资源描述:
《publication bias in strategic management research》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在工程资料-天天文库。
1、535438JOMXXX10.1177/0149206314535438JournalofManagementHarrisonetal./PublicationBiasinStrategyResearchresearch-article2014JournalofManagementVol.43No.2,February2017400–425DOI:10.1177/0149206314535438©TheAuthor(s)2014Reprintsandpermissions:sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav
2、PublicationBiasinStrategicManagementResearchJeffreyS.HarrisonUniversityofRichmondGeorgeChristopherBanksLongwoodUniversityJeffreyM.PollackNorthCarolinaStateUniversityErnestH.O’BoyleUniversityofIowaJeremyShortUniversityofOklahomaPublicationbiasisthesystematicsuppressionofrese
3、archfindingsduetosmallmagnitude,statisticalinsignificance,orcontradictionofpriorfindingsortheory.Wereviewpossiblerea-sonswhypublicationbiasmayexistinstrategyresearchandexamineempiricalevidenceregardingtheinfluenceofpublicationbiasinthefield.Overall,weconcludethatpublication
4、biasaffectsmany,butnotall,topicsinstrategicmanagementresearch.Correlationinflationduetopublicationbiasrangedinmagnitudefrom.00,indicatingnobias,to.19,representingconsiderablebias.Theseresultssuggestthatcautionshouldbeexercisedwheninterpretingscientificconclusionsregardingce
5、rtaindeterminantsoffirmperformance,whilegreaterconfi-dencemaybeexpressedinothers.Wediscusshowpublicationbiascanbeaddressedbothphilosophicallyandempiricallyinthedomainofstrategy.Keywords:publicationbias;meta-analysis;strategicmanagementresearch;firmperfor-mance;researchmetho
6、dsAcknowledgment:ThisarticlewasacceptedundertheeditorshipofDeborahE.Rupp.Correspondingauthor:ErnestH.O’Boyle,UniversityofIowa,W332PappajohnBusinessBuilding,IowaCity,IA52242-1994,USA.E-mail:oboyleeh@gmail.com400Harrisonetal./PublicationBiasinStrategyResearch401Publicationbia
7、sisthesystematicsuppressionofresearchfindingsduetosmallmagni-tude,statisticalinsignificance,orcontradictionofpriorfindingsortheory(Begg&Mazumdar,1994;Dickersin&Min,1993).Itoccurswhenthefindingsofpublishedworksdiffersystem-aticallyfromthepopulationofresearchonimportantrelati
8、onsofinterest(Rothstein,Sutton,&Borenstein,2005).Acrossmultipledisciplines,suchase