资源描述:
《The Literature of Pain》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在学术论文-天天文库。
1、TheLiteratureofPainJeffreyMeyersInlightoftherecentAbuGhraibprisonscandal,thispaperexaminesvariousworksofliteraturetorevealthatpeoplewhohaveprisonersintheirpowertendtotormenttheirvictims.RichardHenryDanaandHermanMelville’sseafaringnovelsrevealhowthecaptainandhismatesassumebrutal,go
2、dlikepowersoverthecommonsailors;T.E.Lawrencedescribeshowthevictim’spaincanbecomeamasochisticpleasure;FranzKafkaimaginesastateofuniversalguilt,wherethevictim,anaverageman,suffersinthegripofanelaboratetorturemachine;FyodorDostoyevskyandJacoboTimerman,bothpoliticalprisonerswhosurvive
3、dtodescribetheirterror,andGeorgeOrwell,meditatingoncontemporarytotalitarianregimesashesufferedtheagoniesofmedicaltreatment,transformtheirpainintoart.Suchliteraryworksprovideinsightsintothemorallyambiguousdepthsofpunishment.Everysceneoftorture,basedontheauthors’experience,observati
4、onandimagination,hasthesamecontextasthosevividlycapturedintheAbuGhraibsnapshots.Whatneedistheretoweepoverpartsoflife?Thewholeofitcallsfortears.SenecaAmericanswereshockedbythephotographsofU.S.soldiersterrifyingandtorturingprisonersinIraqandbytheabuseanddeathsofdetaineesinAfghanista
5、nandGuantánamoBay.WeknowthatevenU.S.citizensdetainedunderHomelandSecurityrulescanbeheldindefinitelyandwithoutlegalaidandthatourmilitaryhasbeendelegatinginterrogationsofcaptivestosecretprisonsinEasternEurope.Yetourattorneygeneralpubliclydefendstheseandotherviolationsofourlawsasvital
6、tonationalsecurity.InthewidercontextoftheWorldTradeCenterattackandtheinvasionofIraq–twohugeeventsthatarepersistentlyandfraudulentlylinked–Americanshavelargelyignoredtheseatrocities.A“fewbadapples”havebeenputinjailandthemythofessentialAmericangoodnessandGodlinesspersists,despitethe
7、horrificevidenceofourhistoryandculture.Ourliterature,however,revealsthatpeoplewhohaveprisonersintheirpowertendtotreatthemcruelly.RichardHenryDanaandHermanMelville’sseafaringnovelsrevealhowthecaptainandhismatesassumebrutal,godlikepowersoverthecommonsailors;T.E.Lawrencedescribeshowth
8、evictim’spaincanbecomeamasochisti