资源描述:
《学位论文-—汽车专业 翻译 中英文(全)a person who is injured in an automobile accident while in the ....doc》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在学术论文-天天文库。
1、UNINSUREDMOTORISTCOVERAGETHEIMPACTOFWORKERS’COMPENSATIONANDWORK-RELATEDINJURIESByTimothyW.MonseesApersonwhoisinjuredbyaco-employeeinanautomobileaccidentwhileinthecourseofhisorheremploymentmaybeentitledtorecoverunderbothapolicyprovidingforuninsuredmotorvehiclecoverage(UM)andunderthe
2、workers’compensationlaw.Thissituationraisesseverallegalissues.First,inlightofcaselawimmunizingco-employeesfromlegalliabilityunderworkers’compensation,istheat-faultemployeeconsideredsomeonefromwhomtheinjuredpartyis“legallyentitledtorecover?”Second,fromwhoseuninsuredmotoristpolicycan
3、aninjuredworkerrecover?Finally,mayaninjuredemployeerecoverbothuninsuredmotorvehiclebenefitsandworkers’compensation?TheWorkers’CompensationLaw,§287.010R.S.Mo.etseq.,providestheexclusiveremedyforemployeesagainstemployersforinjuriescoveredbyitsprovisions.However,thisimmunityextendstoe
4、mployeesoftheemployerinamorelimitedfashion.Whilesuitsagainstemployeespersonallyforbreachofthedutytomaintainasafeworkingenvironmentarepreemptedbytheworkers’compensationlaws,anemployeemaysueafellowemployeeforaffirmativenegligentactsoutsidethescopeofanemployer’sresponsibilitytoprovide
5、asafeworkplace.Gunnettv.GirardierBldg.AndRealtyCo.70S.W.3d632(Mo.App.E.D.,2002).Thisraisesthequestion,whatisan“affirmativenegligentact”?12InStateexrel.Taylorv.Wallace,73S.W.3d620,623(Mo.2002)theCourtstatedthat,“thequestionofwhatconstitutesan“affirmativenegligentact”hasnotprovensusc
6、eptibleofreliabledefinition,andMissouricourtshaveessentiallyappliedtheruleonacasebycasebasiswithclosereferencetothefactsineachindividualcase.”Id.Withoutan“affirmativenegligentact”aco-employeetortfeasorcannotbeheldliable,sotheonlywayforaninjuredemployeetocollectforthenegligenceofana
7、utomobiletortfeasormaybetocollectfromanuninsuredmotoristpolicy.Conventionalwisdomhasheldthat,duetothehigherstandardofcarerequiredofoperatorsofmotorvehicles,afellowemployeedriverwassimilarlyheldtoahigherstandardofcarethanthegeneralobligationofemployerstoprovideasafeworkplace.Operato
8、rsofmotorvehiclesareheldto