如何回复审稿人意见(response to reviews)

《如何回复审稿人意见(response to reviews)》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在行业资料-天天文库。

1、DearEditor,Wehavestudiedthevaluablecommentsfromyou,theassistanteditorandreviewerscarefully,andtriedourbesttorevisethemanuscript.Thepointtopointrespondstothereviewer’scommentsarelistedasfollowing:Respondstothereviewer’scomments:Reviewer1Comment1:inpage3,line40,wefedrats...

2、"changedtoratswerefedwith...Response:Accordingtothereviewer’scomment,wehavecorrectedthesentence.Furthermore,wehavehadthemanuscriptpolishedwithaprofessionalassistanceinwriting.Comment2:page25.Thestyleofreference40isnotright(usinginitialsforthefirstnames).Sincethispaperhasb

3、eenpublished,thevolumeandpageNosshouldbeprovided.Response:Thankyouforyourcarefulwork.Wehaveaddedthevolumeandpagenumbersforreference40.Reviewer2Comment:Iwouldliketothanktheauthorsfortheireffortsinaddressingthecriticismswithadditionalexperiments.Theonecriticismthattheydidno

4、taddresswasrelatingtoenergyexpenditureasthereasonthattheanimalsonthelowcalciumdietgainedmoreweight.WhileIunderstandthatperformingthisexperimentwillnotaffecttheconclusionofthismanuscript,IdobelievethatthispointcouldbediscussedintheDiscussionsection.Response:Thankyouforyour

5、valuableadvice.Basedonthepreviousrevision,wefurtheraddresstherelationshipbetweenlowcalciumdietandenergyexpenditureinthesectionofdiscussionaccordingtoyourthoughtfulcomments.Reviewer3Comment1:Inthetextyouoftenwrite:“Aspreviouslydescribed”.Unlessthatpaperisfromyourlaboroneof

6、themethodpaperco-authorsisonthepresentMSthisisnotquitepropersincethestatementinfersmethoddevelopmentfromyourlab.Therearenumerousinstanceslikethatinthemethodssection;theseshouldallbechanged“accordingtothosedescribedby…..”Response:Wearesorryforthislanguagemistake.Wehavecare

7、fullycorrectedthisphrasethroughoutthemanuscriptaccordingtoyourcomment.Comment2:Therearestillsomewording,sentencestructureandgrammaticalissueseveninthisbasicallywellputtogetherMS.Forexample,whileauthorsmayhavebeenexcitedaboutthedatayoucannotstartasentencewith“Excitedly”inl

8、ine418or“Whatever”inline395.Response:Thankyouverymuchtopointoutthesentencestructureandgrammatica