资源描述：
《Is AIDS a just punishment.full》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在学术论文-天天文库。
1、Downloadedfromjme.bmj.comonMay11,2012-Publishedbygroup.bmj.comJ7oumalofmedicalethics,1988,14,154-160IsAIDSajustpunishment?TimothyFMurphyCenterforEducationalDevelopment,UniversityofIllinoisatChicago,USAAuthor'sabstractparitybetweencrimeandpunishmentthatthepunishmentnotionofAIDSisintellectuallyTherear
2、ereligiousandphilosophicalversionsofthethesisindefensibleandentirelycounterproductiveinthatAIDSisapunishmentforhomosexualbehaviour.attemptingtounderstandandcontrolthedisease.ItisarguedherethatthereligiousversionisseriouslyWrongfulbehaviourincomplete.BecauseofthisincompletenessandbecauseofBehaviouris
3、wrongfulwhenitisinappropriatetoortheindeterminaciesthatordinarilyattendreligiousincompatiblewithsomestipulatedgoalornorm.argumentation,itisconcludedthattheclaimmaybesetWrongfulbehaviourmaybetheresultofaccident,asideasunconvincing.Homosexualbehaviouristheninattention,inability,ordirectvolition.Notall
4、judgedforitsmoralityagainstutilitarian,deontological,wrongfulbehaviourconstitutesamoralwrong.Oneandnaturallawtheoriesofethics.Itisarguedthatsuchcan,forexample,bewronginthewayoneplaysagamebehaviourinvolvesnoimpedimenttoimportantmoralwithoutbeingmorallyculpable.Moralbehaviourgoalsandisnotthereforeimmo
5、ral.Wherenaturallawpertainstopersonsassuch,tothosegoalsandgoodsmightbeusedtocondemnhomosexualbehaviour,itisassociatedwiththedignityandworthofhumanlife.arguedthatthetheoryitselfisnotwellestablished.ImmoralbehaviouristhatwhichbreachestheConsequentlythereisaprimafaciereasonforrejectingthephilosophicalv
6、ersionofthepunishmentthesis.Thisprospectsforachievingthosegoalsandgoods.Inviewofthesedistinctions,notallwrongsareofconclusionisfurthersupportedbynotingthelackofequalevil.SomeactsareevilonlywithinthecontextofproportionbetweenthepurportedimmoralityofhomosexualityandapunishmentasdevastatingasAIDS.apart
7、icular,electivegoal.Thus,forexample,hockeyplayersaresenttothepenaltyboxandnottheelectricIfanymanliewithamanaswithawoman,bothhavechairfortheirinfractions.Neitherisanyonecommittedanabomination,letthembe
