资源描述:
《Efficiency and Complexity in Grammars》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在学术论文-天天文库。
1、JohnHawkinshaslongbeenatrail-blazerintheattempttoreconciletheresultsofformalandfunctionallinguistics.EfficiencyandComplexityinGrammarschartsnewterritoryinthisdomain.Thebookarguespersuasivelythatasmallnumberofperformance-basedprinciplescombinetoaccountformanygr
2、am-maticalconstraintsproposedbyformallinguistsandalsoexplaintheoriginsofnumeroustypologicalgeneralizationsdiscoveredbyfunctionalists.FrederickJ.Newmeyer,UniversityofWashington.ThecentralclaiminHawkins’snewbookisthatgrammarfacilitateslanguageprocessing.Thisrat
3、hernaturalideaisbynomeansnovel:attemptstoexplainaspectsoflinguisticstructureonthebasisofprocessingconsiderationsgobackatleasttothe1950s.Butsuchattemptshavecharacteristicallybeenlittlemorethan“justsostories”–thatis,posthocaccountsofisolatedobservations.Whathas
4、beenlackinguntilnowisanythingthatcouldbecalledatheoryofhowconstraintsonthehumanprocessorshapegrammaticalstructure.Hawkinshasfilledthislacuna.Startingwiththreeverygeneralandintuitiveprinciplesaboutefficientprocessingoflanguage,hederivesaricharrayofpredictionsabo
5、utwhatkindsofgrammaticalstructuresshouldbepreferred.Hethenadducesawealthofevidencetodemonstratethathispredictionshold.Hisdataareofavarietyoftypes,includinggrammaticalpatternsinparticu-larlanguages,typologicaltendencies,usagestatisticsfromcorpora,historicalcha
6、nges,andpsycholinguisticfindings.Thephenomenahedealswitharesim-ilarlyvaried,includingwordorder,casemaking,filler-gapdependencies,islandconstraints,andanaphoricbinding.EfficiencyandComplexityinGrammarsisalandmarkwork,settinganewstandardinthestudyoftherelationship
7、betweenlinguisticcompetenceandperformance.TomWasow,StanfordUniversity.Hawkinsarguesthatgrammarsareprofoundlyaffectedbythewayhumansprocesslanguage.Hedevelopsasimplebuteleganttheoryofperformanceandgrammarbydrawingonconceptsanddatafromgenerativegrammar,lin-guist
8、ictypology,experimentalpsycholinguisticsandhistoricallinguistics.Insodoing,healsomakesalaudableattempttobridgetheschismbetweenthetworesearchtraditionsinlinguistics,theformalandthefunction