资源描述:
《Linda Nochlin, From “Why Have There Been No Great Women Artists” (1971)》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在行业资料-天天文库。
1、LindaNochlin,From“WhyHaveThereBeenNoGreatWomenArtists?”(1971)Whiletherecentupsurgeoffeministactivityinthiscountryhasindeedbeenaliberatingone,itsforcehasbeenchieflyemotional,personal,psychological,andsubjective—centered,liketheotherradicalmovementstowhichitisrelated,onthepresen
2、tanditsimmediateneeds,ratherthanonhistoricalanalysisofthebasicintellectualissueswhichthefeministattackonthestatus1quoautomaticallyraises.Likeanyrevolution,however,thefeministoneultimatelymustcometogripswiththeintellectualandideologicalbasisofthevariousintellectualorscholarlydi
3、sciplines—history,philosophy,sociology,psychology,etc.—inthesamewaythatitquestionstheideologiesofpresentsocialinstitutions.If,asJohnStuartMillsuggested,wetendtoacceptwhateverisasnatural,thisisjustastrueintherealmofacademicinvestigationasitisinoursocialarrangements.Intheformer,
4、too,"natural"assumptionsmustbequestionedandthemythicbasisofmuchso-calledfactbroughttolight.Anditisherethattheverypositionofwomanasanacknowledgedoutsider,themaverick"she"insteadofthepresumablyneutral"one"—inrealitythewhite-male-position-accepted-as-natural,orthehidden"he"asthes
5、ubjectofallscholarlypredicates—isadecidedadvantage,ratherthanmerelyahindranceorasubjectivedistortion.Inthefieldofarthistory,thewhiteWesternmaleviewpoint,unconsciouslyacceptedastheviewpointofthearthistorian,may—anddoes—provetobeinadequatenotmerelyonmoralandethicalgrounds,orbeca
6、useitiselitist,butonpurelyintellectualones.Inrevealingthefailureofmuchacademicarthistory,andagreatdealofhistoryingeneral,fortakeaccountoftheunacknowledgedvaluesystem,theverypresenceofanintrudingsubjectinhistoricalinvestigation,thefeministcritiqueatthesametimelaysbareitsconcept
7、ualsmugness,itsmeta-historicalnaivety.Atamomentwhenalldisciplinesarebecomingmoreself-conscious,moreawareofthenatureoftheirpresuppositionsasexhibitedintheverylanguagesandstructuresofthevariousfieldsofscholarship,suchuncriticalacceptanceof"whatis"as"natural"maybeintellectuallyfa
8、tal.JustasMillsawmaledominationasoneofalongseriesofsocialinju