爱母尼亚号案

《爱母尼亚号案》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在行业资料-天天文库。

1、EMJA(Ms.“EMJA”BraakSchiffahrtsKG,Germanyv.WartsilaDieselAktiebolag,SwedenSwedishSupremeCourt,15October,1997,caseno.3174/95)Claimant:Ms“EMJA”BraakSchiffahrtsKG(Germany)Defendant:WartsilaDieselAktiebolag(Sweden)Subjectmatter:assignmentofarbitrationclauseContentTh

2、eintroductionofthe“EMJA”caseAbriefanalysisofthepartiesThevalidityofthearbitrationclauseafteracontractassignmentThearbitrationagreementtothethirdparty’seffectivenessAsimilarcaseinChinaSummaryScheepswerfFerusBV(Dutch)sub-contract（分包合约）ScheepswerfBijlsmaBV(Dutch)W

3、artsila(Sweden)MSEMJASandFirdenBV(Dutch)Emja(German)transferassignmentInstituteproceedingdeliveryofenginetransferassignmentpurchasemainlegalproblemsAssignmentoftheInternationalCommercialArbitrationAgreementThevalidityoftheassignmentofarbitrationagreementtotheth

4、irdpartyThedebatefocusonthequestion:WhethertheassigneeisboundbythearbitralclauseWartsilapreferthemeansofarbitrationComplicatedtechnicalquestionanarbitratorwithpecializedknowledge.ArbitrationprovidesagreaterpossibilityForWartsila:Thenewpartyshouldbeboundotherwis

5、etheremainingpartywouldbeinlessfavorableposition.Whenacontractualrightisassigned,thenewcreditorcannothavemorerightsthantheassignor.ThearbitrationclauseonlyexistedbetweentheoriginalpartiesForEmjaArbitralclausecouldbeinvokedagainstitriskofamiscarriageofjustice.Re

6、coursetoarbitrationtherequestforarbitrationwouldbedeniedAftercontractassignment,whethertheassigneeisboundbythearbitralclause?FOCUS:ThearbitrationagreementiscapableofsurvivingtheinvalidityofthecontractAfteratransferassignment,whetheritisstillsurvivingWartsilaThe

7、ImportancetoKnowitAdmitthevalidityofthearbitrationassignmentHopethecontractassignmentcannotaffectthevalidityoftheclauseEmjaKnowthearbitrationclause’sexistinganddon’tdenyitsvalidityDisputeTheinitialpartiesareboundbythearbitrationclauseTwoViews☆Arbitrationclausec

8、anbetransferredwiththeotherclausesinthecontractatthesametime☆Arbitrationclausecannotbeassignedwiththecontractassignmentatthesametime,exceptboththepartiesagree.Arbitrationcla