资源描述:
《In the United States》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在教育资源-天天文库。
1、IntheUnitedStates,thoseattitudesbegantosoftenduringthecourseofthenineteenthcenturywhencorporationsinAmericansocietyfirstbegantoblossomandtheirpotentialtodoharmfirstbecamesignificant.Bytheturnofthetwentiethcentury,astheIndustrialRevolutionfundamentallyalteredtheroleoflargecorporationsinAmericanlife,t
2、heneedforsomemechanismofregulatingandpunishingcorporatemalfeasancebecameallthemoreclear.MosthistoriesofAmericancorporatecriminalliabilitystartthere—theIndustrialRevolution,theriseoftheregulatorystate,andtheSupremeCourt’slandmark1909decisioninNewYorkCentral&HudsonRiverRailroadv.UnitedStates.InNewYork
3、Central,theCourtupheldtheconstitutionalityoftheElkinsAct,afederalstatuteregulatingrailwayratesthatimposedcriminalliabilityoncorporationsthatviolatedthestatute’smandates.Insweepinglanguage,theCourtrejectedthecorporation’scontentionthat,asanentity,itcouldnotcommitacrime,findingCongresshadexpansivepowe
4、rtoregulateinterstatecommercethatincludedtheauthoritytoimposecriminalsanctions.TheCourtwasuntroubledbythelegalfictionthatanentitycouldneithertakecriminalactionnorpossesscriminalintent.Instead,theCourtadoptedthecivillawdoctrineofrespondeatsuperior,holdingthatacorporationcouldconstitutionallybeconvict
5、edofacrimewhenoneofitsagentshadcommittedacriminalact(1)withinthescopeofhisorheremployment,and(2)forthebenefitofthecorporation.Thatstandardremainsgoodlawtothisday.BeginningthehistoryofAmericanentityliabilitywithNewYorkCentraliscertainlylogicalbecausethecaseestablishedtheauthorityofCongresstocriminali
6、zecorporateconduct.ButdoingsooverlooksaveryimportantmovementthatwasafootwellbeforeNewYorkCentral,onethatiscriticaltounderstandinghowandwhyentityliabilityexpandedsorapidlyinitswake.WhileNewYorkCentralinvolvedastatutethatexplicitlyextendedcriminalliabilitytocorporations,forsomefiftyyearsbeforeCongress
7、passedtheElkinsAct,prosecutorsacrossthecountryhadbeencreativelypursuingcriminalsanctionsagainstcorporationsbyapplyinggeneralcriminallaws—lawsthat,bytheirterms,didnotextendtocorporationsasentities—toco