资源描述：
《耶鲁学堂个人总结》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在应用文档-天天文库。
1、WearenottheGod—Justice——ThefatmanisinnocentDearChris，Ireallyappreciateyourtimetoreadthislettersinceyouaresobusyeveryday.IwritethislettertotellyouthatthankyoueverymuchforyourhelpinYeleClassandIfeelsoluckytobeoneofyourstudents.IntheYeleClass,youcommunicatewithusinfourtopics--Justice,Intimatefriendsh
2、ip,Law,Happiness.Thewayyoutaughttousissointerestingandthevideosyouchooseforushaveagoodimpressiononus.Especially,onevideoimpressesmemostandinsomedegreepuzzlemeaftertheclass.ThereisoneopinionIhopetoletyouknow.Ithinkyoumustrememberourfirstquestionthatyouareadriverwhodriveatrainwhosebrakewasbrokenandt
3、hedirectionyoudrovewillkillfivepeople.Butthereisanotherwaywhosedirectionistokillonepeopleonly.Whichwaywillyouchoose?Truthfully,IoftenaskmyselfwhichwayIwillchooseandsometimesIevendreamofthis,andevennowIdon’tknowwhichonetochoose.Buttothesecondquestion,whenyouareaspectatorinabridgeandthere’safatmanst
4、andbesideyouandthebrokentrainwasrushingtokill5people,butifyoupushthefatmantothetrack,you’llsavethe5people.Whatwillyoudo?Myanswerisno,never.ThoughIdon’tamanwhobelieveinGoddeeply,Ibegyoutoletmeusethegodtoexplainmyexcuse.Inmyopinion,thefatmanisinnocent.Weshouldn’tsacrificeothersnomatterinwhichsituati
5、on.Mabye,insomedegree,Godwanttoseethe5peopleandneedtheirserviceinthatsituation.Asyouknowmaybeinothersituation,Godneedthefatmanbutnotthistime.AndwearenottheGod,wecan’tdecideothers’livesnomatterinwhichsituationandonmatterseekforwhatresult.Wehavenorighttosacrificethefatmantosavethefivepeople,becauseh
6、eisinnocentandtheGoddon’twanttoseehimnow.WhentheGodwanttoseehim?Godknowsonly.Ifsomeonepushthefatmanandisn’tpunishedbylaw,oursocietywillbeoutoforder.Becausetheywillthinkthere’sabetterresultforthemtosacrificeothers,buthowtoevaluatetheresult?Inwhatcriteriontojudgeabetterresult?Defferentpeoplehavediff
7、erentstandard.So,wearenottheGodandwecan’tdecideothers’livesnomatterinwhictsituation.SoIthinkthere’snostrictjusticeandseekingforbestresultisnotthecriticalstandard.Butifyouaskmewhatismyowenstandardtoshowjustice?Imu
