共谋者对加重结果的刑事责任承担——李某张某抢劫案的分析报告

《共谋者对加重结果的刑事责任承担——李某张某抢劫案的分析报告》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在工程资料-天天文库。

1、AbstractThesituationthattwoormorepersonsconspiretorealizecertaincrimebutinfactonlyapartofthemimplementexecutiveconductofthiscrimeoccursalotinjudicialpractice,sometimeswiththeaggravatedconsequence.Thereisconsiderablecontroversyabouttheconvictionandsentencingt

2、ooffenderswhoonlyconspire.Thisarticlestartswithatypicalcaseandanalysestheconvictionandsentencingtoconspiratorsabouttheaggravatedconsequence.Thisarticleisdividedintofourparts-PartOneisthecasedescription.Thispartdescribesthecase:ZhangandLiconspiredtorob.Afterr

3、eachingthevillageofrobberysite,Zhangdidn'tgototherobberysitebecauseoftemporaryreasonswhileLiwent,implementedrobberyandkilledWangforrobbing.PartTwoisdifferentopinionsandcontendingfocusinthiscase.Therearethreedifferentopinions:ThefirstopinionthinksthatZhangand

4、Lidon'testablishjointcrime,ZhangestablishesRobberyCrime(Preparation)aloneanddoesn'tbearcriminalresponsibilityforthedeathofWang;ThesecondopinionthinksZhangandLiestablishjointcrimeabouttheRobberyCrimedessentialoffensebutZhangdoesn'tbearcriminalresponsibilityfo

5、rthedeathofWang;ThethirdopinionthinksthatZhangandLiestablishjointprincipaloffenderabouttheRobberyCrimeessentialoffenseandaggravatedconsequentialoffenseandZhangshouldbearcriminalresponsibilityforthedeathofWang.Thispartalsodescribesthecontendingfocus:Conspira

6、torsestablishjointcrimeornot,alltheconspiratorsestablishthecollusivejointprincipaloffenderornotwhenonlyapartofthemimplementexecutiveconductofthecrime,andZhangshouldbearcriminalresponsibilityforthedeathofWangornotaswellasthereason.PartThreeisLegalAnalysis.Fir

7、stly,thewriterdemonstratesthatConspiratorsestablishjointcrime;secondly,thewriterdiscussesthetheoryofthecollusivejointprincipaloffenderfromfouraspects,pointsthatitisquitenecessarytousethedivisionclassificationmethodtoclassifytheconspiratorsaccurateconvictiona

8、ndsentencingandconcludesthatZhangandLiestablishthecollusivejointprincipaloffenderabouttheRobberyCrime'sessentialoffense;thirdly,thewriteranalysesthequestionthatcollusivejointprincipaloffendersof