资源描述:
《Alexy-the nature of legal philosophy》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在学术论文-天天文库。
1、RatioJuris.Vol.17No.2June2004(156–67)TheNatureofLegalPhilosophy*ROBERTALEXYAbstract.Philosophyisgeneralandsystematicreflectionaboutwhatthereis,whatoughttobedoneorisgood,andhowknowledgeaboutbothispossible.Legalphi-losophyraisesthesequestionswithrespecttothelaw.Insodoing,legalphilosoph
2、yisengagedinreasoningaboutthenatureoflaw.Theargumentsaddressedtothequestionofthenatureoflawrevolvearoundthreeproblems.Thefirstproblemaddressesthequestion:Inwhatkindsofentitiesdoesthelawconsist,andhowaretheseentitiesconnectedsuchthattheyformtheoverarchingentitywecall“law”?Theanswerist
3、hatlawconsistsofnormsasmeaningcontentswhichformanorma-tivesystem.Thesecondproblemaddressesthequestionofhownormsasmeaningcontentsareconnectedwiththerealworld.Thisconnectioncanbegraspedbymeansoftheconceptsofauthoritativeissuanceandsocialefficacy.Thelatterincludestheconceptofcoercionorf
4、orce.Thethirdproblemaddressesthecorrectnessorlegiti-macyoflaw,and,bythis,therelationshipbetweenlawandmorality.Toaskaboutthenatureoflawistoaskaboutnecessaryrelationsbetweentheconceptsofnor-mativemeaning,authoritativeissuanceaswellassocialefficacy,andcorrectnessofcontent.Thequestionoft
5、henatureoflegalphilosophyconnectstwoproblems.Thefirstconcernsthegeneralnatureofphilosophy,thesecond,thespecialchar-acterofthatpartofphilosophywecall“legalphilosophy.”I.TheNatureofPhilosophyTherearesomanyschools,methods,styles,subjects,andidealsofphiloso-phythatitisdifficulttoexplainit
6、snature.Ageneralexplanationofthenatureofphilosophywouldpresupposethatalloratleastmostoftheverydifferentconceptionsofphilosophywhichhaveappearedinthehistoryofthefieldhavesomethingincommonthatcanbeconceivedofasthefocalmeaningortheconceptofphilosophy.Perhapsthemostgeneralfeatureofthecon
7、ceptofphilosophyseemstobereflexivity.Philosophyisreflectivebecauseitisreasoningaboutreason-ing.Philosophyisreasoningaboutreasoning,foritssubject,thehuman*IshouldliketothankStanleyL.PaulsonforhelpandadviceonmattersofEnglishstyle.©BlackwellPublishingLtd2004,9600GarsingtonRoad,OxfordOX42
8、DQ,UKand350MainStre