资源描述:
《扩张与不确定:囊性纤维化 分类与遗传学 亚当·亨德科》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在教育资源-天天文库。
1、SociologyofHealth&IllnessVol.25No.12003ISSN0141–9889,pp.50–70BlackwellPublishing,LtdOxford,UKSHILSociologyofHealth&Illness0141-9889©BlackwellPublishersLtd/EditorialBoard2001January2002251000OriginalArticleCysticfibrosis,classificationandgeneticsAdamM.HedgecoeExpans
2、ionanduncertainty:cysticfibrosis,classificationandgeneticsAdamM.HedgecoeSociologySubjectGroup,UniversityofSussexAbstractThispaperpresentsanempiricalexaminationofgeneticization,theprocesswheregeneticexplanationsgainascendancyinmedicalandsocialdiscourse.ByfocusingonC
3、ysticFibrosis(CF),thisstudyshowshowgeneticexplanationsplayaroleinthereclassificationofCysticFibrosis.Oneresultofthisgeneticizationisanosologicalexpansion,wheretheboundariesofthediseaseexpandtoincludeacertainformofmaleinfertility.Inadditionthispaperhighlightstheunc
4、ertaintyintheCFclassificationsystemthatresultsfromtheuseofgeneticexplanations.Keywords:genetics,explanations,ethics,cysticfibrosis‘Comparedwithpolygenicdiseases,cysticfibrosisiseasyandthereforepaintstherosiestpictureofwhatcanbeachievedbygeneticresearch’(GeddesandAlt
5、on1999:1052).1.IntroductionAlthoughanumberofsociologistshaveengagedwiththe‘new’genetics(seeConradandGabe1999forareview),theyhavetendedeithertocritiquethebroadersocialimplicationsofgenetictechnologies(e.g.KatzRothman1995)ortofocusonpatients’responsestoindividualas
6、pectsofmedicalgeneticssuchasgeneticcounselling(Bosk1992)orperceptionsofrisk(Hallowell1999).Whiletheseapproachesarevitaladditionstothenormalbioethicsdiscussion,dominatedasitisbyphilosophicalandlegaltheory(Hoffmaster1992,Nelson2000)theytendtotakethefactsofgeneticsc
7、ienceasagiven.Thispapertakesadifferentapproach,addressingthechallengeraisedbyauthorssuchasBartley(1990)orCasperandBerg(1995)whosuggestthatresearchersshouldturntowardsmedicalknowledgeasasiteofsociologicalinterest.Somesociologistshaveexaminedmedicalknowledgeinanumb
8、erofdifferentareas(seeElston1997orAtkinson1995:Chapter3forreviews)andthereisworkonthesocialconstructionofgeneticdisease(Yoxen1982,©BlackwellPublishingLtd/Edito