论文审稿意见模板

《论文审稿意见模板》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在应用文档-天天文库。

1、ReviewFormSectionI.GeneralInformationA.Overview1.ReaderInterest.Whichcategorydescribesthismanuscript?*Practice/Application/CaseStudy/ExperienceReportResearch/TechnologySurvey/Tutorial/How-To2.Howrelevantisthismanuscripttothereadersofthisperiodical?Please

2、explainyourrating.*VeryRelevantRelevantInteresting-butnotveryrelevantIrrelevantCommentB.Content1.Pleaseexplainhowthismanuscriptadvancesthisfieldofresearchand/orcontributessomethingnewtotheliterature.*2.Isthemanuscripttechnicallysound? Pleaseexplainyouran

3、swer.*YesAppearstobe-butdidn'tcheckcompletelyPartiallyNoCommentC.Presentation1.Arethetitle,abstract,andkeywordsappropriate? Pleasecomment.*YesNoComment2.Doesthemanuscriptcontainsufficientandappropriatereferences?Pleasecomment*Referencesaresufficientandap

4、propriateImportantreferencesaremissing;morereferencesareneededNumberofreferencesareexcessiveComment3.Doestheintroductionstatetheobjectivesofthemanuscriptintermsthatencouragethereadertoreadon? Pleaseexplainyouranswer*YesCouldbeimprovedNoComment4.Howwouldy

5、ouratetheorganizationofthemanuscript? Isitfocused? Isthelengthappropriateforthetopic? Pleasecomment.*SatisfactoryCouldbeimprovedPoorComment5.PleaserateandcommentonthereadabilityofthismanuscriptandqualityofEnglish.*EasytoreadReadable-butrequiressomeeffort

6、tounderstandDifficulttoreadandunderstandUnreadableCommentSectionII.SummaryandRecommendationA.EvaluationPleaseratethemanuscript. Explainyourchoice.*AwardQualityExcellentGoodFairPoorCommentB.RecommendationPleasemakeyourrecommendationandexplainyourdecision.

7、*AcceptwithnochangesAuthorshouldprepareaminorrevisionAuthorshouldprepareamajorrevisionforasecondreviewRejectCommentSectionIII.DetailedCommentsA.PublicComments(thesewillbemadeavailabletotheauthor)*B.ConfidentialComments(authorswillnotseethesecomments)*Top

8、ofFormBottomofForm*Denotesrequiredfield