资源描述:
《罗秉祥:Confucian Views on Suicide and Their Implications for Euthanasia》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在学术论文-天天文库。
1、ConfucianViewsonSuicideandTheirImplicationsforEuthanasiaPing-CheungLoPing-CheungLoisaprofessorofphilosophyattheHongKongBaptistUniversity.Hehaswrittenextensivelyonbioethicsandcomparativereligiousethics.HeisalsotheauthorofTreatingPersonsasEnds:AnEssayonKant'sMoralPhilosophy(1987).I.,Inthisselection,Lo
2、distinguishesbetweenself-regardingandother-regardingsuicides.Hemaintains,ithatwhilekillingoneselfforone'sownsakewasconsideredmostlywronginpremodernChina,givingupIone'sownlifeforthesakeofotherswasquitecommonandevenadmired.HeshowshowtheclassicalIConfucianidealsofbenevolence(ren)andjustice(yi)governhow
3、oneshouldliveanddie.Ontheotherhand,healsoexplainshowonekindofself-regardingsuicide,namely,dyingtoavoidhumiliationanddisgrace,wasacceptedintraditionalConfucianismandevenmodernChina.1.INTRODUCTIONitasin.InancientChina,however,notwith•standingsomepettysuicidescommittedbyOnJune2,1927,afamousprofessorofQ
4、ingcommonpeople,manyeminentfiguresusedHuaUniversity,WangGuowei,drownedhim•suicidetoexpresstheircounter-culturalaspi•selfinalakeoftheformerimperialgardeninrations.Thesewerepraiseworthysuicides,Beijing.Hissuicideprovedextremelycontro•Liangconcluded,andshouldbynomeansbeversialandevokedmuchdiscussion.1H
5、iscol•rashlyreproachedbyalienEuropeanvaluesleagueandfamousintellectual,LiangQichao,(Liang,1927,p.75).wroteseveraleulogiesinhishonor.InoneofIthinkthemainideaofLiang'sobservationtheseeulogiesLiangremindedhiscolleaguesislargelycorrect.TraditionalChineseethicalandstudents,wholivedinaculturewhichhadpersp
6、ectivesonsuicidediffersignificantlyfromjustenteredthemodernageandwasundertheirWesterncounterparts,withthepossibleheavyWesterninfluence,nottouseWesternexceptionofStoicRome.JustasWesternviewsperspectivestoevaluateWang'ssuicide.Euro•onsuicidehavebeenstronglyinfluencedbythepeans,Liangasserted,usedtorega
7、rdsuicideancientGreekphilosophers(Pythagoras,Plato,asanactofcowardice,andChristianitymadeandAristotle)andAugustinianChristianity,theChineseviews,especiallyamongtheedu•catedpeople,havebeenlargelyinflue