资源描述:
《Chapter 24 Terror, Justice and Freedom》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在学术论文-天天文库。
1、CHAPTER24Terror,JusticeandFreedomAl-Qaidaspent$500,000ontheevent,whileAmerica,intheincidentanditsaftermath,lostaccordingtothelowestestimatemorethan$500billion.OsamabinLadenExperienceshouldteachustobemostonourguardtoprotectlibertywhenthegovernmentspurposesarebeneficient...Thegreatestdan
2、gerstolibertylurkininsidiousencroachmentbymenofzeal,wellmeaningbutwithoutunderstanding.SupremeCourtJusticeLouisBrandeisTheythatcangiveupessentiallibertytoobtainalittletemporarysafetydeserveneitherlibertynorsafety.BenjaminFranklin24.1IntroductionTheattacksofSeptember11,2001,onNewYorkan
3、dWashingtonhavehadahugeimpactontheworldofsecurityengineering,andthisimpacthasbeendeepenedbythelaterattacksonMadrid,Londonandelsewhere.AseveryonehassurelyrealisedbynowandasthequotefromOsamabinLadenbluntlyspellsoutmodernterrorismworkslargelybyprovokingoverreaction.Therearemanythornyissu
4、es.First,theresthepoliticalquestion:areWesternsocietiesuniquelyvulnerablebecausewereopensocietieswithdemocracyandafreepress,whoseinteractionfacilitatesfearmongeringandifsowhat(ifanything)shouldwedoaboutit?TheattackschallengedourcorevaluesexpressedintheUSAastheConstitution,andinEuropea
5、stheCon-ventiononHumanRights.Ourcommonheritageofdemocracyandtheruleoflaw,builtslowlyandpainfullysincetheeighteenthcentury,mighthave769770Chapter24■Terror,JusticeandFreedombeenthoughtwellentrenched,especiallyafterwedefendeditsuccessfullyintheColdWar.Yettheaftermathof9/11sawonegovernmen
6、tafteranotherintroducingauthoritarianmeasuresrangingfromfingerprintingatairportsthroughIDcardsandlarge-scalesurveillancetodetentionwithouttrialandeventorture.Scantheedhasbeengiventowhetherthesemeasureswouldactuallybeeffective:wesawinChapter15thattheUS-VISITfingerprintingprogramdidntwork
7、,andthatgiventhefalsealarmrateoftheunderlyingtechnologyitcouldneverreasonablyhavebeenexpectedtowork.Wevenotmerelycompromisedourprinciples;wevewastedbillionsonbadengineering,anddamagedwholeindustries.Cantwefindbetterwaystodefendfreedom?Second,therestheeconomicquestion:whyaresuchvastamou
8、ntsof