如何回复Peer Review.pdf

《如何回复Peer Review.pdf》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在行业资料-天天文库。

1、BothSidesofManuscripts:RespondingtoPeer-ReviewersCommentsandDoingthePeerReview2012ScientificWritingSeriesJasjitS.Ahluwalia,MD,MPH,MSExecutiveDirector,CenterforHealthEquityAssociateDirector,CTSIAgendaRespondingtoPeer-ReviewersCommentsDoingthePeerReviewCreditgoesto:–RivaraFR,Cumming

2、sP.ReviewingManuscriptsforArchivesofPediatricsandAdolescentMedicine.ArchPediatrAdolescMed.2002;156:11-13.–RivaraFR,CummingsP.RespondingtoReviewersCommentsonSubmittedArtticles.ArchPediatrAdolescMed.2002;156:105-107.RespondingtoReviewersCommentsonSubmittedArticlesSimilarprinciplestore

3、spondingtograntcritiquesTheletterfromtheeditorgenerallycomesinoneof4flavors:–Acceptedwithoutanychanges–onceinmylife–Accepted(provisionalacceptance)withsuggestionsforminorrevisions–Reconsider(“provisionalrejection”)withsuggestionsformajorrevisions–OutrightrejectionDealingWithRejectio

4、nOutrightrejectionispainfulThickhideisprerequisiteDONOTtakeitpersonallyResubmitquicklyMyrecordis3rejectionsbeforeacceptedon4rthtryToappealornottoappealReconsiderwithMajorRevisionsMostcommonroutetofinalpublicationGetsafootinthedoorWhattodo…–Immediatelyandcarefullyreadallcomme

5、nts,notjustsome–Aftercoolingdownforacoupleofdays,re-readallcomments–Respondpromptly,politely,thoughtfully,clearly,andwithdetailReconsiderwithMajorRevisionsAvoiddefensiveorconfrontationaltonesGoalistogleanhelpfulinformationfromthecommentsAdoptanyusefulsuggestionsCalmlyexplainyourp

6、ointofviewwhenyoudisagreeFormat–TheSilverPlatterCoverletterTableorinanoutlinedmanner(thecommentinitalics,yourresponse,locationofchangeorn/a)Manuscriptwithtrackchanges(ornot!)ManuscriptwithtrackchangesacceptedPuteverythingintooneorderlypackageEXAMPLEYouwrote,"Studysubjectsranged

7、inagefrom0to10years;27%were0to2years,and41%were2to6years."ReviewerAwrites,"Thedescriptionoftheagedistributionofstudysubjectswasunclear.Were2-year-oldsinthefirstgrouporthesecondgroup?Andthe2groupsadduptoonly68%."EXAMPLEThereviewerwasconcernedaboutthelackofclarityinourdescriptionofth

8、eagedistribu