gmat范文-10-智课网

《gmat范文-10-智课网》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在行业资料-天天文库。

1、智课网GMAT备考资料GMAT官方写作题库范文赏析10.Thefollowingappearedintheeditorialsectionofalocalnewspaper.“Thispastwinter,200studentsfromWaymarshStateCollegetraveledtothestatecapitolbuildingtoprotestagainstproposedcutsinfundingforvariousstatecollegeprograms.Theother12,000Waymarshstudentsevident

2、lyweren’tsoconcernedabouttheireducation:theyeitherstayedoncampusorleftforwinterbreak.Sincethegroupwhodidnotprotestisfarmorenumerous,itismorerepresentativeofthestate’scollegestudentsthanaretheprotesters.Thereforethestatelegislatureneednotheedtheappealsoftheprotestingstudents.”

3、范文Theconclusionoftheargumentisthatthestatelegislaturedoesnotneedtoconsidertheperspectiveofprotestingstudents.Theauthorpointsoutthataminorityof200outof12,000studentstraveledtothestatecapitoltodemonstrateagainstpotentialcutsincollegeprogramsandfunding.Theauthorconcludesthatstud

4、entsnotinattendanceareconsequentlynotinterestedinthisissue;iftheywere,thenthoseremainingstudentswouldhavetakenpartinthisprotest,.Thereasoninghereisflawedfortworeasons.First,theauthorassumesthatsinceonlyone-tenthofthetotalstudentbodytookpartintheprotest,thesestudents’donotrepr

5、esenttheentirestudentbody.Thisassumptionisflagrantandhasty.If,perhaps,itturnsoutthattheprotestingstudentswererandomlyselectedfromtheentirestudentbody,itwouldbesafetosaythattheirviewsreflecttheviewsoftheentirecollege.Informationregardingthemethodofselectingorcategorizingprotes

6、tingstudentsisnecessaryforthecogencyoftheargument.Itisgroundlesstoconcludethattheiropinionsdonotreflecttheopinionsoftheirpeers.Second,theauthorarbitrarilycreatesadirectcorrelationbetweentheremaining12,000studentswhostayedoncampusorleftforwinterbreakandthedubitableassertiontha

7、ttheyareapatheticabouttheireducation.Oneresponsetothisreasoningisthatthestudentswhodidnotparticipatefeltthattheirconcernswouldbeaccuratelyexpressedbytheprotestingstudents,whoareasmallbutaccuraterepresentationofstudentsentiment.Regardless,theauthorhasnotdemonstratedasubstantia

8、lconnectionbetweenthestudents’perceivedapathyandthefactthattheyeithe