资源描述:
《Reconciling Privacy and Speech in the Era of Big Data_ A Comparative Legal Analysis》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在学术论文-天天文库。
1、William&MaryLawReviewVolume56
2、Issue4Article8ReconcilingPrivacyandSpeechintheEraofBigData:AComparativeLegalAnalysisRonaldJ.KrotoszynskiJr.RepositoryCitationRonaldJ.KrotoszynskiJr.,ReconcilingPrivacyandSpeechintheEraofBigData:AComparativeLegalAnalysis,56Wm.&MaryL.Rev.1279(2015),http://scholarsh
3、ip.law.wm.edu/wmlr/vol56/iss4/8Copyrightc2015bytheauthors.ThisarticleisbroughttoyoubytheWilliam&MaryLawSchoolScholarshipRepository.http://scholarship.law.wm.edu/wmlrRECONCILINGPRIVACYANDSPEECHINTHEERAOFBIGDATA:ACOMPARATIVELEGALANALYSISRONALDJ.KROTOSZYNSKI,JR.*ABSTRACTInboththeUnitedStatesandt
4、henationsofWesternEurope,significantconstitutionalcommitmentssafeguardbothexpressivefreedom(includingfreedomofspeechandofthepress)andalsoageneralizedconstitutionalrightofprivacy.Withsomeregularity,however,theserightswillcomeintoconflict,astheprotectionofonerightcanbeachievedonlyatthecostofabr
5、idgingordenyingtheother.Whenagovernmentofficialorpublicfigureobjectstothepublicationofanembarrassingphotograph,perhapstakenbyaninvasivepaparazzo,itissimplynotpossibletofullyvindicatebothanewspaper’sinterestinpublishingthephotographandthesubject’sinterestinprivacy.Althoughgeneralizationsofteno
6、versimplifycomplexlegal,cultural,andmoralunderstandings,itneverthelessremainstruethatEuropeancourtstendtoplacegreaterrelativeemphasisonsafeguardingprivacythandocourtsintheUnitedStates.Thus,thestandardnarrativepositsthattheUnitedStatesgivesanabsoluteprioritytospeech,overvindicationofprivacyint
7、er-ests,whereasEuropeanlawtendstodiscounttheimportanceof*JohnS.StoneChair,ProfessorofLaw,andDirectorofFacultyResearch,UniversityofAlabamaSchoolofLaw.WiththankstotheeditorsoftheWilliam&MaryLawReviewforinvitingmetoparticipateinthiswonderfulSymposium.ThisArticlereflectsthebenefitofveryhelpfulcom
8、mentsandsuggestionsofferedincidenttoworkshopshostedbythelawfacultiesattheUniversityofMiamiSchoolofLaw,theMichiganStateUniversityCollegeofLaw,andtheUniversityofWashingtonSchoolofLaw.ThanksalsototheUniversityofAlabamaLawSchoolFoundationforitsge