资源描述：
《Should_Coercive_Interrogation-——by E.A. Posner》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在学术论文-天天文库。
1、11676CTimeofRequest:Saturday,December17,201107:39:25ESTClientID/ProjectName:NumberofLines:1125JobNumber:2825:323733484ResearchInformationService:TermsandConnectorsSearchPrintRequest:CurrentDocument:1Source:MichiganLawReviewSearchTerms:ShouldCoerciveInterrogationBeLe
2、galSendto:University,PekingPEKINGUNIVERSITYPEKINGUNIVERSITYLIBRARYBEIJING,CHN100871Page11of1DOCUMENTCopyright(c)2006MichiganLawReviewMichiganLawReviewFebruary,2006104Mich.L.Rev.671LENGTH:18452wordsARTICLE:SHOULDCOERCIVEINTERROGATIONBELEGAL?NAME:EricA.Posner*andAdria
3、nVermeule**BIO:*KirklandandEllisProfessorofLaw,UniversityofChicago.B.A.,M.A.1988,Yale;J.D.1991,Harvard.**BernardD.MeltzerProfessorofLaw,UniversityofChicago.B.A.1990,Harvard;J.D.1993,Harvard.-Ed.ThankstoMatthewAdler,LarryAlexander,AlAlschuler,OrenGross,BernardHarcour
4、t,TraceyMeares,TomMiles,JaniceNadler,JideNzelibe,ArielPorat,LarrySolum,CassSunstein,LesleyWexler,andworkshopparticipantsattheUniversityofChicago,theUniversityofMinnesota,andNorthwesternUniversityforhelpfulcomments;andtoJustinRubinforexcellentresearchassistance.Posne
5、rthankstheLyndeandHarryBradleyFoundationandtheJohnM.OlinFoundationforfinancialsupport,whileVermeulethankstheRussellJ.ParsonsResearchFund.LEXISNEXISSUMMARY:...Coerciveinterrogationisnowalivesubject,thanksto9/11....Shueflinchesfromthisimplication,however,concludingint
6、heendthatthebestlegalregimewouldboth"prohibit"coerciveinterrogationexanteandyetalsocontainsomesortofexpostmechanismforallowingjustifiedinterrogationtoescapepunishment:"Thetorturershouldbeinroughlythesamepositionassomeonewhocommitscivildisobedience....Ifthesituationa
7、pproximatesthoseintheimaginaryexamplesinwhichtortureseemspossibletojustify,ajudgecansurelybeexpectedtosuspendthesentence....Underthenecessitydefense,whichexistsinU.S.lawaswell,anactthatwouldotherwisebeaseriouscrime-killing,torture-doesnotgiverisetolegalliabilityifit
8、wasnecessarytopreventagreaterharm....TEXT:[*672]IntroductionCoerciveinterrogationisnowalivesubject,thanksto9/11.Atonetime,coerciveinterrog
