资源描述:
《to appear in linguistics and philosophy abstract the meaning of free choicenew》由会员上传分享,免费在线阅读,更多相关内容在教育资源-天天文库。
1、ToappearinLinguisticsandPhilosophyTheMeaningofFreeChoiceAnastasiaGiannakidouUniversityofGroningenApril2001AbstractInthispaper,Idiscussthedistributionandinterpretationoffreechoiceitems(FCIs)inGreek,alanguageexhibitingalexicalparadigmofsuchitemsdistinctfromthatofnegativepolarityitem
2、s.GreekdiffersinthisrespectfromEnglishwhichuniformlyemploysany.FCIsaregrammaticalonlyincertaincontextsthatcanbecharacterizedasnonveridical(Giannakidou1998,1999),andalthoughtheyyielduniversal-likeinterpretationsincertainstructures,theyarenot,Iargue,universalquantifiers.Evidencewill
3、beprovidedthatFCIsareindefinites;thequasi-universaleffectisshowntobetheresultofbindingbyanoperatorwithuniversalforce.Additionally,thelimiteddistributionofFCIsinnonveridicalcontextscanbeaccountedforbyanalyzingthemasindefiniteswhichmustalwaysbeinterpretedinanintensionaltype.Thediffe
4、rencebetweenÒregularÓindefinitesandFCIs,therefore,isreducedtoatypedifferencewhichcapturesthefactthatonlythelatterexhibitlimiteddistribution:becauseoftheirintensionaltype,FCIswillbegrammaticalonlyincontextsprovidingalternatives(worldsorsituations),andnonveridicalcontextsdoexactlyth
5、is.Bycontrast,FCIsareexcludedfromveridicalandepisodiccontextsbecausetheseprovidenoalternativesandhencedonotsatisfythelexicalsemanticrequirementofFCIs.Theproposedanalysisissupportedbydatafromotherlanguagesaswell(Spanish,Catalan,French)andhasimportantconsequencesregardingtheanalysis
6、ofEnglishany.IfFCIsarenotuniversalquantifiersbutindefinites,thentheusualambiguitythesis(freechoiceanybeinguniversal,negativepolarityanyanexistential)cannolongerbemaintained,atleastnotasoneintermsofquantificationalforce.1TheproblemoffreechoiceConsideralanguagelikeEnglishwhichposses
7、sesthenotoriousitemanyandemploysitinthetwocasesbelow:(1)aDidAriadnetalktoanybody?bAnybodycansolvethisproblem.Inthefirstsentenceanybodyseemstocontributeanexistentialquantifier,alikelyparaphraseof(1a)beingIsthereanx,suchthatxisapersonandAriadnetalkedtox?.Inthisinstance,1anybodyhasbe
8、encharacterizedasÔnegativeÕpolari