä஺

6683,8s5-᪍?26⚓஺84,óôᙠᨬᜧö÷Ḅøᑣú᪀©üᢇᑨஹ©üᦋ☩
᦮ᔠᳮឋḄḄ஺Ḅ℉ᳮ!"ᜧ$%᱐'1993(᱐)ஹ+,ᱏ./01ᖪ3ᓺ5✂1995(᱐)஺85,ὃ89:;<=>$??@ABC“12᱐EFG86,ὃ89:;<=>$??@ABC“1991(᱐;H”155⚓஺87,Kᱯ:MḄᭆO1127⚓஺88,PQ₈:$S153⚓1356⚓஺89,TKᱯ:ὤ᪍ḄᭆOᜩX<=ᑖ᪆$஺90,Kᱯ:ὤ᪍ḄᭆOᜩX<=ᑖ᪆$஺91,PQ₈[\Ḅ]^$_ὃ`aஹbcdefg%Ḅ

67iᑖ᪆$jkᙠmnMoᑣḄoᵨḄsẠuvwxyz{|
g%|}“——wy”ḄMowᳮឋᢵḄ᪀Ḅ᪀஺PQ₈:$S_ὃ`a(N.MacCormick)>bcdef(Weinberger):ᑴᕜ¢£+ᜧ$%᱐'1994(11᱐1197⚓.92,Kᱯ:ὤ᪍ḄᭆOᜩX<=ᑖ᪆$஺93,Kᱯ:ὤ᪍ḄᭆOᜩX<=ᑖ᪆$஺«$ὅ឵ᔡ¯(Engisch)ஹ³´(Esser)ஹµc(Coing)ஹᓱ·¸¯(Canaris)>PQ₈kg%|ᵨ“[¹º»”¼ᦗᭆO$Ḅ¾஺:Engisch,DieEinheitderRechtsordnung,S.83fEsser,GrundsatzundNorm,S.44,239,7Canaris,SystemdenkenundSystembegriffinderJurisprudenz,2.Aufl.1983PQ₈:$S147-51⚓஺