资源描述：
《How-to-review-paper.pdf》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在学术论文-天天文库。
1、TheTaskoftheRefereeAlanJaySmithUniversityofCaliforniaatBerkeleyhereisanendlessstreamofgenerallyapplicable;separatesectionsTresearchpaperssubmittedtocon-considerresearchproposalsandsurveyferences,journals,newsletters,andtutorialpapers.Authorsmightfindanthologies,annuals,tradejournals,news-t
2、hismaterialusefulforpreparingpaperspapers,andotherperiodicals.ManysuchComputerforpublication.Anotherrecentpaperdis-publicationsuseimpartial,externalcussesrefereeingintheoreticalcomputerresearchershaveexpertstoevaluatepapers.Thisapproachsciences;therearesomedifferencesisoftencalledpeerrevie
3、w,andthebetweentheoryandtheappliedareascon-aprofessionalreviewersarecalledreferees.Refereeingsideredhere.isapublicservice,oneoftheprofessionalobligationobligationsofacomputerscienceandengineeringprofessional.Unfortunately,torefereetheworkTherefereestaskrefereestypicallylearntoproducerefere
4、eofothers.Thisreportswithoutanyformalinstruction;theylearnbypractice,byfeedbackfromYourroleasrefereeistodecidearticletellsyoueditors,byseeingrefereereportsfortheirwhetherapapermakesasufficientcon-ownpapers,andbyreadingrefereereportstributiontothefield.Thecontributionhowtoevaluateawrittenby
5、others.canbenewandinterestingresearchThisarticletellsyouhowtoevaluatearesults,anewandinsightfulsynthesisofpaperandwriteaexistingresults,ausefulsurveyoforpaper,writearefereereport,andapplytutorialonafield,oracombinationofreportusingcommonstandardsandprocedures.Itisthosetypes.Toquoteareferee
6、forthisintendedtoreplaceForschersrules,1article:commonwhicharedistributedbysomeeditorsbutdonotreflecttheproceduresusedincom-Smallresultswhicharesurprisingandmightstandardsandputerscienceandengineering.Thisarticlesparknewresearchshouldbepublished;procedures.focusesonresearchpapersinappliedp
7、aperswhicharemostlyrepetitionsofotherareasofcomputerscienceandengineer-papersshouldnot;paperswhichhavegoodideasbadlyexpressedshouldnotbepub-ing,suchassystems,architecture,hard-lishedbuttheauthorsshouldbeencouragedware,communications,andperformancetorewritethem
